David Winston

Wisdom 8:19-20: souls that exist before the body

Scholars appear here for their published work. No affiliation with the Foundation, and no endorsement of it or of Latter-day Saint teaching, is implied.

MA and PhD in Greek and Latin (Columbia). Professor of Hellenistic and Judaic Studies at the Graduate Theological Union, Berkeley, from 1966, and director of its Center for Jewish Studies. Author of Anchor Bible 43 (Wisdom of Solomon). Remembered as 'his generation's most learned scholar of Philo'. 1927 – 13 Dec 2022.

Shows a Jewish book read by the first Christians teaching that souls lived before birth (Wisdom 8:19-20) and that God shaped the world from formless matter (Wisdom 11:17).

An academic work: the standard commentary; start with the introduction and the notes on those verses.
6. Premortal existence · direct8. Creation from existing matter · direct17. Apostasy and restoration · direct15. Temple theology · tangential
CaveatWinston, a historian and rabbi, reads Wisdom's pre-existent souls and formless matter as Hellenistic Jewish ideas shaped partly by Platonism, not as teachings he endorses. In his 1978 essay for BYU's Religious Studies Center he compared them with Latter-day Saint teaching, noting differences as well as parallels.

Why the work is featured

  • Jewish scholar: Wisdom 8:19-20 clearly teaches preexistent souls. In the Anchor Bible commentary, Winston says the verse plainly teaches souls that exist before the body and should not be explained away.
    The Wisdom of Solomon, AB 43 (1979), p. 198 · source
  • Creation from nothing: a second-century Christian formulation. Winston finds creation from nothing absent from Greek, Hellenistic Jewish and rabbinic thought until second-century Christian writers.
    “the concept of creation ex nihilo formed no part of Greek philosophical thought…”
    Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources (1978), pp. 13-35 · source
  • Wisdom 11:17: God shaped the world from formless matter. Winston argues that the 'formless matter' of Wisdom 11:17 is eternal, pre-existing matter, not a first stage God created from nothing.
    The Book of Wisdom's Theory of Cosmogony, History of Religions 11 (1971), 185-202 · source
  • Philo: souls as numerous as the stars, descending into bodies. Winston documents Philo's teaching of countless souls of differing spiritual grades, some of which enter bodies.
    “full of souls equal in number to the stars, but consisting of distinctive spiritual grades.”
    Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources (1978) · source

Key works

Only works tied to the reasons above.

The Wisdom of Solomon: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (Anchor Bible 43) (1979)Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources (1978)The Book of Wisdom's Theory of Cosmogony (1971)Creation Ex Nihilo Revisited: A Reply to Jonathan Goldstein (1986)Logos and Mystical Theology in Philo of Alexandria (1985)
book · 1979

The Wisdom of Solomon: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (Anchor Bible 43)

Doubleday; Yale University Press reissue 2008

Standard commentary; p. 198 on Wis 8:19-20 is the classic statement on preexistent souls.

View at the publisher →
chapter · 1978

Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources

BYU Religious Studies Center

A non-LDS specialist directly compares premortality and creation from matter with Latter-day Saint teaching, parallels and differences.

View at the publisher →
article · 1971

The Book of Wisdom's Theory of Cosmogony

History of Religions 11.2

Main argument that Wisdom 11:17 assumes eternal formless matter.

View at the publisher →
article · 1986

Creation Ex Nihilo Revisited: A Reply to Jonathan Goldstein

Journal of Jewish Studies 37.1

His defence against the rabbinic creation-from-nothing reading; cited by Ostler and Barney.

View at the publisher →
book · 1985

Logos and Mystical Theology in Philo of Alexandria

Hebrew Union College Press

Establishes his Philo authority; not counted toward any topic.

View at the publisher →