Jeffrey A. Trumbower

Rescue for the dead in early Christianity

Scholars appear here for their published work. No affiliation with the Foundation, and no endorsement of it or of Latter-day Saint teaching, is implied.

Professor of Religious Studies and Director of the Honors Program, Saint Michael's College (Vermont), formerly Dean and Vice President for Academic Affairs there; BA Vanderbilt, MA/PhD University of Chicago; monographs with Oxford University Press (Oxford Studies in Historical Theology, 2001) and Mohr Siebeck (1992).

Read Jeffrey A. Trumbower because he shows that early Christians believed the dead could still hear the gospel and be saved, until Augustine closed the door.

Start here: Rescue for the Dead (Oxford University Press, 2001)
19. Salvation of the dead · direct17. Apostasy and restoration · supportive
CaveatTrumbower writes history: he limits the Corinthian practice to people who wanted baptism in life or died in the faith unbaptised, and he does not argue for a general apostasy.

Why we spotlight this scholar

  • Oxford historian: 1 Corinthians 15:29 describes real vicarious baptism. Trumbower argues that the verse refers to living Christians being baptized for people who had died, though he thinks the Corinthians limited it to those who had wanted baptism while alive.
    “the grammar and logic of the passage point to a practice of vicarious baptism…”
    Rescue for the Dead (2001), ch. 2, pp. 35-36 · source
  • Early Christians practised baptism on behalf of the dead. The book's publisher summary says that some early Christians practised vicarious baptism for the dead, alongside prayers meant to rescue those who died outside the faith.
    Rescue for the Dead (2001) · source
  • Salvation through Christ's descent stayed an open question for four centuries. Early Christians disagreed about whom Christ saved when he descended to the dead, and some read 1 Peter as an offer of salvation to them.
    “The question of who was saved at the descent was not settled in the first four centuries of Christianity.”
    Rescue for the Dead (2001), ch. 5, p. 108 · source
  • Augustine narrowed early hopes of salvation for the dead. Trumbower shows Augustine limiting earlier beliefs about rescuing the dead to prayer for Christians who died with light sins, which set the later Western position.
    Rescue for the Dead (2001), ch. 7 · source

Key works

Only works tied to the reasons above.

Rescue for the Dead: The Posthumous Salvation of Non-Christians in Early Christianity (2001)
book · 2001

Rescue for the Dead: The Posthumous Salvation of Non-Christians in Early Christianity

Oxford University Press (Oxford Studies in Historical Theology)

The only scholarly monograph surveying early Christian vicarious baptism, prayer for the unbaptized dead and the descent to the underworld.

View at the publisher →