Since the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Nag Hammadi books came to light in the 1940s, scholars have changed how they read the Bible and the first Christians. These are the twelve changes they themselves named, from the 1940s to today, with the work of the scholars on our Top 100 placed on the timeline.
Scholars appear here for their published work. No affiliation with the Foundation, and no endorsement of it or of Latter-day Saint teaching, is implied.
Each shift goes by the name scholars use for it, with a plain description beneath in italics. Every one was named by scholars, not by us. For what these changes mean for Latter-day Saint readers, read the essay Familiar Ground.
1
The Divine Council
The council of heaven
Named by Cross 1953; Mullen 1980
Named by one scholar or a small groupOngoing
The Canaanite texts found at Ugarit describe a council of gods under El, and scholars came to read Israel’s own scriptures as remembering the Lord among such a council. It grew into a wider rethinking of how Israel’s belief in one God took shape out of a world of many divine beings.
On our Top 100 (10)
2
Enochic Judaism
The Enoch tradition
Named by Boccaccini 1998; the Enoch Seminar, founded by him, from 2001
Named by one scholar or a small groupOngoing
Fragments of 1 Enoch and related books among the Dead Sea Scrolls showed how widely they were read before Jesus. Boccaccini named an “Enochic Judaism” behind them; the Enoch Seminar he founded became the main forum for apocalypses, angels and ascent to heaven, even among scholars who doubt a separate Enochic Judaism.
On our Top 100 (12)
3
The Bauer Thesis
Many early Christianities
Named by Walter Bauer 1934
Lost steam c. 2012
Bauer argued that in many regions what was later called heresy came first, and that orthodoxy was the view of the side that won. The Nag Hammadi library, found in 1945 and published in English in 1977, gave the thesis its evidence and its public (Pagels, The Gnostic Gospels, 1979).
On our Top 100 (3)
4
The Third Quest for the Historical Jesus
Jesus in his Jewish world
Named by N. T. Wright 1982
Lost steam c. 2012
From the 1970s historians set Jesus firmly inside the Judaism the Dead Sea Scrolls had brought to light. Sanders read him as expecting the restoration of all Israel, a line Wright and Pitre carried on.
On our Top 100 (7)
5
The New Perspective on Paul
A new reading of Paul on grace and works
Named by Wright 1978; Dunn 1982
Lost steam c. 2015
Sanders showed that ancient Judaism joined God’s gracious choice with obedience inside the covenant, and Dunn and Wright named the new reading of Paul that followed. Its successors, the debate over “the faith of Christ” and Barclay’s Paul and the Gift, keep the question of grace and works open.
On our Top 100 (10)
6
Paul within Judaism
Paul as a faithful Jew
Named by Nanos and Zetterholm 2015
Ongoing
Going further than the New Perspective, these scholars read Paul as a Jew who never left Judaism, sent to bring the nations to Israel’s God. Staples’s work on the restoration of all twelve tribes sits with them.
On our Top 100 (9)
7
Early High Christology
Jesus worshipped as divine from the start
Named by Hurtado 1988; Segal 1977
Ongoing
Hengel, Segal and Hurtado argued that devotion to Jesus as divine came early and from inside Judaism, where some already spoke of a second power in heaven. Critics such as Fredriksen now ask how high “high” was in a world full of gods.
On our Top 100 (15)
8
Temple Theology
The temple at the centre
Named by Margaret Barker
Named by one scholar or a small groupOngoing
Barker argues that the faith of Solomon’s temple, with its high priest, heavenly council and holy of holies, lived on into early Christianity. Others read Eden and the creation week as a temple and the tabernacle as a model of the cosmos.
On our Top 100 (13)
9
Theosis
Becoming like God
Named by Russell 2004; the Oxford Handbook of Deification 2024
Ongoing
Russell’s history of deification in the Greek Fathers and Gorman’s reading of Paul as participation in Christ brought theosis into Western biblical scholarship. A handbook now carries the label.
On our Top 100 (10)
10
Intertextuality
Scripture echoing scripture
Named by Hays 1989 (“echoes of scripture”); Fishbane 1985
Ongoing
Fishbane showed scripture interpreting scripture inside the Hebrew Bible, and Hays showed Paul and the Gospels building meaning from Old Testament echoes. A reference industry followed (Beale and Carson, 2007).
On our Top 100 (6)
11
The Parting of the Ways
How Judaism and Christianity separated
Named by Dunn 1991
Ongoing
Dunn traced how the church and the synagogue drew apart; Boyarin, Becker and Reed argued the lines stayed blurred for centuries. The critique of supersessionism, the idea that the church replaced Israel, travels with it.
On our Top 100 (5)
12
Ressourcement
Returning to the early church
Named by French theologians of the nouvelle théologie, 1930s–1950s
Absorbed c. 1970
Catholic and Orthodox theologians from the 1930s went back behind later systems to the Church Fathers and the early liturgy. Its heirs on our list recover early Christian teaching on deification, worship and the life to come.
On our Top 100 (4)
Red lines are discoveries; green lines are when the finds were opened to scholars. Each band runs from when scholars named the shift to today, or fades where it lost steam; the thin line before a band is the work that came before the name; the dotted outline marks its busiest years (our judgement). Each mark is one book or article by a Top 100 scholar.
The table and the marks on the timeline count the same books and articles by scholars on our Top 100, each once. The list favours recent, readable work that bears on Latter-day Saint teachings, so later decades are fuller partly because of how it was chosen. Even so, the rise begins after the Nag Hammadi books appeared in English (1977) and gathers pace once the Dead Sea Scrolls were fully opened (1991).
Some things are often counted with these but are really discoveries, periods, fields or topics. They are not on the list because no group of scholars named them as a school.