Theological Topics

Twenty-one Latter-day Saint theological topics and scriptural understandings, set against the scholars whose published work bears on each. Colour shows how directly the work supports the topic.

Scholars appear here for their published work. No affiliation with the Foundation, and no endorsement of it or of Latter-day Saint teaching, is implied.

How many scholars touch each topic

Bars stack every scholar's strongest link to the topic. Each topic's fact cards are further down; for the questions people ask, see Common questions. For the background, read the essay Familiar Ground.

Topics against scholars

directsupportivetangentialno linkchecked quotationGold star: Spotlight, a reading recommendationPurple star: Advanced Spotlight, academic work for deeper study
Theological topics (columns) against scholars (rows); each square opens the works behind the link.
God and humanityCreation, Fall and atonementCovenant, faith and salvationTemple, priesthood and scriptureDeath and eternity
Scholar
1. Divine council1
2. The Godhead: distinct persons2
3. Embodied God3
4. Yahweh (Jehovah) as Christ4
5. Deification and exaltation5
6. Premortal existence6
7. Heavenly Mother7
8. Creation from existing matter8
9. The Fall, agency, no inherited guilt9
10. Atonement: participation and victory10
11. Gathering of Israel, adoption11
12. Law and works in Judaism and Paul12
13. Faith as covenant faithfulness13
14. Justification in the covenant14
15. Temple theology15
16. Priesthood and ordinances16
17. Apostasy and restoration17
18. Open canon, revelation18
19. Salvation of the dead19
20. Gradations of Glory20
21. Resurrection and new creation21
N. T. Wright
Michael J. Gorman
John M. G. Barclay
Jon D. Levenson
Benjamin D. Sommer
Jason A. Staples
Margaret Barker
John H. Walton
Mark S. Smith
Michael S. Heiser
E. P. Sanders
Matthew J. Thomas
Paula Fredriksen
Matthew Thiessen
Daniel Boyarin
Norman Russell
Jeffrey A. Trumbower
James L. Kugel
Brant Pitre
Madison N. Pierce
Teresa Morgan
Matthew W. Bates
Jacob Milgrom
David M. Moffitt
Crispin Fletcher-Louis
Scott W. Hahn
John N. Oswalt
James D. G. Dunn
Loren T. Stuckenbruck
Matthew V. Novenson
James F. McGrath
Bart D. Ehrman
Frank Moore Cross
Moshe Weinfeld
Isaac W. Oliver
John J. Collins
John Day
Grant Macaskill
Larry W. Hurtado
Andrei A. Orlov
Alan F. Segal
M. David Litwa
Christoph Markschies
Gerhard May
Richard E. DeMaris
George W. E. Nickelsburg
James H. Charlesworth
Gary A. Anderson
Rachel Elior
Lee Martin McDonald
Jaroslav Pelikan
William G. Dever
Francesca Stavrakopoulou
Saul M. Olyan
Krister Stendahl
Thomas Römer
Mark D. Nanos
Troels Engberg-Pedersen
Michael Patrick Barber
Géza Vermes
Jacob Neusner
Martin Hengel
Jürgen Moltmann
Raymond E. Brown
James C. VanderKam
Hindy Najman
Annette Yoshiko Reed
Amy-Jill Levine
Martha Himmelfarb
Caroline Johnson Hodge
Joshua D. Garroway
Lawrence H. Schiffman
Philip S. Alexander
Eyal Regev
Alexander Golitzin
Bogdan G. Bucur
Silviu N. Bunta
Kallistos Ware
Alexander Schmemann
Ilaria L. E. Ramelli
Sebastian P. Brock
Brittany E. Wilson
Richard B. Hays
J. Warren Smith
Hugo Méndez
Elaine Pagels
Karen L. King
Alister McGrath
G. K. Beale
Joel Marcus
Michael Fishbane
Bernard M. Levinson
L. Michael Morales
Paul R. Williamson
Mark J. Boda
David Winston
Ziony Zevit
Brian E. Daley
Gustaf Aulén
Nijay K. Gupta

Tap a square for the works, checked quotations and sources. A scholar's name opens their profile.

Fact cards by topic

God and humanity

1. Divine council · 5 fact cards
23 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 4 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
strong support

Five scholars read Deuteronomy 32:8–9 as nations allotted to divine sons

Following the older Dead Sea Scrolls and Greek text, these scholars read the passage as the Most High dividing the nations among divine beings and receiving Israel as Yahweh's portion; most treat this as an older Israelite view that later texts revised.

Mark S. SmithMatthew V. NovensonPaula FredriksenJohn J. CollinsJohn Day
The Origins of Biblical Monotheism (2001) - Mark S. Smith
The Universal Polytheism and the Case of the Jews (2020) - Matthew V. Novenson
How High Can Early High Christology Be? (2020) - Paula Fredriksen
Daniel (1993) - John J. Collins
Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan (2000) - John Day
strong support

Nine scholars read Psalm 82's 'gods' as a real heavenly council

These scholars read Psalm 82 as God presiding over an assembly of real divine beings, not human judges; Smith notes the psalm itself condemns the older view, and Heiser holds that God remains unique in kind. Hays reads the psalm's 'gods' as the nations' deities judged in the divine assembly. Alexander shows the rabbinic heavenly law court built on Psalm 82, 1 Kings 22 and Daniel 7.

Mark S. SmithMichael S. HeiserPaula FredriksenJohn DayLarry W. HurtadoJames L. KugelJohn J. CollinsRichard B. HaysPhilip S. Alexander
The Origins of Biblical Monotheism (2001) - Mark S. Smith
You've Seen One Elohim, You've Seen Them All? (2007) - Michael S. Heiser
How High Can Early High Christology Be? (2020) - Paula Fredriksen
Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan (2000) - John Day
Monotheism, Principal Angels, and the Background of Christology (2010) - Larry W. Hurtado
How to Read the Bible (2007) - James L. Kugel
Jewish Monotheism and Christian Theology (Aspects of Monotheism) - John J. Collins
Echoes of Scripture in the Gospels (2016) - Richard B. Hays
3 (Hebrew Apocalypse of) Enoch (1983) - Philip S. Alexander
strong support

Seven scholars: modern 'monotheism' misdescribes ancient Jewish and Christian belief

These scholars argue that ancient Jews, and on Fredriksen's and Novenson's reading Paul, accepted real lesser divine beings while worshipping one supreme God, whose supremacy all of them keep. Bunta argues early Jewish theology was neither monotheistic nor polytheistic: God's one divine selfhood is shared with 'gods' in varying degrees.

Paula FredriksenMatthew V. NovensonLarry W. HurtadoGrant MacaskillSaul M. OlyanJohn J. CollinsSilviu N. Bunta
Philo, Herod, Paul, and the Many Gods of Ancient Jewish 'Monotheism' (2022) - Paula Fredriksen
Did Paul Abandon either Judaism or Monotheism? (2020) - Matthew V. Novenson
One God, One Lord, 3rd ed., Epilogue (2015) - Larry W. Hurtado
The Entangled Enoch (2024) - Grant Macaskill
Is Isaiah 40–55 Really Monotheistic? (2012) - Saul M. Olyan
Jewish Monotheism and Christian Theology (Aspects of Monotheism) - John J. Collins
The Lord God of Gods (2021) - Silviu N. Bunta
moderate support

The Hebrew 'sod': God's council behind the New Testament 'mystery'

Brown argued that the New Testament's 'mystery' has a Semitic background including the Hebrew sod, which in some Old Testament passages means God's heavenly council, where the prophets were admitted.

Raymond E. Brown
The Semitic Background of the Term "Mystery" in the New Testament (1968) - Raymond E. Brown
moderate support

Zechariah 3: prophets stand in God's heavenly council

Boda reads the high priest Joshua's scene in Zechariah 3 as a heavenly-council court and argues that in the Hebrew Bible the council's human members are the prophets (Jer 23:18); he reads 3:7 as promising the temple a continuing line of prophets.

Mark J. Boda
Exploring Zechariah, Volume 2 (2017), ch. 4 - Mark J. Boda
2. The Godhead: Father, Son and Holy Spirit as distinct persons · 3 fact cards
11 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 3 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • The Son a distinct divine person beside the Father: 11 linked works
  • 'Two powers': a second divine figure beside God: 7 linked works
  • The Holy Spirit as a distinct person: 4 linked works
strong support'Two powers': a second divine figure beside God

Early belief in a second divine figure beside God ('two powers')

Segal shows that the early 'two powers' tradition read scripture as placing in heaven a principal figure equivalent to God, drawing on the human-like figure on the throne in Ezekiel 1 and Daniel 7 and the angel who bears God's name in Exodus 23. Boyarin argues the rabbis later branded an older, shared Jewish belief in a second divine power as heresy, and reads John's Logos against the Targums' Memra, a second divine figure distinct from God. Heiser finds a visible, human-form Yahweh ruling beside the invisible Yahweh in Israel's divine council. Barker argues pre-Christian Israel knew a High God and his sons, Yahweh among them.

Alan F. SegalDaniel BoyarinMichael S. HeiserMargaret Barker
Two Powers in Heaven (1977) - Alan F. Segal
Two Powers in Heaven; or, The Making of a Heresy (2004); The Gospel of the Memra (2001) - Daniel Boyarin
Co-regency in Ancient Israel's Divine Council (2016) - Michael S. Heiser
The Great Angel: A Study of Israel's Second God (1992) - Margaret Barker
strong supportThe Son a distinct divine person beside the Father

Father and Son as distinct persons in the earliest Christian writings

Hengel dates belief in the pre-existent Son, enthroned at God's right hand (Psalm 110:1), to the first two decades after the crucifixion. Fredriksen reads Paul's Christ as God's pre-existent agent in creation, distinct from the Father and subordinate to him; McGrath finds John presenting the Son as the agent God authorised, who bears his name and does his works. Vermes, and J. Warren Smith's history, record that thinkers before Nicaea, and many bishops after it, held the Son distinct from and subordinate to the Father. Bates and Pierce show New Testament writers hearing Old Testament texts as the Father and the Son addressing and answering each other. Fletcher-Louis distinguishes Father and Son as two divine persons within one divine identity; Moltmann starts theology from the three persons and their relations.

Martin HengelPaula FredriksenJames F. McGrathGéza VermesJ. Warren SmithMatthew W. BatesMadison N. PierceCrispin Fletcher-LouisJürgen Moltmann
The Son of God (1976); "Sit at My Right Hand!" (1995) - Martin Hengel
How High Can Early High Christology Be? (2020) - Paula Fredriksen
The Only True God (2009); John's Apologetic Christology (2001) - James F. McGrath
Christian Beginnings (2012) - Géza Vermes
Early Christian Theology: A History (2026) - J. Warren Smith
The Birth of the Trinity (2015) - Matthew W. Bates
Divine Discourse in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2020) - Madison N. Pierce
The Divine Heartset (2023) - Crispin Fletcher-Louis
The Trinity and the Kingdom (1980) - Jürgen Moltmann
moderate supportThe Holy Spirit as a distinct person

The Holy Spirit heard as a distinct speaker

Pierce shows Hebrews assigning its Scripture quotations to three distinct divine speakers: the Father addresses the Son, the Son answers the Father, and the Holy Spirit speaks to the church; she argues Hebrews 'has not merged' the Spirit with the Father. Bates finds the same Father, Son and Spirit dialogues in the New Testament and early Christian readers. Moltmann starts theology from the three persons, Spirit included, and their relations. Brock documents early Syriac writers who spoke of the Spirit as Mother, a personal figure.

Madison N. PierceMatthew W. BatesJürgen MoltmannSebastian P. Brock
Divine Discourse in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2020) - Madison N. Pierce
The Birth of the Trinity (2015) - Matthew W. Bates
The Trinity and the Kingdom (1980) - Jürgen Moltmann
The Holy Spirit as Feminine in Early Syriac Literature (1990) - Sebastian P. Brock
3. An embodied God · 4 fact cards
18 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 3 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • A God who feels and suffers: 4 linked works
  • Permanent embodiment: 4 linked works
  • Material spirit: nothing immaterial: 3 linked works
strong support

Six Hebrew Bible scholars find an embodied, human-shaped God in scripture

These scholars find that the biblical texts depict God with a body or in human form; Sommer holds that no biblical author believed in a bodiless God (though he describes 'fluid' multiple bodies), while Smith describes the depictions without arguing that God has a body. Bunta finds in the Psalter a divinity both physical and embodied.

Benjamin D. SommerFrancesca StavrakopoulouJames L. KugelJohn DayMark S. SmithSilviu N. Bunta
The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (2009) - Benjamin D. Sommer
God: An Anatomy (2021) - Francesca Stavrakopoulou
The God of Old (2003) - James L. Kugel
From Creation to Abraham (2022) - John Day
Where the Gods Are (2016) - Mark S. Smith
'The Divine Face as Theopoeia in the Psalter' (2025) - Silviu N. Bunta
strong support

Six scholars trace God's visible, human-like form beyond the Hebrew Bible

These scholars show that many early Christians believed God had a body (Markschies) and that Jewish visionary and mystical texts pictured God's Glory in human-like form, though Elior reads the Hekhalot measurements as metaphysical. Wilson finds Luke-Acts and the Synoptic Gospels portraying a perceptible, human-like God. Golitzin shows the 'anthropomorphite' monks of 399 carrying an ancient tradition of the Glory seen in human form, which he identifies with the Son. Neusner traces the rabbinic texts coming to portray God in bodily, personal terms.

Christoph MarkschiesRachel EliorAndrei A. OrlovBrittany E. WilsonAlexander GolitzinJacob Neusner
God's Body (2019) - Christoph Markschies
The Concept of God in Hekhalot Literature (1989) - Rachel Elior
Divine Manifestations in the Slavonic Pseudepigrapha (2009) - Andrei A. Orlov
The Embodied God (2021) - Brittany E. Wilson
The Form of God and Vision of the Glory (1998) - Alexander Golitzin
The Incarnation of God (1988) - Jacob Neusner
moderate supportA God who feels and suffers

Two scholars: God's impassibility came from philosophy, and theology has challenged it

Pelikan shows the Fathers took God's impassibility from philosophy as an axiom with little biblical support; Moltmann, a systematic theologian, argues that God suffers in the cross. Neither concerns God's body.

Jaroslav PelikanJürgen Moltmann
The Christian Tradition, vol. 1 (1971) - Jaroslav Pelikan
The Crucified God (1972) - Jürgen Moltmann
moderate supportMaterial spirit: nothing immaterial

Spirit as a refined substance, not something immaterial

Thiessen reads Paul's pneuma as the finest matter in the cosmos; Markschies documents Tertullian and other ancient writers who held the soul to be corporeal. Both are historical readings that parallel the teaching that all spirit is matter (D&C 131:7-8) without establishing it.

Matthew ThiessenChristoph Markschies
A Jewish Paul (2023) - Matthew Thiessen
God's Body (2019) - Christoph Markschies
4. Yahweh (Jehovah) as Christ · 1 fact card
6 scholars with a direct or supportive link. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
strong support

Early Christians read the LORD of the Old Testament as the Son

Bucur shows that early Christians read the Lord who appeared at Mamre, the burning bush, Sinai and Isaiah 6 as the Son himself, from Jude 5 through Justin, Irenaeus and Tertullian and across the first millennium. Barker argues the first Christians identified Jesus with Yahweh, a son of God Most High. Golitzin finds monks who kept an ancient tradition of the divine Glory seen in human form, which he identifies with the Second Person. The Fathers held that the Son appears because the Father is unseen.

Bogdan G. BucurMargaret BarkerAlexander Golitzin
Scripture Re-envisioned (2017) - Bogdan G. Bucur
The Great Angel (1992) - Margaret Barker
The Form of God and Vision of the Glory - Alexander Golitzin
5. Deification and exaltation · 5 fact cards
23 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 1 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • Eternal progression: 1 linked works
  • Eternal marriage and family: 2 linked works
strong support

Seven scholars of Paul read his salvation as becoming divine

These scholars argue that Paul taught transformation into Christ's divine image or sharing God's qualities such as immortality, which several call theosis or deification, though most frame it as participation by grace without fusion with God, not as Latter-day Saint exaltation. Engberg-Pedersen argues that for Paul the resurrected actually become heavenly beings. Michael Patrick Barber and Kincaid find a temple-based theosis in Paul.

Michael J. GormanCrispin Fletcher-LouisM. David LitwaMatthew ThiessenAlan F. SegalTroels Engberg-PedersenMichael Patrick Barber
Inhabiting the Cruciform God (2009) - Michael J. Gorman
The Divine Heartset (2023) - Crispin Fletcher-Louis
We Are Being Transformed (2012) - M. David Litwa
Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016) - Matthew Thiessen
Paul the Convert (1990) - Alan F. Segal
Cosmology and Self in the Apostle Paul (2010) - Troels Engberg-Pedersen
Cultic Theosis in Paul and Second Temple Judaism (2015, with John A. Kincaid) - Michael Patrick Barber
strong support

Historians: early Church Fathers taught that redeemed humans become 'gods'

These scholars trace deification from Justin, Irenaeus and Origen to Byzantium as a central account of salvation, defined by the Fathers as participation by grace rather than sharing God's essence. Ware presents deification as the goal of the Christian life in Orthodox teaching, by grace through God's energies. Brock shows it central to Ephrem the Syrian. J. Warren Smith sets out Gregory of Nyssa's endless growth into God, in which the soul never arrives.

Norman RussellKallistos WareSebastian P. BrockJ. Warren Smith
The Doctrine of Deification in the Greek Patristic Tradition (2004) - Norman Russell
Second- and Third-Century Greek Fathers, Oxford Handbook of Deification (2024) - Norman Russell
The Orthodox Church (1963; rev. 2015) - Kallistos Ware
The Luminous Eye (1985; rev. 1992) - Sebastian P. Brock
Passion and Paradise (2004) - J. Warren Smith
moderate support

Eight scholars find ancient Jewish texts that raise humans to divine status

These scholars document texts in which humans are enthroned in heaven, made angel-like or transformed in nature (the Qumran Self-Glorification Hymn, Enoch becoming Metatron), while noting these are mostly exceptional figures, not a general teaching. Alexander, who translated 3 Enoch, traces Enoch becoming a heavenly 'second god'. Bunta reads Moses, Daniel and Adam traditions as human deification. VanderKam argues 1 Enoch 71 identifies the man Enoch with the heavenly Son of Man. Himmelfarb shows the ascent ending with the righteous human transformed and given a place among the angels.

John J. CollinsGrant MacaskillCrispin Fletcher-LouisAndrei A. OrlovPhilip S. AlexanderSilviu N. BuntaJames C. VanderKamMartha Himmelfarb
A Throne in the Heavens: Apotheosis in Pre-Christian Judaism (1995) - John J. Collins
The Entangled Enoch (2024) - Grant Macaskill
All the Glory of Adam (2002) - Crispin Fletcher-Louis
The Enoch-Metatron Tradition (2005) - Andrei A. Orlov
From Son of Adam to Second God (1998) - Philip S. Alexander
The Lord God of Gods (2021) - Silviu N. Bunta
Righteous One, Messiah, Chosen One, and Son of Man in 1 Enoch 37-71 (1992) - James C. VanderKam
Ascent to Heaven in Jewish and Christian Apocalypses (1993) - Martha Himmelfarb
moderate support

A Johannine scholar argues John's Gospel is about humans becoming divine

Méndez argues that John's discourses come down to one claim: Christ came to transform humans into divine beings like himself. He reads this as the evangelist's theology, not Jesus' own teaching.

Hugo Méndez
The Gospel of John: A New History (2025) - Hugo Méndez
thin supportEternal marriage and family

Eternal marriage and family: one Orthodox theologian sees marriage outlasting death

Schmemann, an Orthodox liturgical theologian, reads the marriage vow in the light of the Kingdom: not until death parts the spouses but until death unites them for ever; this is not sealing. J. Warren Smith reads Gregory of Nyssa as keeping the risen body's sex, though it serves no purpose there, which cuts against marriage and increase. Litwa accurately describes Latter-day Saint exaltation as the deification of families, as a description, not a biblical argument.

Alexander SchmemannJ. Warren Smith
For the Life of the World (1963/1973) - Alexander Schmemann
The Body of Paradise and the Body of the Resurrection (2006) - J. Warren Smith
6. Premortal existence · 2 fact cards
1 scholar with a direct or supportive link, 3 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
thin support

Other premortal material: particular figures, not souls in general

Beyond Winston, the material is tangential, such as the Prayer of Joseph's preexistent Jacob (Schäfer), heavenly counterparts of patriarchs (Orlov) and descriptions of Origen's view (Fredriksen), and none of it amounts to a teaching of premortal souls in general. J. Warren Smith's history records Origen's teaching that minds lived with God before the world and fell. Pierce notes Hebrews' teaching of the Son's own pre-existence.

Andrei A. OrlovPaula FredriksenJ. Warren SmithMadison N. Pierce
The Greatest Mirror (2017) - Andrei A. Orlov
Sin: The Early History of an Idea (2012) - Paula Fredriksen
Early Christian Theology: A History (2026) - J. Warren Smith
Divine Discourse in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2020) - Madison N. Pierce
moderate support

Wisdom 8:19-20: souls that exist before the body

Winston, in his Anchor Bible commentary on the Wisdom of Solomon, holds that Wisdom 8:19-20 teaches souls that exist before the body and should not be explained away. In his 1978 essay for BYU's Religious Studies Center he adds that Philo pictures countless souls of differing spiritual grades, some of which enter bodies. He reads both as Hellenistic Jewish ideas, not as teachings he endorses.

David Winston
The Wisdom of Solomon (Anchor Bible 43, 1979) - David Winston
Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources (BYU RSC, 1978) - David Winston
7. Heavenly Mother · 2 fact cards
7 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 3 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
strong support

Five scholars: some ancient Israelites worshipped Asherah as Yahweh's consort

Citing inscriptions such as 'Yahweh and his Asherah', these scholars argue that Asherah was worshipped as Yahweh's consort before later reformers suppressed her, though the biblical writers condemned the practice and whether 'asherah' names a goddess or an object is still debated.

Thomas RömerWilliam G. DeverJohn DaySaul M. OlyanFrancesca Stavrakopoulou
The Invention of God (2015) - Thomas Römer
Did God Have a Wife? (2005) - William G. Dever
Yahweh and the Gods and Goddesses of Canaan (2000) - John Day
Asherah and the Cult of Yahweh in Israel (1988) - Saul M. Olyan
God: An Anatomy (2021) - Francesca Stavrakopoulou
moderate support

Five scholars trace a suppressed divine feminine into Wisdom and Spirit

Barker reconstructs a divine Lady, Wisdom, in the First Temple whom she calls the Heavenly Mother, Römer sees the goddess resurfacing as Wisdom in Proverbs 8, and DeConick finds a remembered Mother Spirit, a figure that is not a consort of the Father. Pagels finds early Christian texts picturing God as Father and Mother, or the Mother as the Spirit or Wisdom. Brock shows early Syriac writers using feminine language for the Spirit, a few calling it Mother. King's text has Barbelo as the Mother in a Father-Mother-Son triad.

Margaret BarkerThomas RömerElaine PagelsSebastian P. BrockKaren L. King
The Mother of the Lord, Vol. 1 (2012) - Margaret Barker
Yhwh, the Goddess and Evil (2013) - Thomas Römer
'What Became of God the Mother?' (Signs, 1976) - Elaine Pagels
The Holy Spirit as Feminine in Early Syriac Literature (1990) - Sebastian P. Brock
The Secret Revelation of John (2006) - Karen L. King

Creation, Fall and atonement

8. Creation from pre-existing matter · 2 fact cards
7 scholars with a direct or supportive link. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
strong support

Four scholars: Genesis 1 orders existing chaos, not creation from nothing

These scholars read Genesis 1 as God ordering or mastering material already present; Walton nonetheless affirms creation from nothing on other grounds, Smith's view is reported from reviews, and biblical chaos is not the same as eternal matter.

Jon D. LevensonPaula FredriksenJohn H. WaltonMark S. Smith
Creation and the Persistence of Evil (1988) - Jon D. Levenson
How High Can Early High Christology Be? (2020) - Paula Fredriksen
The Lost World of Genesis One (2009) - John H. Walton
The Priestly Vision of Genesis 1 (2009) - Mark S. Smith
strong support

Creation from nothing became explicit Christian teaching only in the second century

May identifies Tatian (c. 170s) as the first Christian to say expressly that God made matter, and Fredriksen ties the teaching to second-century controversies, though May regarded it as a legitimate development and Gary Anderson defends it. Winston argues that Wisdom 11:17's 'formless matter' is eternal matter God shaped, and that creation from nothing first appears explicitly in second-century Christian writers.

Gerhard MayPaula FredriksenJon D. LevensonDavid Winston
Creatio ex Nihilo (1994) - Gerhard May
How High Can Early High Christology Be? (2020) - Paula Fredriksen
Creation and the Persistence of Evil (1988) - Jon D. Levenson
The Book of Wisdom's Theory of Cosmogony (1971); Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources (1978) - David Winston
9. The Fall, agency and no inherited guilt · 2 fact cards
8 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 1 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
Distinctive against Protestant teaching; Orthodox and largely Catholic teaching hold versions of it.
moderate support

Before Augustine, the Fall was not read as inherited guilt

Pagels argues that earlier Christian writers (Justin, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Clement) held that Adam's sin did not take away each person's freedom to choose, and that Augustine's reading of Genesis moved the West toward inherited sin; specialists dispute how new Augustine's view was. Anderson shows early readers took Adam and Eve's 'garments of skin' as the mortal flesh they put on after the transgression. Smith's history records Irenaeus's view that humans were made unfinished and meant to grow. Meyendorff (not featured) documents the Greek reading of Romans 5:12 as an inheritance of mortality rather than of guilt. Ware writes, as the Orthodox position, that people 'inherit Adam's corruption and mortality, but not his guilt'. Fredriksen documents that Augustine set out to explain how God was just to punish all later generations for one man's sin, leaning on often poor Latin translations. Zevit reads Genesis 2-3 as a story of humans rising into moral discernment and dates the idea of original sin to Second Temple-era interpretation; he does not affirm a Fall.

Elaine PagelsGary A. AndersonJ. Warren SmithKallistos WarePaula FredriksenZiony Zevit
Adam, Eve, and the Serpent (1988) - Elaine Pagels
The Genesis of Perfection (2001) - Gary A. Anderson
Early Christian Theology: A History (2026), ch. 3 - J. Warren Smith
The Orthodox Church (1963; rev. 1993) - Kallistos Ware
Sin: The Early History of an Idea (2012) - Paula Fredriksen
John Meyendorff, Byzantine Theology (1974), ch. 11 'Original Sin' (cited, not featured)
What Really Happened in the Garden of Eden? (2013) - Ziony Zevit
moderate support

Genesis 3 as choice and consequence, not a fall into inherited guilt

Smith finds that 'The Fall is actually quite rare in Scripture': Genesis 3 tells of consequences, and scholars now read it as a story of human development. Brock shows that for Ephrem the commandment was given so that Adam and Eve could exercise their free will, with the Tree of Life as the reward for obedience. Walton argues that people are subject to sin and death because of the disorder in the world, not because Adam's sin is passed on biologically.

Mark S. SmithSebastian P. BrockJohn H. Walton
The Genesis of Good and Evil (2019) - Mark S. Smith
'The Robe of Glory', The Way 39 (1999) - Sebastian P. Brock
The Lost World of Adam and Eve (2015) - John H. Walton
10. Atonement as participation, victory and enabling power · 2 fact cards
9 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 1 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
Distinctive against Protestant teaching; Orthodox and largely Catholic teaching hold versions of it.
moderate support

Atonement through Christ's death and risen life, shared by believers

Gorman argues that Paul's justification is 'justification by co-crucifixion', a participatory transformation, and that believers die and rise with Christ now; Morgan reads life 'in Christ' as the present side of eternal life. Pitre, Barber and Kincaid read grace as enabling the works that follow. Moffitt argues that in Hebrews atonement is accomplished through the risen Jesus's bodily self-offering in the heavenly sanctuary.

Michael J. GormanTeresa MorganBrant PitreDavid M. Moffitt
Inhabiting the Cruciform God (2009); Participating in Christ (2019) - Michael J. Gorman
Being 'in Christ' in the Letters of Paul (2020) - Teresa Morgan
Paul, a New Covenant Jew (2019) - Brant Pitre
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2011) - David M. Moffitt
moderate support

Victory over the powers, a new covenant shared, and grace that empowers

Wright argues that the cross defeats the powers through the forgiveness of sins and restores humans to their vocation as royal priests. Gorman proposes a new-covenant model: the cross establishes the covenant and the church participates in it. Moffitt argues that atonement includes the resurrection and ascension, and reads Jesus's death in Hebrews as the defeat of the devil. Barclay counts efficacy, a gift that empowers its recipient, among the ways Paul's grace was understood; Engberg-Pedersen, Thiessen and Fredriksen argue that the spirit given to believers enables the life that follows. None of them uses the phrase 'enabling power'. Aulén argued that the early church saw Christ's work first as God's victory over sin, death and the devil, the typology Latter-day Saint writers on the atonement cite.

N. T. WrightMichael J. GormanDavid M. MoffittJohn M. G. BarclayTroels Engberg-PedersenMatthew ThiessenPaula FredriksenGustaf Aulén
The Day the Revolution Began (2016) - N. T. Wright
The Death of the Messiah and the Birth of the New Covenant (2014) - Michael J. Gorman
Rethinking the Atonement (2022) - David M. Moffitt
Paul and the Gift (2015) - John M. G. Barclay
Cosmology and Self in the Apostle Paul (2010) - Troels Engberg-Pedersen
A Jewish Paul (2023) - Matthew Thiessen
Paul's Letter to the Romans, the Ten Commandments, and Pagan 'Justification by Faith' (JBL, 2014) - Paula Fredriksen
Christus Victor (1931) - Gustaf Aulén

Covenant, faith and salvation

11. The gathering of Israel and adoption into the covenant · 5 fact cards
18 scholars with a direct or supportive link. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • Gathering and restoration of all Israel: 9 linked works
  • Adoption into Israel and Abraham's family: 7 linked works
  • Israel not replaced: 7 linked works
strong support

Eight scholars stress hopes for restoring all Israel, including lost tribes

These scholars show that a twelve-tribe restoration hope persisted in Second Temple Judaism, Paul and Luke-Acts (Staples, Oliver, Thiessen), that resurrection was tied to Israel's restoration (Levenson), and that 4 Ezra 13 pictures the Messiah gathering the ten tribes (Charlesworth); none argue for a latter-day gathering. Pitre argues Jesus sought the ingathering of all twelve tribes, the lost ten included. Nanos reads Romans 11:26 as all Israel 'kept safe'. Levine reads 'all Israel' as the Jewish people, whose calling Paul calls irrevocable.

Jason A. StaplesIsaac W. OliverMatthew ThiessenJon D. LevensonJames H. CharlesworthBrant PitreMark D. NanosAmy-Jill Levine
The Idea of Israel in Second Temple Judaism (2021) - Jason A. Staples
Luke's Jewish Eschatology (2021) - Isaac W. Oliver
Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016) - Matthew Thiessen
Resurrection and the Restoration of Israel (2006) - Jon D. Levenson
Messianism in the Pseudepigrapha and the Book of Mormon (1978) - James H. Charlesworth
Jesus, the Tribulation, and the End of the Exile (2005) - Brant Pitre
Paul – Why Bother? (2019) - Mark D. Nanos
Supersessionism: Admit and Address (2022) - Amy-Jill Levine
strong support

Seven scholars read salvation as covenant belonging, not only legal acquittal

These scholars argue that Paul's justification concerns who belongs to God's covenant people (Stendahl, Wright) and that covenant creates a real family bond with God (Hahn) mediated by the Messiah (Macaskill). Hodge shows gentiles in Christ becoming Abraham's descendants and heirs by kinship. Garroway argues that Paul taught baptised gentiles become Abraham's descendants. Nanos reads gentiles as joining Israel's God as gentiles.

Krister StendahlN. T. WrightScott W. HahnGrant MacaskillCaroline Johnson HodgeJoshua D. GarrowayMark D. Nanos
The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West (1963) - Krister Stendahl
Justification (2009) - N. T. Wright
Kinship by Covenant (2009) - Scott W. Hahn
Union with Christ in the New Testament (2013) - Grant Macaskill
If Sons, Then Heirs (2007) - Caroline Johnson Hodge
Paul's Gentile-Jews (2012) - Joshua D. Garroway
The Mystery of Romans (1996) - Mark D. Nanos
moderate support

Two covenants with Abraham: a nation, and blessing for all nations

Williamson argues that Genesis 15 ratifies the promise that Abraham will become a great nation, while Genesis 17 and 22 develop the blessing of all nations through a royal seed. Noel B. Reynolds builds his Book of Mormon reading of the Abrahamic covenant on this (BYU Studies Quarterly 57.3, 2018).

Paul R. Williamson
Abraham, Israel and the Nations (2000); Sealed with an Oath (2007) - Paul R. Williamson
strong supportAdoption into Israel and Abraham's family

Gentiles adopted into Abraham's family

Johnson Hodge shows Paul using descent and adoption language so that gentiles baptized into Christ become real descendants of Abraham; Garroway argues that for Paul such gentiles have acquired descent from Abraham 'according to the flesh'; Thiessen that gentiles become Abraham's seed by receiving Christ's pneuma; Staples that restoring Israel meant bringing gentiles in. Hahn reads covenant as a real family bond. Most hold the adopted remain distinct from ethnic Israel in some way.

Caroline Johnson HodgeJoshua D. GarrowayMatthew ThiessenJason A. StaplesScott W. Hahn
If Sons, Then Heirs (2007) - Caroline Johnson Hodge
Paul's Gentile-Jews (2012) - Joshua D. Garroway
Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016) - Matthew Thiessen
Paul and the Resurrection of Israel (2023) - Jason A. Staples
Kinship by Covenant (2009) - Scott W. Hahn
moderate supportGathering and restoration of all Israel

James 1:1: Gentile converts as the lost tribes

Marcus argues that James addresses Gentiles who accept the gospel as the Ten Lost Tribes, whose Israelite identity was lost in the Diaspora and reawakened by the gospel, so that restored Israel includes them. This is his reading of what James means, not his own endorsement. Fishbane reads Isaiah 56 and 66 as opening the Temple and its service to foreigners who hold to the covenant.

Joel MarcusMichael Fishbane
'The Twelve Tribes in the Diaspora' (James 1.1), NTS 60.4 (2014) - Joel Marcus
The JPS Bible Commentary: Haftarot (2002) - Michael Fishbane
12. Law and works in Judaism and in Paul · 1 fact card
10 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 1 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • Covenantal nomism: 3 linked works
  • 'Works of the law' as Mosaic boundary markers: 6 linked works
strong support

Judaism was not a religion of earning salvation; 'works of the law' meant Mosaic observances

Sanders showed that Second Temple Judaism was 'covenantal nomism': Israel entered the covenant by God's gracious election and stayed in by obedience. Dunn argues Paul's 'works of the law' were Torah markers such as circumcision and food laws that kept gentiles out, not good works as such; Thomas finds every second-century writer he examined read them that way, and McGrath that early writers generally did. Levine faults portraits of Judaism as burdensome law; Barclay shows grace that asks a response.

E. P. SandersJames D. G. DunnMatthew J. ThomasAlister McGrathAmy-Jill LevineMark D. NanosJohn M. G. Barclay
Paul and Palestinian Judaism (1977) - E. P. Sanders
The New Perspective on Paul (2005) - James D. G. Dunn
Paul's Works of the Law in the Perspective of Second-Century Reception (2018) - Matthew J. Thomas
Iustitia Dei, 4th ed. (2020) - Alister McGrath
The Misunderstood Jew (2006) - Amy-Jill Levine
The Irony of Galatians (2002) - Mark D. Nanos
Paul and the Gift (2015) - John M. G. Barclay
13. Faith as covenant faithfulness (pistis: allegiance, loyalty, trust) · 2 fact cards
8 scholars with a direct or supportive link. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
Distinctive against Protestant teaching; Orthodox and largely Catholic teaching hold versions of it.
strong support

Pistis meant trust, faithfulness and allegiance, not only belief

Morgan shows that in Graeco-Roman, Jewish and early Christian usage pistis was chiefly relational trust and faithfulness, and that belief overtook trust only gradually. Bates argues saving pistis is allegiance to Jesus as king, expressed in embodied loyalty. Hays reads Paul's gospel as resting on Christ's own faithful obedience.

Teresa MorganMatthew W. BatesRichard B. Hays
Roman Faith and Christian Faith (2015) - Teresa Morgan
Salvation by Allegiance Alone (2017) - Matthew W. Bates
The Faith of Jesus Christ (1983; 2002) - Richard B. Hays
moderate support

Faith as loyalty inside a covenant or gift relationship

Fredriksen argues that in Paul's day pistis meant conviction, steadfastness and loyalty, not belief. Levenson argues that loving God in Deuteronomy is first a covenant duty of loyalty: God's gift answered with gratitude and faithfulness (a reading that goes back to William L. Moran, 1963). Barclay shows that ancient gifts looked for a return, and that Paul's grace, given without regard to worth, still transforms those who receive it. Gorman reads Paul's faith as obedience shaped by Christ's own faithfulness. Gupta, building on Morgan, reads Paul's pistis as active covenant loyalty ('covenantal pistism'), not passive reliance.

Paula FredriksenJon D. LevensonJohn M. G. BarclayMichael J. GormanNijay K. Gupta
Paul's Letter to the Romans, the Ten Commandments, and Pagan 'Justification by Faith' (JBL, 2014) - Paula Fredriksen
The Love of God (2016) - Jon D. Levenson
Paul and the Gift (2015) - John M. G. Barclay
Cruciformity (2001) - Michael J. Gorman
Paul and the Language of Faith (2020) - Nijay K. Gupta
14. Justification in the covenant, not by faith alone · 2 fact cards
9 scholars with a direct or supportive link. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • Covenant membership: 1 linked works
  • Baptism as its sign and entry: 1 linked works
  • Made righteous, not only declared: 5 linked works
  • Judgment according to works: 4 linked works
Distinctive against Protestant teaching; Orthodox and largely Catholic teaching hold versions of it.
strong support

Seven scholars read salvation as covenant belonging, not only legal acquittal

These scholars argue that Paul's justification concerns who belongs to God's covenant people (Stendahl, Wright) and that covenant creates a real family bond with God (Hahn) mediated by the Messiah (Macaskill). Hodge shows gentiles in Christ becoming Abraham's descendants and heirs by kinship. Garroway argues that Paul taught baptised gentiles become Abraham's descendants. Nanos reads gentiles as joining Israel's God as gentiles.

Krister StendahlN. T. WrightScott W. HahnGrant MacaskillCaroline Johnson HodgeJoshua D. GarrowayMark D. Nanos
The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West (1963) - Krister Stendahl
Justification (2009) - N. T. Wright
Kinship by Covenant (2009) - Scott W. Hahn
Union with Christ in the New Testament (2013) - Grant Macaskill
If Sons, Then Heirs (2007) - Caroline Johnson Hodge
Paul's Gentile-Jews (2012) - Joshua D. Garroway
The Mystery of Romans (1996) - Mark D. Nanos
strong support

Justification as being made righteous, with judgment by the life lived

Wright argues justification declares who belongs to the covenant family, while final judgment accords with the whole life lived; Dunn and Thomas also hold judgment according to works. Gorman argues justification is a participatory transformation, and Pitre and his co-authors that it is both verdict and real change. McGrath shows the Greek Fathers, Augustine and the medieval West understood justification as making the believer righteous; on his account the purely forensic reading came with the Reformation.

N. T. WrightJames D. G. DunnMatthew J. ThomasMichael J. GormanBrant PitreAlister McGrathMatthew W. Bates
Justification: God's Plan and Paul's Vision (2009) - N. T. Wright
The New Perspective on Paul (2005) - James D. G. Dunn
Inhabiting the Cruciform God (2009) - Michael J. Gorman
Paul, a New Covenant Jew (2019) - Brant Pitre
Iustitia Dei, 4th ed. (2020) - Alister McGrath
Salvation by Allegiance Alone (2017) - Matthew W. Bates

Temple, priesthood and scripture

15. Temple theology · 6 fact cards
31 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 2 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
strong support

Nine scholars link Israel's temple to the creation of the cosmos

These scholars read the temple or tabernacle as a model of the cosmos and Genesis 1 as God building a cosmic temple, with the temple as the place where heaven and earth meet. Pitre shows Second Temple Jews saw the Temple as a small copy of heaven and earth. Morales argues the tabernacle is a portable Sinai, a cosmic mountain, and the way back to Eden. Beale argues that Eden was the first sanctuary and that the temple pictured God's presence one day filling the cosmos.

Jon D. LevensonJohn H. WaltonMark S. SmithFrank Moore CrossGary A. AndersonN. T. WrightBrant PitreL. Michael MoralesG. K. Beale
The Temple and the World (1984) - Jon D. Levenson
The Lost World of Genesis One (2009) - John H. Walton
The Priestly Vision of Genesis 1 (2009) - Mark S. Smith
The Priestly Tabernacle in the Light of Recent Research (1984) - Frank Moore Cross
That I May Dwell Among Them (2023) - Gary A. Anderson
History and Eschatology (2019) - N. T. Wright
Jesus, the New Temple, and the New Priesthood (2008) - Brant Pitre
The Tabernacle Pre-Figured (2012); Who Shall Ascend the Mountain of the Lord? (2015) - L. Michael Morales
The Temple and the Church's Mission (2004) - G. K. Beale
strong support

Nine scholars trace ascent into a heavenly temple in ancient texts

These scholars show that Jewish and early Christian texts pictured seers, priests and the risen Christ entering God's heavenly sanctuary; they describe literary and ritual traditions, not an ancient endowment, and Elior's account of origins is disputed. Himmelfarb shows the ascent apocalypses picturing heaven as a temple. Alexander reads the Qumran Sabbath songs as worshippers joining the angels in the heavenly temple.

Andrei A. OrlovGeorge W. E. NickelsburgCrispin Fletcher-LouisRachel EliorMargaret BarkerAlan F. SegalDavid M. MoffittMartha HimmelfarbPhilip S. Alexander
The Enoch-Metatron Tradition (2005) - Andrei A. Orlov
The Temple According to 1 Enoch (2014) - George W. E. Nickelsburg
Heavenly Ascent and Incarnational Presence? (1998) - Crispin Fletcher-Louis
The Three Temples (2004) - Rachel Elior
The Great High Priest (2003) - Margaret Barker
Heavenly Ascent in Hellenistic Judaism (1980) - Alan F. Segal
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in Hebrews (2011) - David M. Moffitt
Ascent to Heaven in Jewish and Christian Apocalypses (1993) - Martha Himmelfarb
The Mystical Texts (2006) - Philip S. Alexander
moderate support

Ancient traditions tied priestly vesting and the veil to God's presence

These scholars find Adam and Eve pictured as vested priests (Anderson), a heavenly high priest behind the veil (Orlov, Barker) and sacraments mapped onto holier temple spaces (DeConick, in a Valentinian text); these are parallels, not proof of continuity with Latter-day Saint rites. Himmelfarb reads Enoch's anointing and clothing in 2 Enoch 22 as a heavenly priestly investiture. Brock traces the Syriac robe of glory, lost at the Fall and restored in baptism. Alexander reads the heavenly curtain of 3 Enoch 45 as the counterpart of the Temple veil. King reads that text's 'five seals' as a baptismal sealing that secures the soul's ascent.

Gary A. AndersonAndrei A. OrlovMargaret BarkerMartha HimmelfarbSebastian P. BrockPhilip S. AlexanderKaren L. King
The Genesis of Perfection (2001) - Gary A. Anderson
The Enoch-Metatron Tradition (2005) - Andrei A. Orlov
The Great High Priest (2003) - Margaret Barker
Ascent to Heaven in Jewish and Christian Apocalypses (1993) - Martha Himmelfarb
The Robe of Glory (1999) - Sebastian P. Brock
3 (Hebrew Apocalypse of) Enoch (1983) - Philip S. Alexander
The Secret Revelation of John (2006) - Karen L. King
moderate support

Two scholars: Jesus and the New Testament writers did not reject the Temple

Michael Patrick Barber argues the historical Jesus took part in and endorsed the Temple's rites even while predicting its destruction; Regev finds that passages long read as anti-Temple are not, with Hebrews the most critical.

Michael Patrick BarberEyal Regev
The Historical Jesus and the Temple (2023) - Michael Patrick Barber
The Temple in Early Christianity (2019) - Eyal Regev
moderate support

Two scholars: the earthly temple as the image of a heavenly or God-built one

Schiffman shows the Temple Scroll looking to a temple God will create at the End of Days, with concentric zones of holiness; Bunta reads Ezekiel's divine glory as itself the sanctuary, the earthly temple embodying the heavenly one.

Lawrence H. SchiffmanSilviu N. Bunta
Reclaiming the Dead Sea Scrolls (1994) - Lawrence H. Schiffman
'In Heaven or on Earth' (2010) - Silviu N. Bunta
moderate support

Two scholars: Christian worship and monastic prayer as entry into the heavenly sanctuary

Schmemann reads the liturgy's entrance, with Hebrews 9:24, as the Church ascending into Christ's heavenly sanctuary; Golitzin shows the ascent and throne-vision motifs of the Jewish apocalypses continuing, turned inward, in Eastern monastic writers. Both describe Orthodox worship and ascetic practice, not an ancient endowment.

Alexander SchmemannAlexander Golitzin
The Eucharist: Sacrament of the Kingdom (1987) - Alexander Schmemann
Earthly Angels and Heavenly Men (2001) - Alexander Golitzin
16. Priesthood, Melchizedek, ordinances · 6 fact cards
15 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 4 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
moderate support

Three scholars highlight a Melchizedek priesthood older than Aaron's

Fletcher-Louis argues Jesus saw himself as a Melchizedek priest, Barker that early Christians did, and Orlov that 2 Enoch traces a Melchizedek line from Methuselah; all concern Christ's or ancient priesthood, not ordination today.

Crispin Fletcher-LouisMargaret BarkerAndrei A. Orlov
Jesus as the High Priestly Messiah: Part 1 (2006) - Crispin Fletcher-Louis
The Great High Priest (2003) - Margaret Barker
Melchizedek Legend of 2 (Slavonic) Enoch (2000) - Andrei A. Orlov
moderate support

A Catholic scholar argues Israel's priesthood was reassigned after the golden calf

Hahn argues that a family priesthood in Melchizedek's pattern passed to the Levites after the golden calf, and with Bergsma reads Ezekiel 20:25 as a lesser law given to a rebellious generation, close parallels to D&C 84 that he applies to Catholic priesthood.

Scott W. Hahn
What Laws Were 'Not Good'? (2004, with John S. Bergsma) - Scott W. Hahn
The Meal of Melchizedek (talk) - Scott W. Hahn
thin support

Saving ordinances and priesthood authority: little direct scholarly support

Bates ties baptism to salvation when it is joined to repentance and allegiance, but no reviewed scholar argues for priesthood authority or ordinances as required saving covenants.

Matthew W. Bates
Beyond the Salvation Wars (2025) - Matthew W. Bates
moderate support

Three scholars: priesthood comes by call, and Jesus gave it an ordered form

Pierce reads Hebrews 5:4 as a rule that the high priesthood comes by God's call, never self-taken; Pitre argues Jesus organised his disciples on Sinai's priestly pattern (the Twelve and the Seventy); Michael Patrick Barber reads Peter's keys as a priestly steward's office. Each concerns Christ and the first disciples, and Pitre and Barber draw Catholic conclusions about succession.

Madison N. PierceBrant PitreMichael Patrick Barber
Divine Discourse in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2020) - Madison N. Pierce
Jesus, the New Temple, and the New Priesthood (2008) - Brant Pitre
Jesus as the Davidic Temple Builder and Peter's Priestly Role in Matthew 16:16-19 (2013) - Michael Patrick Barber
moderate support

Three scholars: early baptism and anointing as real, effective rites of entry

Schmemann treats baptism and chrismation as effective acts of entry into Christ; Brock traces the Syriac invocations of the Spirit over water and oil and the shift in when the anointing came; Garroway argues that for Paul baptism is the rite that makes gentiles Abraham's descendants. None argues that priesthood authority is required for the rite; Schmemann's anointing is every Christian's share in Christ's priesthood, not ordination.

Alexander SchmemannSebastian P. BrockJoshua D. Garroway
Of Water and the Spirit (1974) - Alexander Schmemann
The Holy Spirit in the Syrian Baptismal Tradition (1979) - Sebastian P. Brock
Paul's Gentile-Jews (2012) - Joshua D. Garroway
moderate support

The high priest's entry and investiture as the way into God's presence

Morales argues that the high priest entering beyond the veil on the Day of Atonement portrays Adam returning to the presence lost in Eden. Boda reads Joshua's re-clothing in Zechariah 3 as the high priest's investiture and atonement ritual.

L. Michael MoralesMark J. Boda
The Tabernacle: Mountain of God in the Cultus of Israel (2014; Interpreter 37, 2020) - L. Michael Morales
Exploring Zechariah, Volume 2 (2017), ch. 4 - Mark J. Boda
17. Apostasy and restoration · 3 fact cards
18 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 4 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
strong support

Five scholars date belief in a bodiless God after the Bible

Markschies and Stavrakopoulou trace the bodiless God to Platonist philosophy and later theology, and Sommer calls it a later development than the Bible; none frames this as an apostasy. Golitzin argues the post-Nicene settlement turned the older Christology of the visible divine body into an anachronism. Bucur shows Augustine recasting the Old Testament appearances as created signs, a view that became normative in the Latin West.

Christoph MarkschiesFrancesca StavrakopoulouBenjamin D. SommerAlexander GolitzinBogdan G. Bucur
God's Body (2019) - Christoph Markschies
God: An Anatomy (2021) - Francesca Stavrakopoulou
The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (2009) - Benjamin D. Sommer
The Demons Suggest an Illusion of God's Glory in a Form (2007) - Alexander Golitzin
Christological Exegesis of Theophanies (2022) - Bogdan G. Bucur
moderate support

Nine scholars document how early Christian teaching shifted after the apostles

These scholars trace specific changes (faith from trust to creed, a Platonised hope of heaven, Augustine narrowing hope for the dead, the West losing deification's centrality, later lines drawn around heresy), each as development rather than general apostasy, and Wright affirms the creeds. Brown shows the churches coping in different ways after the apostles died, and finds limits to the idea of bishops as the apostles' successors. Vermes treats Nicaea as a departure from earlier Christian thought. Pagels traces Augustine moving the church from free will to inherited sin. Reed documents Enochic writings early Christians used being set aside.

Teresa MorganN. T. WrightJeffrey A. TrumbowerJames F. McGrathDaniel BoyarinRaymond E. BrownGéza VermesElaine PagelsAnnette Yoshiko Reed
Two Aspects of Early Christian Faith (2021) - Teresa Morgan
Surprised by Hope (2008) - N. T. Wright
Rescue for the Dead (2001) - Jeffrey A. Trumbower
The Only True God (2009) - James F. McGrath
Border Lines (2004) - Daniel Boyarin
The Churches the Apostles Left Behind (1984) - Raymond E. Brown
Christian Beginnings (2012) - Géza Vermes
Adam, Eve, and the Serpent (1988) - Elaine Pagels
Fallen Angels and the History of Judaism and Christianity (2005) - Annette Yoshiko Reed
moderate support

Two scholars find older Israelite teachings deliberately removed by later reformers

Barker argues Josiah's reform suppressed older temple teaching, Angelini that scribes erased the heavenly council from Deuteronomy 32, and Olyan that Deuteronomistic reformers suppressed Asherah; these are pre-Christian losses, not a Christian apostasy.

Margaret BarkerSaul M. Olyan
The Older Testament (1987) - Margaret Barker
Asherah and the Cult of Yahweh in Israel (1988) - Saul M. Olyan
18. Open canon and continuing revelation · 5 fact cards
17 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 2 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
strong support

Ten scholars: ancient scripture's boundaries were wider and later fixed

These scholars show that writings such as 1 Enoch were treated as authoritative, that the New Testament list settled only in the 4th to 6th centuries, and (Barker) that Judah around 600 BCE had no closed canon; this is history of the canon, not an argument for adding scripture today. VanderKam shows authoritative writings at Qumran were recognisable but not fixed. Najman shows Jubilees and the Temple Scroll claiming Torah authority before the canon was fixed. Reed shows early Christians using the Book of the Watchers as authoritative. Hengel finds the early Christian Old Testament loosely bounded. Pagels shows other early prophets' visions left out of the canon.

Lee Martin McDonaldLoren T. StuckenbruckGeorge W. E. NickelsburgJames H. CharlesworthMargaret BarkerJames C. VanderKamHindy NajmanAnnette Yoshiko ReedMartin HengelElaine Pagels
The Biblical Canon (2007) - Lee Martin McDonald
The Book of Enoch: Its Reception (2013) - Loren T. Stuckenbruck
1 Enoch 1 (2001) - George W. E. Nickelsburg
The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, vol. 1 (1983) - James H. Charlesworth
Joseph Smith and Preexilic Israelite Religion (2005) - Margaret Barker
Questions of Canon Viewed through the Dead Sea Scrolls (2001) - James C. VanderKam
Seconding Sinai (2003) - Hindy Najman
Fallen Angels and the History of Judaism and Christianity (2005) - Annette Yoshiko Reed
The Septuagint as Christian Scripture (2002) - Martin Hengel
Revelations (2012) - Elaine Pagels
moderate support

Revelatory experience shaped early Christianity; one scholar affirms continuing revelation

Hurtado argues revelatory experiences drove early Christian innovation while bracketing their truth, McDonald asks whether a closed canon was necessary, and Charlesworth, speaking personally, affirmed that God kept speaking after the canon, without endorsing Latter-day Saint scripture. Neusner describes the rabbis' Torah as an unfinished canon, with revelation continuing through study. Schiffman shows the Qumran sect holding that hidden laws were revealed to it progressively. Najman reads 4 Ezra's Ezra re-giving the Torah, with further books revealed.

Larry W. HurtadoLee Martin McDonaldJames H. CharlesworthJacob NeusnerLawrence H. SchiffmanHindy Najman
Revelatory Experiences and Religious Innovation in Earliest Christianity (2014) - Larry W. Hurtado
The Formation of the Christian Biblical Canon, rev. ed. (1995) - Lee Martin McDonald
Messianism in the Pseudepigrapha and the Book of Mormon (1978) - James H. Charlesworth
The Glory of God Is Intelligence (1978) - Jacob Neusner
Reclaiming the Dead Sea Scrolls (1994) - Lawrence H. Schiffman
Losing the Temple and Recovering the Future (2014) - Hindy Najman
moderate support

A major evangelical commentary attributes all of Isaiah to Isaiah

Oswalt's NICOT commentary assigns chapters 40–66 to the eighth-century prophet, a minority view that removes the main objection to Book of Mormon Isaiah quotations, though he does not discuss the Book of Mormon.

John N. Oswalt
The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 1–39 (1986) and 40–66 (1998) - John N. Oswalt
moderate support

Prophecy renewed after the exile, not ended

Boda argues that the oracle headings of Zechariah 9-14 and Malachi mark a renewal of authoritative prophecy in the Persian period, against the view that prophecy had ended, and that the period saw no end to new revelation.

Mark J. Boda
Exploring Zechariah, Volume 2 (2017), ch. 8 - Mark J. Boda
moderate support

Inside the Bible, later scripture revised earlier scripture

Fishbane showed later biblical writers clarifying, reapplying and revising earlier authoritative texts and oracles before any canon was fixed. Levinson shows Deuteronomy, which forbids adding to the law, itself revising the Decalogue's rule on punishment across generations. Both describe how the biblical text grew; neither argues for modern revelation.

Michael FishbaneBernard M. Levinson
Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel (1985) - Michael Fishbane
'You Must Not Add Anything to What I Command You' (Numen, 2003) - Bernard M. Levinson

Death and eternity

19. Salvation of the dead · 2 fact cards
8 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 1 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • Intermediate state and spirit world: 1 linked works
  • Preaching to the dead: 4 linked works
  • Baptism for the dead: 7 linked works
strong supportBaptism for the dead

Five scholars read 1 Corinthians 15:29 as real proxy baptism

These scholars take the verse to describe living Christians baptised on behalf of the dead, and Stendahl and DeMaris note Paul cites it without condemning it; they speak as historians and do not endorse the modern ordinance (DeMaris sees a local funerary rite, Trumbower a limited practice). Hays reads the verse as an actual practice Paul cites without condemning.

Krister StendahlJeffrey A. TrumbowerRichard E. DeMarisN. T. WrightRichard B. Hays
Baptism for the Dead: Ancient Sources (1992) - Krister Stendahl
Rescue for the Dead (2001) - Jeffrey A. Trumbower
Corinthian Religion and Baptism for the Dead (1995) - Richard E. DeMaris
The Kingdom New Testament (2011) - N. T. Wright
First Corinthians (1997) - Richard B. Hays
moderate support

Early Christians debated whether the dead could still be saved

Trumbower shows that some early Christians read Christ's descent and 1 Peter as an offer of salvation to the dead until Augustine narrowed the question, and Anderson traces belief that purification and the living's alms can still help the dead. Ramelli argues that a line of Fathers from Clement and Origen to Gregory of Nyssa held the dead can still turn to God. J. Warren Smith's history records the early view of Hades as a holding place where Christ preached to the dead and freed the faithful.

Jeffrey A. TrumbowerGary A. AndersonIlaria L. E. RamelliJ. Warren Smith
Rescue for the Dead (2001) - Jeffrey A. Trumbower
Is Purgatory Biblical? (2011) - Gary A. Anderson
The Christian Doctrine of Apokatastasis (2013) - Ilaria L. E. Ramelli
Early Christian Theology: A History (2026) - J. Warren Smith
20. Gradations of Glory · 2 fact cards
3 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 3 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
moderate support

Early Christians debated whether the dead could still be saved

Trumbower shows that some early Christians read Christ's descent and 1 Peter as an offer of salvation to the dead until Augustine narrowed the question, and Anderson traces belief that purification and the living's alms can still help the dead. Ramelli argues that a line of Fathers from Clement and Origen to Gregory of Nyssa held the dead can still turn to God. J. Warren Smith's history records the early view of Hades as a holding place where Christ preached to the dead and freed the faithful.

Jeffrey A. TrumbowerGary A. AndersonIlaria L. E. RamelliJ. Warren Smith
Rescue for the Dead (2001) - Jeffrey A. Trumbower
Is Purgatory Biblical? (2011) - Gary A. Anderson
The Christian Doctrine of Apokatastasis (2013) - Ilaria L. E. Ramelli
Early Christian Theology: A History (2026) - J. Warren Smith
moderate support

Gradations of Glory: graded glory in the Church Fathers; wide salvation; two levels of glory in Daniel 12:3

Daley's Cambridge handbook documents that many Church Fathers taught graded glory among the redeemed; Irenaeus (Against Heresies 5.36) describes the saved dwelling in heaven, in paradise or in the city, and ties this to Christ's 'many mansions' (John 14:2); early writers also read Paul's star differing from star in glory (1 Cor 15:41) this way. That is a documented early Christian teaching, not the three kingdoms of D&C 76. Ramelli argues that early Christian texts call future punishment aionios ('of an age'), never aidios ('eternal'), and that a line of Fathers from Clement and Origen to Gregory of Nyssa held punishment after death to be corrective. That is wide salvation, not differing gradations of glory; her universalism is not Latter-day Saint teaching. Collins reads Daniel 12:3, where the wise shine like the brightness of the firmament and those who turn many to righteousness like the stars, as the righteous raised to a heavenly, star-like glory with two levels of it; that is glory for the righteous, not ranks among all the saved.

Brian E. DaleyIlaria L. E. RamelliJohn J. Collins
The Hope of the Early Church (1991) - Brian E. Daley
Irenaeus, Against Heresies 5.36 (via Daley) - Brian E. Daley
Terms for Eternity (2007, with David Konstan) - Ilaria L. E. Ramelli
The Christian Doctrine of Apokatastasis (2013) - Ilaria L. E. Ramelli
Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993) - John J. Collins
21. Bodily resurrection and new creation · 3 fact cards
11 scholars with a direct or supportive link, 2 more tangential only. See them on the Top 100 › · The common question ›
  • Bodily, not disembodied: 13 linked works
  • Transformation of the body: 4 linked works
  • New creation: the earth renewed, not escaped: 5 linked works
strong supportBodily, not disembodied

Five scholars stress bodily resurrection in biblical and early Jewish hope

These scholars argue that resurrection meant a bodily raising (Wright, Levenson), rooted in the Hebrew Bible and central to Christ's saving work in Hebrews (Moffitt), though Nickelsburg shows early Jewish hopes varied; this belief is shared with creedal Christianity. Wilson reads Luke's risen and ascended Jesus as embodied in heaven.

N. T. WrightJon D. LevensonDavid M. MoffittGeorge W. E. NickelsburgBrittany E. Wilson
The Resurrection of the Son of God (2003) - N. T. Wright
Resurrection and the Restoration of Israel (2006) - Jon D. Levenson
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in Hebrews (2011) - David M. Moffitt
Resurrection, Immortality, and Eternal Life (2006) - George W. E. Nickelsburg
The Embodied God (2021) - Brittany E. Wilson
strong supportTransformation of the body

Five scholars: Paul expected a real, transformed, glorified resurrection body

These scholars read Paul's hope as a transformed body sharing Christ's glory and incorruption, which most describe as pneumatic rather than flesh and bone. Engberg-Pedersen argues Paul's spirit is a fine material substance that transforms the body.

Matthew ThiessenPaula FredriksenM. David LitwaCrispin Fletcher-LouisTroels Engberg-Pedersen
A Jewish Paul (2023) - Matthew Thiessen
Philo, Herod, Paul, and the Many Gods (2022) - Paula Fredriksen
We Are Being Transformed (2012) - M. David Litwa
The Divine Heartset (2023) - Crispin Fletcher-Louis
Cosmology and Self in the Apostle Paul (2010) - Troels Engberg-Pedersen
strong supportNew creation: the earth renewed, not escaped

The hope is a renewed creation, not an escape from the body or the world

Wright argues the final Christian hope is not a disembodied heaven but bodily resurrection in a renewed creation where heaven and earth are joined; Bates likewise describes final salvation as bodily resurrection and life in a renewed creation. Pelikan documents that early Christian hope was bodily, first set against the immortality of the soul, and that Irenaeus expected Christ's kingdom physically on this earth; the immortal-soul framing became standard only later. Anderson shows early readers seeing priestly and baptismal clothing as anticipating the incorruptible resurrection body.

N. T. WrightMatthew W. BatesJaroslav PelikanGary A. Anderson
Surprised by Hope (2008) - N. T. Wright
Salvation by Allegiance Alone (2017) - Matthew W. Bates
The Christian Tradition, vol. 1 (1971) - Jaroslav Pelikan
The Genesis of Perfection (2001) - Gary A. Anderson