Essay

Familiar Ground

What fifty years of biblical scholarship offers Latter-day Saint readers

Summary

Since the 1970s, scholars of the Bible and early Christianity have revised several long-held readings of scripture. Most are Protestant, Catholic or Jewish; none is a Latter-day Saint or was writing about Latter-day Saint belief. Their work argues that ancient Judaism joined grace with covenant obedience, that Paul describes salvation as sharing in God’s life, that the Christian hope is bodily resurrection on a renewed earth, that Israel’s restoration stood at the centre of first-century expectation, that temple and priesthood run through the whole Bible, and that ancient Israel pictured God with a body and a heavenly council. This scholarship does not establish Latter-day Saint teaching. It does show that much of what Latter-day Saints believe is at home in the biblical world.

A Latter-day Saint who picks up a recent book on Paul, on Genesis or on the hope of Israel may be surprised. The author is an Anglican bishop, a Methodist layman or a professor of Jewish studies at Harvard, and is not writing about Latter-day Saints. Yet the subjects are familiar from childhood: covenant, the gathering of Israel, temple, a renewed earth, becoming like God.

That was less true fifty years ago. Beginning with E. P. Sanders’s Paul and Palestinian Judaism in 1977, a number of lines of scholarship have re-examined readings long standard in Western Christianity, several of them specifically Protestant. The scholars hold to their own traditions. This essay sets out what six of those lines argue, what a Latter-day Saint reader may see in each, and where the likeness stops.

Six readings, then and nowFor six subjects, the older reading and what recent scholarship argues, with the scholars and years. The text version below gives every entry.Six readings, then and nowThe older reading, and what recent scholarship argues.Grace and covenantOLDER READINGThe Judaism of Paul’s day was a religion of legalisticworks-righteousness.RECENT SCHOLARSHIP ARGUESGod chose Israel by grace; obedience was theresponse inside the covenant. Grace is unconditionedbut not unconditional.Sanders 1977 · Dunn 1983 · Barclay 2015Becoming like GodOLDER READINGDeification was a Hellenistic importation, foreign tothe Bible.RECENT SCHOLARSHIP ARGUESDeification is biblical in its roots, and Paul’scross-shaped life is participation in the life of God.Russell 2004 · Gorman 2009 · Mannermaa 2005Resurrection and a renewed earthOLDER READINGThe Christian hope is to “go to” heaven.RECENT SCHOLARSHIP ARGUESThe hope is bodily resurrection in a renewed creation,and resurrection is rooted in the Hebrew Bible.Wright 2003, 2008 · Levenson 2006Israel restoredOLDER READINGThe church has replaced Israel (supersessionism).RECENT SCHOLARSHIP ARGUESThe first-century hope was Israel’s restoration, thenorthern tribes included, with the gentiles brought in.Sanders 1985 · Soulen 1996 · Staples 2021, 2023 · Oliver2021Temple and priesthoodOLDER READINGGenesis 1 is an account of material origins; Hebrewsis nearly silent on Jesus’s resurrection.RECENT SCHOLARSHIP ARGUESGenesis 1 presents the cosmos as God’s temple; inHebrews the risen Jesus is high priest in the heavenlysanctuary.Walton 2009 · Moffitt 2011 · Beale 2004God’s body and God’s councilOLDER READINGGod is without body; the “gods” of Psalm 82 arehuman judges.RECENT SCHOLARSHIP ARGUES“The God of the Hebrew Bible has a body.” EarlyIsrael pictured a council of divine beings.Sommer 2009 · Smith 2001 · Markschies 2019 · Wilson 2021· Stavrakopoulou 2021The scholars are not Latter-day Saints and do not argue forLatter-day Saint teaching.
Figure 1. Six readings, then and now.
Text version of figure 1
  • Grace and covenant. Older reading: The Judaism of Paul’s day was a religion of legalistic works-righteousness. Recent scholarship argues: God chose Israel by grace; obedience was the response inside the covenant. Grace is unconditioned but not unconditional. (Sanders 1977; Dunn 1983; Barclay 2015.)
  • Becoming like God. Older reading: Deification was a Hellenistic importation, foreign to the Bible. Recent scholarship argues: Deification is biblical in its roots, and Paul’s cross-shaped life is participation in the life of God. (Russell 2004; Gorman 2009; Mannermaa 2005.)
  • Resurrection and a renewed earth. Older reading: The Christian hope is to “go to” heaven. Recent scholarship argues: The hope is bodily resurrection in a renewed creation, and resurrection is rooted in the Hebrew Bible. (Wright 2003, 2008; Levenson 2006.)
  • Israel restored. Older reading: The church has replaced Israel (supersessionism). Recent scholarship argues: The first-century hope was Israel’s restoration, the northern tribes included, with the gentiles brought in. (Sanders 1985; Soulen 1996; Staples 2021, 2023; Oliver 2021.)
  • Temple and priesthood. Older reading: Genesis 1 is an account of material origins; Hebrews is nearly silent on Jesus’s resurrection. Recent scholarship argues: Genesis 1 presents the cosmos as God’s temple; in Hebrews the risen Jesus is high priest in the heavenly sanctuary. (Walton 2009; Moffitt 2011; Beale 2004.)
  • God’s body and God’s council. Older reading: God is without body; the “gods” of Psalm 82 are human judges. Recent scholarship argues: “The God of the Hebrew Bible has a body.” Early Israel pictured a council of divine beings. (Sommer 2009; Smith 2001; Markschies 2019; Wilson 2021; Stavrakopoulou 2021.)

Grace and covenant

Sanders argued that the Judaism of Paul’s day was not a system for earning salvation. Its pattern, which he named covenantal nomism, was that God chose Israel by grace and that obedience was the fitting response inside the covenant. James D. G. Dunn and N. T. Wright reread Paul in that light. John M. G. Barclay’s Paul and the Gift (2015) added that grace in Paul is, in his publisher’s summary, “unconditioned” but not “unconditional”: given without regard to worth, yet looking for a response. A Latter-day Saint may recognise covenant life here, with grace first and faithfulness as the answer to it. But Sanders was describing ancient Judaism, not Paul, and Wright still treats justification as God’s declaration of who belongs to his people.

Becoming like God

Michael J. Gorman’s Inhabiting the Cruciform God (2009) argues that the cross-shaped life Paul describes is at heart what Christian tradition calls theosis, participation in the life of God. Tuomo Mannermaa found a like theme in Luther, for whom, he writes, “the divine life in Christ which is present in faith” stands at the centre. Norman Russell’s history of deification in the Greek fathers (2004) holds, in a reviewer’s words, that the doctrine is “essentially biblical and not a Hellenistic importation.” Latter-day Saints teach that God’s children may become like him, and the Church’s essay on the subject cites the same early fathers. For these scholars, though, humans share God’s life by grace and remain his creatures. Latter-day Saints see all people as children of God “in a full and complete sense,” which goes further.

Resurrection and a renewed earth

N. T. Wright’s The Resurrection of the Son of God (2003) and Surprised by Hope (2008) argue that the first Christians hoped for bodily resurrection in a renewed creation, not for escape from the earth. Jon D. Levenson’s Resurrection and the Restoration of Israel (2006) finds the roots of resurrection in the Hebrew Bible and challenges the notion that it was “a foreign import into Judaism.” Here the agreement is plainest. Latter-day Saints believe in a literal resurrection and that “the earth will be renewed and receive its paradisiacal glory.” These books do not address Restoration teachings such as the degrees of glory.

Israel restored

For most of Christian history the church was said to have replaced Israel. R. Kendall Soulen’s The God of Israel and Christian Theology (1996) is, in its publisher’s words, the “first full-scale critique of Christian supersessionism.” Jason A. Staples argues that “Israel” in this period was a wider name than “the Jews” and still took in the scattered northern tribes, and that for Paul their restoration “required gentile inclusion” (2021, 2023). Isaac W. Oliver finds the hope for Israel’s national restoration alive in Luke and Acts (2021). Latter-day Saints will think of the “literal gathering of Israel.” These studies reconstruct a first-century hope; none identifies a gathering in the latter days.

Temple and priesthood

John H. Walton’s The Lost World of Genesis One (2009) reads the creation account as God ordering the cosmos as his temple and taking up residence there. David M. Moffitt (2011) argues that in Hebrews the risen, embodied Jesus is the high priest who enters the heavenly sanctuary. G. K. Beale’s The Temple and the Church’s Mission (2004) follows the temple from Eden to the new creation. Margaret Barker argues, controversially, that the theology of Solomon’s temple shaped early Christian worship. Latter-day Saints, to whom temples are central, will welcome the attention. But Beale concludes that the physical temple foreshadowed Christ and his people as the true temple, and none of these scholars argues for temple ordinances today.

God’s body and God’s council

Benjamin D. Sommer opens The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (2009) with the sentence, “The God of the Hebrew Bible has a body.” Francesca Stavrakopoulou’s God: An Anatomy (2021) presents the God of the biblical texts as a human-shaped deity who walks, talks, eats and breathes. Brittany E. Wilson’s The Embodied God (2021) argues that early Jews and Christians often pictured God as having a visible form, and Christoph Markschies shows that many early Christians thought of God as embodied (2019). Mark S. Smith, drawing on the texts of ancient Ugarit, describes an early Israelite divine council in which the God of Israel stood among other divine beings (2001). Joseph Smith taught that “the Father has a body of flesh and bones,” and the Book of Abraham shows God in the midst of intelligences “organized before the world was.” Here the scholars stand furthest from Latter-day Saint conclusions. Sommer’s God has many bodies at once. Stavrakopoulou, an atheist, describes what ancient people believed. Smith treats the council as an early stage that later biblical writers denounced. Michael S. Heiser, who also reads the gods of Psalm 82 as divine beings, wrote a long critique of Latter-day Saint use of that psalm.

Who argues whatA grid of 21 scholars against the six subjects, marking where each scholar’s cited work bears. The text version below gives every entry.Who argues whatEach mark is a work in the source list.GraceLikenessRisingIsraelTempleGodE. P. Sanders1977, 1985James D. G. Dunn1983N. T. Wright1997–2008John M. G. Barclay2015Michael J. Gorman2009Tuomo Mannermaa2005Norman Russell2004Jon D. Levenson2006R. Kendall Soulen1996Jason A. Staples2021, 2023Isaac W. Oliver2021John H. Walton2009David M. Moffitt2011G. K. Beale2004Margaret Barker2003, 2004Benjamin D. Sommer2009Mark S. Smith2001Christoph Markschies2019Brittany E. Wilson2021Francesca Stavrakopoulou2021Michael S. Heiser2007the work bears on this subjectbears on it, and criticises the Latter-day Saint readingColumns: grace and covenant; becoming like God; resurrection anda renewed earth; Israel restored; temple and priesthood; God’sbody and God’s council.
Figure 5. Who argues what.
Text version of figure 5
  • E. P. Sanders (1977, 1985): Grace and covenant; Israel restored.
  • James D. G. Dunn (1983): Grace and covenant.
  • N. T. Wright (1997–2008): Grace and covenant; Resurrection and a renewed earth.
  • John M. G. Barclay (2015): Grace and covenant.
  • Michael J. Gorman (2009): Becoming like God.
  • Tuomo Mannermaa (2005): Becoming like God.
  • Norman Russell (2004): Becoming like God.
  • Jon D. Levenson (2006): Resurrection and a renewed earth; Israel restored.
  • R. Kendall Soulen (1996): Israel restored.
  • Jason A. Staples (2021, 2023): Israel restored.
  • Isaac W. Oliver (2021): Israel restored.
  • John H. Walton (2009): Temple and priesthood.
  • David M. Moffitt (2011): Temple and priesthood; Resurrection and a renewed earth.
  • G. K. Beale (2004): Temple and priesthood.
  • Margaret Barker (2003, 2004): Temple and priesthood.
  • Benjamin D. Sommer (2009): God’s body and God’s council.
  • Mark S. Smith (2001): God’s body and God’s council.
  • Christoph Markschies (2019): God’s body and God’s council.
  • Brittany E. Wilson (2021): God’s body and God’s council.
  • Francesca Stavrakopoulou (2021): God’s body and God’s council.
  • Michael S. Heiser (2007): God’s body and God’s council (bears on it, and criticises the Latter-day Saint reading).
Where the likeness holds, and where it stopsFor six subjects, what recent scholarship and Latter-day Saint teaching share, and where they part. The text version below gives every entry.Where the likeness holds, and where itstopsReal agreement beside partial overlap.Grace and covenantHOLDSGrace comes first; covenant obedience is theresponse to it, not the price of it.STOPSSanders describes ancient Judaism, not Paul. Wrightkeeps justification as God’s declaration.Becoming like GodHOLDSSharing in God’s life is biblical and early Christianteaching.STOPSFor these scholars humans stay creatures whoshare God’s life by grace.Resurrection and a renewed earthHOLDSBodily resurrection in a renewed creation is theChristian hope.STOPSNothing here on degrees of glory or other Restorationteachings.Israel restoredHOLDSIsrael’s restoration, the northern tribes included,was the first-century hope.STOPSA reconstruction of ancient hope. No one identifies agathering in the latter days.Temple and priesthoodHOLDSTemple runs through the Bible from creation to newcreation.STOPSBeale: Christ and his people are the true temple. Noone argues for temple ordinances today.God’s body and God’s councilHOLDSBiblical writers pictured God with a body, amongother divine beings.STOPSSommer: many bodies at once. Stavrakopoulou:what ancient people believed. Smith: an early stage,later denounced. Heiser: a critic of the Latter-daySaint reading.
Figure 4. Where the likeness holds, and where it stops.
Text version of figure 4
  • Grace and covenant. Holds: Grace comes first; covenant obedience is the response to it, not the price of it. Stops: Sanders describes ancient Judaism, not Paul. Wright keeps justification as God’s declaration.
  • Becoming like God. Holds: Sharing in God’s life is biblical and early Christian teaching. Stops: For these scholars humans stay creatures who share God’s life by grace.
  • Resurrection and a renewed earth. Holds: Bodily resurrection in a renewed creation is the Christian hope. Stops: Nothing here on degrees of glory or other Restoration teachings.
  • Israel restored. Holds: Israel’s restoration, the northern tribes included, was the first-century hope. Stops: A reconstruction of ancient hope. No one identifies a gathering in the latter days.
  • Temple and priesthood. Holds: Temple runs through the Bible from creation to new creation. Stops: Beale: Christ and his people are the true temple. No one argues for temple ordinances today.
  • God’s body and God’s council. Holds: Biblical writers pictured God with a body, among other divine beings. Stops: Sommer: many bodies at once. Stavrakopoulou: what ancient people believed. Smith: an early stage, later denounced. Heiser: a critic of the Latter-day Saint reading.

Whose readings were these?

It would be simple to call this a challenge to Protestant theology. The label fits only part of the picture. Justification by faith alone, and worship without priest or altar, were Reformation positions that Catholic and Orthodox Christians never held, and deification never left their teaching. A God without a body and a church that replaced Israel were the common inheritance of all three. Heaven without resurrection was never the formal teaching of any. And much of the revision is the work of Protestant scholars rereading their own tradition.

Whose reading was it?A grid of six older readings against Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox teaching. Three were taught by Protestants only, two by all three churches, and one by none. The text version below gives every entry.Whose reading was it?Which churches taught each older reading.ProtestantCatholicOrthodoxJustified by faith alone, byrighteousness imputedWestminster 11 · Trent 1547, canon9 · Dositheus 1672, decree 13No deification in theconfession of faithabsent from Westminster ·Catechism 460 · Russell 2004No priest offering sacrifice atan altarWestminster 29.2 · Catechism1366–67 · Dositheus 17The church has replacedIsraelSoulen 1996 · Nostra Aetate 1965God is without a bodyWestminster 2.1 · Vatican I · Johnof DamascusHeaven without a risen bodyWestminster 32 · Catechism 992 ·John of Damascus IV.27taughtnot taughttaught, revised 1965Protestant only: three. All three churches: two. Nochurch: one.“Protestant” here means the Reformed confession (Westminster,1646). The Orthodox mark for Israel is inferred from thesecond-century fathers all three share.
Figure 3. Whose reading was it? Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox teaching.
Text version of figure 3
  • Justified by faith alone, by righteousness imputed. Protestant: taught. Catholic: not taught. Orthodox: not taught. (Westminster 11; Trent 1547, canon 9; Dositheus 1672, decree 13.)
  • No deification in the confession of faith. Protestant: taught. Catholic: not taught. Orthodox: not taught. (absent from Westminster; Catechism 460; Russell 2004.)
  • No priest offering sacrifice at an altar. Protestant: taught. Catholic: not taught. Orthodox: not taught. (Westminster 29.2; Catechism 1366–67; Dositheus 17.)
  • The church has replaced Israel. Protestant: taught. Catholic: taught, revised in 1965. Orthodox: taught. (Soulen 1996; Nostra Aetate 1965.)
  • God is without a body. Protestant: taught. Catholic: taught. Orthodox: taught. (Westminster 2.1; Vatican I; John of Damascus.)
  • Heaven without a risen body. Protestant: not taught. Catholic: not taught. Orthodox: not taught. (Westminster 32; Catechism 992; John of Damascus IV.27.)

Protestant only: three. All three churches: two. No church: one. “Protestant” here means the Reformed confession (Westminster, 1646). The Orthodox entry for Israel is inferred from the second-century fathers all three share.

Before the evidence

The Book of Abraham and the Articles of Faith were in print in 1842. Joseph Smith taught in 1843 that the Father has a body, and gave the King Follett discourse in April 1844, weeks before his death in June. Excavation at Ugarit began in 1929, the Dead Sea Scrolls were found in 1947, and the scholarship described here dates from 1977. Some of what he taught was in the Bible he read, and other Christians of his day also looked for Israel’s return. History cannot test a claim of revelation. It can record that teachings for which Latter-day Saints were long faulted now have a place in the scholarly picture of ancient Israel and early Christianity.

Order in time, 1830 to 2023A timeline: what Joseph Smith taught between 1830 and 1844, then, from 1929 to 2023, two finds, one church statement and the scholarship. The text version below gives every entry.Order in timeWhat Joseph Smith taught, then the finds and thescholarship.Joseph Smithfindscholarshipchurch statement1830Enoch, Zion and the gathering (Moses 7,December 1830)1833The faithful “receive of His fulness” (D&C 93, 6May)1842Book of Abraham published from 1 March:intelligences “organized before the world was”1842Articles of Faith, 1 March: the “literal gatheringof Israel”; the earth “renewed”1843“The Father has a body of flesh and bones”(D&C 130, 2 April)1844King Follett discourse, 7 April1844Joseph Smith killed at Carthage, 27 June85 years: 1844 to 19291929Excavation of Ugarit begins1947Dead Sea Scrolls found (1946–47)1965Vatican II, Nostra Aetate: the Jews not“rejected or accursed by God”1977Sanders, Paul and Palestinian Judaism1983Dunn, “The New Perspective on Paul”1985Sanders, Jesus and Judaism1996Soulen, The God of Israel and ChristianTheology2001Smith, The Origins of Biblical Monotheism2003Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God2004Russell, The Doctrine of Deification; Beale, TheTemple and the Church’s Mission2006Levenson, Resurrection and the Restoration ofIsrael2009Sommer, The Bodies of God; Gorman,Inhabiting the Cruciform God; Walton, The LostWorld of Genesis One2011Moffitt, Atonement and the Logic ofResurrection in Hebrews2015Barclay, Paul and the Gift2019Markschies, God’s Body (English edition)2021Staples, The Idea of Israel; Oliver, Luke’sJewish Eschatology; Wilson, The EmbodiedGod; Stavrakopoulou, God: An Anatomy2023Staples, Paul and the Resurrection of IsraelThe figure shows order in time only. It does not show influence,and history cannot test a claim of revelation.
Figure 2. Order in time, 1830 to 2023.
Text version of figure 2

Joseph Smith:

  • 1830: Enoch, Zion and the gathering (Moses 7, December 1830)
  • 1833: The faithful “receive of His fulness” (D&C 93, 6 May)
  • 1842: Book of Abraham published from 1 March: intelligences “organized before the world was”
  • 1842: Articles of Faith, 1 March: the “literal gathering of Israel”; the earth “renewed”
  • 1843: “The Father has a body of flesh and bones” (D&C 130, 2 April)
  • 1844: King Follett discourse, 7 April
  • 1844: Joseph Smith killed at Carthage, 27 June

Then, 85 years later:

  • 1929 (find): Excavation of Ugarit begins
  • 1947 (find): Dead Sea Scrolls found (1946–47)
  • 1965 (church statement): Vatican II, Nostra Aetate: the Jews not “rejected or accursed by God”
  • 1977 (scholarship): Sanders, Paul and Palestinian Judaism
  • 1983 (scholarship): Dunn, “The New Perspective on Paul”
  • 1985 (scholarship): Sanders, Jesus and Judaism
  • 1996 (scholarship): Soulen, The God of Israel and Christian Theology
  • 2001 (scholarship): Smith, The Origins of Biblical Monotheism
  • 2003 (scholarship): Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God
  • 2004 (scholarship): Russell, The Doctrine of Deification; Beale, The Temple and the Church’s Mission
  • 2006 (scholarship): Levenson, Resurrection and the Restoration of Israel
  • 2009 (scholarship): Sommer, The Bodies of God; Gorman, Inhabiting the Cruciform God; Walton, The Lost World of Genesis One
  • 2011 (scholarship): Moffitt, Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in Hebrews
  • 2015 (scholarship): Barclay, Paul and the Gift
  • 2019 (scholarship): Markschies, God’s Body (English edition)
  • 2021 (scholarship): Staples, The Idea of Israel; Oliver, Luke’s Jewish Eschatology; Wilson, The Embodied God; Stavrakopoulou, God: An Anatomy
  • 2023 (scholarship): Staples, Paul and the Resurrection of Israel

The figure shows order in time only. It does not show influence, and history cannot test a claim of revelation.

Reading with care

The foundation presents these scholars because their work bears on Latter-day Saint doctrine and teaching, not because they share it. They do not. The right use is to read what they argue, to note where they differ, and to let the biblical world come into clearer view. What comes into view is a world of covenant, gathering, temple and divine likeness. Latter-day Saints will know it.

Sources

Words in quotation marks are from the work itself, from its publisher’s description, or from the review named. Each link is the page that was read.