Common questions

Questions people often ask about Latter-day Saint teaching, each answered with the exact words of biblical scholars, in context.

Scholars appear here for their published work. No affiliation with the Foundation, and no endorsement of it or of Latter-day Saint teaching, is implied.

Every answer leads with the scholar's own words, checked against the source, then says what the passage argues and what it does not claim.

1

Does the Bible know of a council of divine beings?

Topic: Divine council · 13 scholars
Michael S. Heiser
The divine council in the Hebrew Bible
“The plural ʾĕlōhîm of Psalm 82:1, 6 are divine beings, not human judges or humans fulfilling any role.”
You've Seen One Elohim, You've Seen Them All? A Critique of Mormonism's Use of Psalm 82 (2007) · FARMS Review 19/1 · pp. 221–266 · source
“belief in a divine council survived the exile.”
The Divine Council in Late Canonical and Non-Canonical Second Temple Jewish Literature (2004) · University of Wisconsin–Madison (PhD dissertation) · source
“I hold that position as well, and Bokovoy provided some new grist for that mill with his articulation in this section.”
Israel's Divine Council, Mormonism, and Evangelicalism: Clarifying the Issues and Directions for Future Study (2007) · FARMS Review 19/1 · pp. 315–323 · source
In context: His dissertation and peer-reviewed articles argue that the Psalm 82 elohim are divine beings, and that a council of such beings is presented as real and persisted after the exile.
What this does not claim: He held that Yahweh is unique in kind, not the same kind of being as the other elohim, and that the other elohim are created beings; he rejected the LDS reading of Psalm 82 as showing the gods are of one kind.
In context: Writing in an LDS journal, he judged that the LDS understanding of God is not inherently polytheistic.
What this does not claim: He added at once that it is polytheistic if Latter-day Saints insist all elohim are species-equals; the concession is conditional.
Caveat
CaveatHeiser disagreed with Latter-day Saint readings of Psalm 82, in a 2007 FARMS Review exchange with the Latter-day Saint scholar David Bokovoy: he held that Yahweh is unique in kind, not the same kind of being as the other elohim, and that creation was ultimately out of nothing.
Mark S. Smith
Israel's divine council and early religion
“In the earliest stage, it would appear that Yahweh was one of these seventy children…”
The Origins of Biblical Monotheism (2001) · Oxford University Press · source
“Psalm 82 also presents the god El presiding in a divine assembly at which Yahweh stands up…”
The Origins of Biblical Monotheism (2001); The Early History of God (1990; 2nd ed. 2002) · Oxford University Press; Harper & Row / Eerdmans · source
In context: His Ugaritic comparison and the older text of Deut 32:8-9 show that early Israelite texts pictured El presiding over an assembly of divine sons, among whom Yahweh received Israel.
What this does not claim: He treats this as an early stage that the biblical writers later merged into one God and denounced; it does not show a lasting plurality of gods, exaltation, or Elohim and Jehovah as Father and Son.
Caveat
CaveatSmith describes early Israel's divine council as history: in his account the biblical writers later moved away from divine plurality, and he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching. Michael Heiser (FARMS Review, 2007) criticised Latter-day Saint use of Smith.
Paula Fredriksen
Many gods, creation from matter, a distinct Son
“For ancient Jews and Christians, God was not the only god, not even in his own book.”
How High Can Early High Christology Be? (2020) · Brill (Novenson, ed., Monotheism and Christology in Greco-Roman Antiquity) · ch. 13, pp. 295–300 · source · quotation source
In context: Argues from Psalms, Deuteronomy, Philo and Paul that ancient Jews assumed other gods really existed and formed God's heavenly court, and that 1 Cor 8:6 does not deny the gods of 8:5.
What this does not claim: Her lesser gods are created or subordinate powers, often hostile and defeated by Christ; she does not describe a council of exalted humans or endorse LDS teaching about the gods.
Caveat
CaveatFredriksen's lesser gods are subordinate, often hostile powers, not exalted humans; Paul's resurrection body in her reading is pneumatic, not flesh; and gentiles join God's family alongside Israel without becoming Israel.
Daniel Boyarin
Two powers in heaven
“Part of the evidence for this very cult will come from efforts at its suppression on the part of rabbinic texts.”
Beyond Judaisms: Metatron and the Divine Polymorphy of Ancient Judaism (2010) · Journal for the Study of Judaism 41.3, Brill · pp. 323-365 · source
In context: Documents a long-lived Jewish 'two powers' tradition that the rabbis only later labelled heresy.
What this does not claim: Two figures, not a divine council or many gods; it says nothing about Ps 82 or Deut 32.
Caveat
CaveatBoyarin finds two divine figures, not a council of many gods, and reads them as an early form of the Trinity. His Daniel 7 reading is disputed (Schäfer, Schremer).
James L. Kugel
The embodied God of the earliest texts
“who held counsel with other gods in Psalm 82”
How to Read the Bible: A Guide to Scripture, Then and Now (2007) · Free Press · 31-32 (per Eliason review) · source
“The Bible makes no secret of the fact that other peoples had their own gods…”
The Great Shift: Encountering God in Biblical Times (2017) · Houghton Mifflin Harcourt · source
In context: He reads Psalm 82 as God holding counsel with other gods, and Deut 4:19 as other nations being allotted their own deities. He calls early Israelite religion monolatry: one God worshipped, others not denied.
What this does not claim: He describes this as an early stage that Israel moved beyond toward Isaiah's peerless God. He does not support plural gods as present truth, or exaltation.
Caveat
CaveatKugel treats the human-form God as an early stage later superseded, and his critical method treats much biblical narrative as non-historical.
Margaret Barker
Temple Theology
“Yahweh was a son of God, manifested on earth in human form as an angel or in the Davidic King.”
The Great Angel: A Study of Israel's Second God (1992) · Westminster John Knox / SPCK · source
In context: She argues that pre-Christian Israel recognised a High God and several sons of God, with Yahweh among them.
What this does not claim: Her reconstruction is disputed (Schäfer, Paul), and she does not affirm a plurality of gods as present-day belief.
Caveat
CaveatBarker's First Temple reconstructions are her own arguments, which specialists dispute (Schäfer, Paul, Twigg). She is an independent scholar and does not endorse Latter-day Saint claims.
John J. Collins
Divine plurality in ancient Israel
“In Deut 32:8-9, Elyon allots the nations to the various gods and allots Israel to Yahweh.”
Daniel (1993); Yale Bible Study 'Daniel' course (Collins co-presenter) · Fortress Press (Hermeneia) · Dan 7 and Dan 10 discussions · source · quotation source
In context: A leading mainstream critic documents that Israelite and Second Temple texts speak of 'gods' and 'sons of El' under the Most High (Deut 32:8-9, Ps 82 at Qumran, Daniel's angelic princes), and that 'monotheism' imperfectly describes the period.
What this does not claim: He explains this as Israel's development from its Canaanite background, not as revealed truth later lost; he affirms the supremacy of the Most High; and his 'gods' are angels, not exalted humans of the same species as God.
Caveat
CaveatCollins explains divine plurality as Israel's development from its Canaanite background. He dates Daniel late, reads the Ancient of Days as God and the 'son of man' as Michael, and reads Daniel 12 as a selective resurrection.
Saul M. Olyan
Asherah and Yahweh's incomparability
“unique power and agency than about his sole existence.”
Is Isaiah 40–55 Really Monotheistic? (2012) · Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 12/2 (Brill) · pp. 190–201 · source · quotation source
In context: Olyan argues the Isaiah 45:5 formula asserts Yahweh's incomparability and unique power, not his sole existence, and that Isaiah 40 presupposes heavenly beings with real agency.
What this does not claim: He notes Second Isaiah no longer calls these beings 'gods'; he does not argue for exalted humans or a plurality of gods of equal standing.
Caveat
CaveatOlyan's consort reading is hedged ('seems'), and in Isaiah 40-55 the heavenly host are no longer called gods.
Alan F. Segal
Two Powers in Heaven, the source study
“The basic heresy involved interpreting scripture to say that a principal angelic or hypostatic manifestation in heaven was equivalent to God.”
Two Powers in Heaven (1977) · E. J. Brill (SJLA 25); reissued Brill 2002, Baylor UP 2012 · source · quotation source
In context: Segal shows that before the rabbis some Jews read scripture as placing a principal figure in heaven, in human form and carrying God's name, who was equivalent to God, and that the earliest versions saw the two powers as complementary.
What this does not claim: Historical description only. It is binitarian (God plus one figure), does not show the Father has a tangible body, and Segal did not endorse the belief. Later scholars (Boyarin, McGrath) debate its dating and framing.
Caveat
CaveatSegal described the 'two powers' belief as history and did not hold it; he found a second divine figure, not a council of many gods.
M. David Litwa
Deification in Paul; "You are gods"
“Although he does not say so explicitly, Clement hints that it is Christ who is the presiding deity, while Christian martyrs make up the deified congregation.”
'You Are Gods: Deification in the Naassene Writer and Clement of Alexandria' (2017) · Harvard Theological Review 110.1, pp. 125-148 (Cambridge UP) · pp. 125-148 · source · quotation source
In context: Shows Clement of Alexandria and the Naassene writer reading Ps 82:6 as about deified humans, with Clement hinting that Christ presides over a deified congregation (Ps 82:1).
What this does not claim: This is evidence of 2nd–3rd century reception, not of the psalm's original divine-council meaning, and it does not touch Deut 32:8-9.
Caveat
CaveatLitwa's Pauline thesis is disputed (Orr, Themelios 38.2). His wider work treats the Gospels as myth shaped into history.
Silviu N. Bunta
Shared divinity, deification and God's face
“neither polytheistic, nor monotheistic, but deificational…”
The Lord God of Gods: Divinity and Deification in Early Judaism (2021) · Gorgias Press · ch. 4 'The Other Gods—Inclusion and Exclusion in the Godhead'; ch. 7 on the angelification of YHWH's council · source
In context: He argues early Jewish theology was 'neither polytheistic, nor monotheistic', with God sharing divinity with 'gods', so strict later monotheism should not be read back into the Bible.
What this does not claim: His model is one divine selfhood shared at God's discretion, not a plurality of separate, independent divine beings.
Caveat
CaveatBunta's model is one divine selfhood shared with 'gods' and humans, not many separate gods; the book also traces periods that exclude humans from the Godhead. He formerly taught at the University of Dayton.
William G. Dever
Archaeology of Asherah beside Yahweh
“the majority of ordinary people were not monotheistic Yahwists…”
Did God Have a Wife? Archaeology and Folk Religion in Ancient Israel (2005) · Eerdmans · source
In context: His archaeology shows that ordinary pre-exilic Israelites recognised more than one divine being, and that exclusive monotheism became dominant later.
What this does not claim: This is folk polytheism, not a divine council theology, and Dever regards later monotheism as progress, not loss.
Caveat
CaveatDever, a self-described non-theist, reads the Asherah cult as folk religion opposed by the biblical writers; his consort thesis is contested. The main Latter-day Saint review (Von Feldt, 2007) declines to call Heavenly Mother a restoration of Asherah belief.
Richard B. Hays
Intertextuality: the echoes of scripture
“they are the deities of other ancient Near Eastern nations…”
Echoes of Scripture in the Gospels (2016) · Baylor University Press · p. 331 (John 10 / Psalm 82) · source
In context: In discussing John 10, Hays reads the 'gods' of Psalm 82 as deities of the nations whom God judges in a divine assembly, not as human judges.
What this does not claim: One page of a long book. It reads the psalm's ancient setting and does not speak to human exaltation or godhood.
Caveat
CaveatHis readings of 1 Cor 15:29 and Psalm 82 are brief commentary points, not sustained arguments. His last book (2024) affirms same-sex relationships, which differs from Church teaching on marriage.
2

Did early Jews and Christians see the Father and the Son as distinct persons?

Topic: The Godhead: distinct persons · 5 scholars
Margaret Barker
Temple Theology
“Yahweh was a son of God, manifested on earth in human form as an angel or in the Davidic King.”
The Great Angel: A Study of Israel's Second God (1992) · Westminster John Knox / SPCK · source
“Jesus was a manifestation of Yahweh, and was acknowledged as Son of God, Messiah, and Lord.”
The Great Angel: A Study of Israel's Second God (1992) · Westminster John Knox / SPCK · source
In context: She argues that pre-Christian Israel recognised a High God and several sons of God, with Yahweh among them.
What this does not claim: Her reconstruction is disputed (Schäfer, Paul), and she does not affirm a plurality of gods as present-day belief.
In context: She argues that the earliest Christians identified Jesus with Yahweh, a son of God Most High distinct from him.
What this does not claim: She is a Trinitarian. This does not show that the Father has a body or that she accepts the Latter-day Saint Godhead.
Caveat
CaveatBarker's First Temple reconstructions are her own arguments, which specialists dispute (Schäfer, Paul, Twigg). She is an independent scholar and does not endorse Latter-day Saint claims.
Daniel Boyarin
Two powers in heaven
“Part of the evidence for this very cult will come from efforts at its suppression on the part of rabbinic texts.”
Beyond Judaisms: Metatron and the Divine Polymorphy of Ancient Judaism (2010) · Journal for the Study of Judaism 41.3, Brill · pp. 323-365 · source
In context: His peer-reviewed work shows that some ancient Jews believed in a second divine figure next to the Most High (Memra/Logos, son of man, Metatron) before and alongside early Christianity.
What this does not claim: He reads this as an early form of the Trinity and does not argue for separate embodied beings. His Daniel 7 reading is disputed (Schäfer prefers the archangel Michael).
In context: Documents a long-lived Jewish 'two powers' tradition that the rabbis only later labelled heresy.
What this does not claim: Two figures, not a divine council or many gods; it says nothing about Ps 82 or Deut 32.
Caveat
CaveatBoyarin finds two divine figures, not a council of many gods, and reads them as an early form of the Trinity. His Daniel 7 reading is disputed (Schäfer, Schremer).
James F. McGrath
Jesus as God's distinct agent
“as the one to whom God has given authority as his agent and viceroy…”
John's Apologetic Christology (2001) · Cambridge University Press (SNTSMS 111) · ch. 8, Conclusion to part 2, pp. 145-148 · source · quotation source
In context: He argues that in John and in first-century Jewish monotheism, Jesus is God's authorised agent, distinct from the one God, and that defining divine oneness by ontology is a post-Nicene framework.
What this does not claim: Historical claim only. He does not reject the Trinity, does not argue that Father and Son are separate embodied beings, and creedal theology also distinguishes the persons.
Caveat
CaveatMcGrath argues as a historian that Jews defined monotheism by worship, not by what God is made of. He does not argue for an embodied God or pre-existence, and he is not persuaded by the Latter-day Saint reading of 1 Cor 15:29.
Alan F. Segal
Two Powers in Heaven, the source study
“The basic heresy involved interpreting scripture to say that a principal angelic or hypostatic manifestation in heaven was equivalent to God.”
Two Powers in Heaven (1977) · E. J. Brill (SJLA 25); reissued Brill 2002, Baylor UP 2012 · source · quotation source
In context: Segal shows that before the rabbis some Jews read scripture as placing a principal figure in heaven, in human form and carrying God's name, who was equivalent to God, and that the earliest versions saw the two powers as complementary.
What this does not claim: Historical description only. It is binitarian (God plus one figure), does not show the Father has a tangible body, and Segal did not endorse the belief. Later scholars (Boyarin, McGrath) debate its dating and framing.
Caveat
CaveatSegal described the 'two powers' belief as history and did not hold it; he found a second divine figure, not a council of many gods.
Jürgen Moltmann
A social Trinity and a God who suffers
“cease to understand God monotheistically as the one, absolute subject…”
The Trinity and the Kingdom (1980; Eng. 1981) · Harper & Row / SCM; Fortress (1993 pbk) · source · quotation source
In context: He argued for starting from three persons in relation, united by mutual indwelling, against single-subject models.
What this does not claim: He keeps one God, rejects tritheism, and does not hold that Father and Son are separate beings.
Caveat
CaveatMoltmann is a systematic theologian; this is theology, not biblical evidence. He affirms creation from nothing and rejects tritheism.
3

Does the Bible picture God with a body?

Topic: Embodied God · 12 scholars
James L. Kugel
The embodied God of the earliest texts
“The God of Old was not invisible or abstract.”
The God of Old: Inside the Lost World of the Bible (2003) · Free Press · xi-xii, 5-6, 104-6, 134-35 (pages cited by Holland, note 17) · source
“God is no longer described as having a human-sized and human-shaped body…”
The Great Shift: Encountering God in Biblical Times (2017) · Houghton Mifflin Harcourt · source
In context: Kugel argues that the earliest biblical narratives present a God who appears in human form and is described with a human-sized, human-shaped body. The abstract, invisible God came later.
What this does not claim: This is historical description, not belief: Kugel treats the early view as superseded. He says nothing about a permanent glorified body, or about the Father and Son as distinct beings.
Caveat
CaveatKugel treats the human-form God as an early stage later superseded, and his critical method treats much biblical narrative as non-historical.
Benjamin D. Sommer
Revelation and divine embodiment
“no biblical (or rabbinic) authors believed in a non-corporeal deity.”
The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (2009) · Cambridge University Press · Introduction (pp. 1-11); chs. 2-3 (pp. 38-79) · source · quotation source
In context: A leading Jewish scholar argues from the texts that biblical (and rabbinic) authors took God's embodiment literally and that the bodiless God is a later teaching.
What this does not claim: He does not argue for a body of flesh and bones, nor for the Father and Son as separate beings. His preferred model is one God in many bodies at once.
Caveat
CaveatSommer's 'fluidity' model, one God present in many bodies at once, differs from Latter-day Saint teaching, and he does not argue for a body of flesh and bones.
Brittany E. Wilson
The New Testament's visible, embodied God
“she is clear that God has a tangible and visible form…”
The Embodied God: Seeing the Divine in Luke-Acts and the Early Church (2021) · Oxford University Press · source · quotation source
“than the unknowable, incorporeal God of modern-day classical theism”
Forming God: Divine Anthropomorphism in Luke-Acts (2021) · Journal of Biblical Literature 140.4: 775-795 · pp. 775-795 · source
“lack an explicit anti-anthropomorphic agenda…”
The Scriptural Shape of God: Divine Anthropomorphisms in Synoptic Perspective (2023) · New Testament Studies 69.2: 138-153 · pp. 138-153 · source
“the long-held claim that God is immaterial”
God's Body and the Material Turn: Divine (Im)Materiality in Biblical Theophanies (2024) · Harvard Theological Review 117.3: 607-630 · pp. 607-630 · source
“bodies are worthy of the heavenly realm, since Jesus is a human in heaven.”
The Embodied God (2021), 'Beholding the Human One' · Oxford University Press · pp. 231-270 · source
“finds its most concrete expression in the flesh-and-bone body of Jesus”
The Embodied God (2021), 'Visually Verifying the Corporeal Christ' · Oxford University Press · pp. 193-230 · source
In context: She argues that Luke-Acts and the Synoptics portray God as visible, concrete and anthropomorphic, and that the incorporeal God belongs to Platonic philosophy and later classical theism, not to the texts.
What this does not claim: She treats God's body as fluid and multiform, with the anthropomorphism at the level of literary representation; she does not argue that God the Father has a body of flesh and bones like ours (D&C 130:22).
In context: She shows the Synoptics take over divine anthropomorphisms from Jewish Scripture without any anti-anthropomorphic agenda, with Luke the most anthropomorphic.
What this does not claim: This is about how the Gospels portray God, not a metaphysical claim about the nature of God's body.
In context: She reads Luke's resurrection and ascension accounts as verifying Jesus's flesh and carrying his body into heaven, so bodies are worthy of the heavenly realm.
What this does not claim: Her argument concerns Jesus; it says nothing about exaltation of others, eternal marriage or family.
Caveat
CaveatWilson treats God's body as fluid and multiform, not a body of flesh and bones like ours, and she is not cited for D&C 130:22. Her argument extends Benjamin Sommer's.
Francesca Stavrakopoulou
The embodied God of the Hebrew Bible
“a human-shaped deity who walks and talks and weeps and laughs, who eats, sleeps, feels, and breathes, and who is undeniably male”
God: An Anatomy (2021) · Picador (UK) / Knopf (US, 2022) · source
“divine corporeality is essential to divine sociality…”
Divine Corporeality in the Hebrew Bible (2026) · Liverpool University Press (Modern Believing 67.2) · pp. 133-142 · source · quotation source
In context: She argues in a trade book and a peer-reviewed article that the Hebrew Bible's writers and worshippers understood Yahweh as truly embodied and human-shaped, and that the image ban does not imply he had no body.
What this does not claim: She describes what ancient texts and people believed, not what God is; she thinks the embodied God is a human projection. Moberly (JTS 2024) argues she undervalues metaphor.
Caveat
CaveatStavrakopoulou, an atheist, treats the Bible as human religious history, not revelation. God: An Anatomy is a trade book with explicit material that its Latter-day Saint reviewer says will at points offend.
John Day
The divine council, God's image and Asherah
“the natural conclusion is that there is similarly a physical likeness between God and human beings.”
From Creation to Abraham: Further Studies in Genesis 1-11 (2022) · T&T Clark / Bloomsbury · ch. on Genesis 1.27, pp. 25-32 · source · quotation source
“it is better to suppose that both a physical and spiritual likeness is envisaged”
From Creation to Babel: Studies in Genesis 1-11 (2013) · Bloomsbury T&T Clark · pp. 13-14 · source · quotation source
In context: An Oxford Hebrew Bible scholar argues from Gen 5:3 that the Genesis image includes a physical likeness between God and humans.
What this does not claim: This is a claim about what the Priestly writer meant. Day does not argue that God has a body of flesh and bone, or that the Father and Son are distinct beings.
Caveat
CaveatDay treats strict monotheism as a later development and Asherah worship as syncretism the biblical writers rejected; he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching.
Christoph Markschies
God's body in ancient Judaism and Christianity
“it was only with the advent of medieval scholasticism that the idea that God has a body became scandalous…”
God's Body: Jewish, Christian, and Pagan Images of God (2019); German original Gottes Körper (2016) · Baylor University Press; C.H. Beck · Ch. 2 and Ch. 6 (English pp. 19-73, 182-282) · source · quotation source
In context: Shows that a bodily God was a serious position held by educated Jews, pagan philosophers and Christians (e.g. Melito of Sardis), not just by unlearned people, and that Origen and Clement argued against people who held it.
What this does not claim: Ancient 'body' talk often meant a refined or ethereal substance, not flesh and bones. Markschies describes the belief without endorsing it, and his own conclusion warns against simply identifying God's body with the human body.
Caveat
CaveatMarkschies documents the ancient belief in God's body; he does not hold it, and ancient 'body' language often meant a refined substance, not flesh and bones. Not cited for D&C 130:22.
Alexander Golitzin
The Glory in human form; the anthropomorphite monks
“Were they, I wonder, the simpletons our sources make them out to be?”
The Form of God and Vision of the Glory: Some Thoughts on the Anthropomorphite Controversy of 399 AD (1998; Romanian tr. in Mistagogia); revised as 'The Vision of God and the Form of Glory' in Abba (2003) · Deisis, Sibiu (1998); St Vladimir's Seminary Press (2003) · source
In context: He argues the monks condemned in 399 held 'a Christology of very ancient provenance' rooted in biblical and Jewish visions of the Glory in human form (Ezek 1, Isa 6, Dan 7), not a peasant error.
What this does not claim: He identifies the form with the Son/Glory and says the Father is 'not at issue'; he himself holds the classical view that the divine nature is beyond form, and does not argue the Father has a tangible body.
Caveat
CaveatGolitzin identifies the divine form with the Son, the Glory; the Father is 'not at issue'. The older tradition was recast and turned inward in monastic mysticism, not simply suppressed.
Jacob Neusner
Rabbinic portrayals of God; an open Torah
“why is it that in the pages of the Bavli in particular the process of incarnation reaches the person of God?”
The Incarnation of God: The Character of Divinity in Formative Judaism (1988); 'Is the God of Judaism Incarnate?' (1988) · Fortress Press; Religious Studies (Cambridge UP) 24:2 · Religious Studies 24:2, pp. 213-238 · source
“In the formative documents of the Torah in its oral version, that same conviction of God's corporeality … governs.”
Conversation in Nauvoo about the Corporeality of God (1996-97) · BYU Studies 36:1 · pp. 6-30 (abstract only read) · source
In context: Neusner documents that classical rabbinic literature, culminating in the Babylonian Talmud, portrays God with a body, emotions and human actions, and argues that 'incarnation' is not foreign to Judaism.
What this does not claim: He describes how the texts portray God and treats incarnation as a mode of thought; he does not argue that God has a body, he puts the human likeness to God in the spiritual, not the corporeal, and his evidence is late (Bavli), not early biblical.
Caveat
CaveatNeusner describes how the rabbinic texts portray God; he did not claim that God has a body. Torah study as continuing revelation is a rabbinic parallel, not support for living prophets. Lieberman, Sanders and others criticised his translations and method.
David M. Moffitt
Hebrews, resurrection and Christ's heavenly priesthood
“his resurrection, ascension, offering, and exaltation.”
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2011); Rethinking the Atonement (2022) · Brill; Baker Academic · source
In context: In Hebrews, Christ's bodily resurrection and ascension are the hinge of his saving work; atonement is completed when the risen Jesus presents himself in the heavenly sanctuary.
What this does not claim: He places the atoning offering in heaven, not in Gethsemane, which cuts against the LDS emphasis on Gethsemane and Calvary; and in his account resurrection is the precondition of the offering, whereas 2 Nephi 9 treats it as a result of the atonement.
Caveat
CaveatMoffitt places Christ's atoning offering in heaven after the resurrection, not at Gethsemane or Calvary, and his thesis is contested. His priesthood argument concerns Christ's own priesthood.
Silviu N. Bunta
Shared divinity, deification and God's face
“as an open and ongoing divine embodiment to be had by the visionary and the hearer-speaker”
'The Divine Face as Theopoeia in the Psalter' (2025); The Lord God of Gods (2021) · ROOTS; Gorgias Press · article pp. 48–50; book chs. 6, 14, 16 · source
In context: He argues early Jewish theology conceives a divinity that is 'fluid and physical, both embodied and shared', and that God's face in the Psalms is a real embodiment.
What this does not claim: An embodied divine face and glory are not the same claim as a tangible body of flesh and bone for the Father (D&C 130:22).
Caveat
CaveatBunta's model is one divine selfhood shared with 'gods' and humans, not many separate gods; the book also traces periods that exclude humans from the Godhead. He formerly taught at the University of Dayton.
Thomas Römer
Asherah, the cult image and early plurality
“Chapter 8 discusses the statue of YHWH that would have existed in the temple in Jerusalem…”
The Invention of God (2015) · Harvard University Press · ch. 8 · source
In context: He argues against original aniconism: a statue of Yhwh probably stood in the First Temple.
What this does not claim: A cult image is not a claim that God has a body; he also notes that no surviving image has been positively identified as Yhwh.
Caveat
CaveatRömer presents monotheism as a late development out of polytheism, and he does not link Asherah to a Heavenly Mother.
Jürgen Moltmann
A social Trinity and a God who suffers
“The Crucified God posited that God died on the Cross, raising the question of the impassibility of God.”
The Crucified God (1972; Eng. 1974) · SCM / Harper & Row; Fortress (40th anniv. ed. 2015) · source · quotation source
In context: The leading modern Protestant theologian argued that God truly suffers in the cross, and that the impassible God comes from Greek metaphysics rather than from the gospel.
What this does not claim: Does not argue that God has a body or a divine form, and does not treat the Trinity as a product of Hellenization.
Caveat
CaveatMoltmann is a systematic theologian; this is theology, not biblical evidence. He affirms creation from nothing and rejects tritheism.
4

Did early Christians see the LORD of the Old Testament as Christ?

Topic: Yahweh (Jehovah) as Christ · 4 scholars
Margaret Barker
Temple Theology
“Yahweh was a son of God, manifested on earth in human form as an angel or in the Davidic King.”
The Great Angel: A Study of Israel's Second God (1992) · Westminster John Knox / SPCK · source
“Jesus was a manifestation of Yahweh, and was acknowledged as Son of God, Messiah, and Lord.”
The Great Angel: A Study of Israel's Second God (1992) · Westminster John Knox / SPCK · source
In context: She argues that pre-Christian Israel recognised a High God and several sons of God, with Yahweh among them.
What this does not claim: Her reconstruction is disputed (Schäfer, Paul), and she does not affirm a plurality of gods as present-day belief.
In context: She argues that the earliest Christians identified Jesus with Yahweh, a son of God Most High distinct from him.
What this does not claim: She is a Trinitarian. This does not show that the Father has a body or that she accepts the Latter-day Saint Godhead.
Caveat
CaveatBarker's First Temple reconstructions are her own arguments, which specialists dispute (Schäfer, Paul, Twigg). She is an independent scholar and does not endorse Latter-day Saint claims.
Bogdan G. Bucur
The premortal Son in Old Testament theophanies
“early Christians saw not only a type or allegory but instead the divine Lord Himself in Old Testament narratives”
Scripture Re-envisioned: Christophanic Exegesis and the Making of a Christian Bible (2018) · Brill · source
In context: He documents that the identification of the LORD of the theophanies with the Son was the common reading from the second century through the first millennium (Justin, Irenaeus, Tertullian, Melito and others).
What this does not claim: The Fathers read the Son as the visible manifestation of the one God whose Father is invisible by nature; that is not the Latter-day Saint view of the Father and Son as separate embodied beings, and Bucur writes as an Orthodox, Nicene theologian.
Caveat
CaveatBucur's subject is the Son appearing in the theophanies; he says nothing of an embodied Father.
Alan F. Segal
Two Powers in Heaven, the source study
“The basic heresy involved interpreting scripture to say that a principal angelic or hypostatic manifestation in heaven was equivalent to God.”
Two Powers in Heaven (1977) · E. J. Brill (SJLA 25); reissued Brill 2002, Baylor UP 2012 · source · quotation source
In context: Segal shows that before the rabbis some Jews read scripture as placing a principal figure in heaven, in human form and carrying God's name, who was equivalent to God, and that the earliest versions saw the two powers as complementary.
What this does not claim: Historical description only. It is binitarian (God plus one figure), does not show the Father has a tangible body, and Segal did not endorse the belief. Later scholars (Boyarin, McGrath) debate its dating and framing.
Caveat
CaveatSegal described the 'two powers' belief as history and did not hold it; he found a second divine figure, not a council of many gods.
Alexander Golitzin
The Glory in human form; the anthropomorphite monks
“Were they, I wonder, the simpletons our sources make them out to be?”
The Form of God and Vision of the Glory: Some Thoughts on the Anthropomorphite Controversy of 399 AD (1998; Romanian tr. in Mistagogia); revised as 'The Vision of God and the Form of Glory' in Abba (2003) · Deisis, Sibiu (1998); St Vladimir's Seminary Press (2003) · source
In context: He argues the monks condemned in 399 held 'a Christology of very ancient provenance' rooted in biblical and Jewish visions of the Glory in human form (Ezek 1, Isa 6, Dan 7), not a peasant error.
What this does not claim: He identifies the form with the Son/Glory and says the Father is 'not at issue'; he himself holds the classical view that the divine nature is beyond form, and does not argue the Father has a tangible body.
Caveat
CaveatGolitzin identifies the divine form with the Son, the Glory; the Father is 'not at issue'. The older tradition was recast and turned inward in monastic mysticism, not simply suppressed.
5

Did early Christians believe people can become like God?

Topic: Deification and exaltation · 12 scholars
Norman Russell
Deification in the Greek Fathers
“is essentially biblical and not a Hellenistic importation…”
The Doctrine of Deification in the Greek Patristic Tradition (2004) · Oxford University Press · source · quotation source
“insists that deification as an eschatological reality is open to every baptized person.”
Second- and Third-Century Greek Fathers, in The Oxford Handbook of Deification (2024) · Oxford University Press · pp. 95-107 · source
“Theosis, originally a Greek term for Christian divinisation or deification, has become a vogue word in modern theology.”
Theosis and Religion (2024) · Cambridge University Press · source
In context: Shows that the Greek Fathers from the second century on spoke of the redeemed becoming 'gods', grounded in Psalm 82:6, John 10:34 and 2 Peter 1:4, with roots in Jewish exegesis rather than pagan import.
What this does not claim: The Fathers, and Russell, mean participation in God's life by grace while remaining creatures; it does not show that humans are God's literal offspring or can become the same kind of being as God.
In context: Traces theosis into the late-medieval West through Dionysius the Areopagite and into modern Western theology.
What this does not claim: Concerns post-biblical reception history, not biblical exegesis.
Caveat
CaveatRussell, an Orthodox scholar, presents deification as participation in God's life by grace, never in God's essence. Inferences Latter-day Saint reviewers draw from his book are theirs, not his. (Not the Anglican archdeacon of the same name.)
Michael J. Gorman
Paul, participation in Christ and theosis
“transformative participation in the life of the Triune God…”
Abide and Go: Missional Theosis in the Gospel of John (2018) · Cascade Books (Wipf and Stock) · p. xvii (as quoted in review) · source
In context: A mainstream Protestant New Testament scholar argues from Paul and John that salvation is transformative participation in God's life, which the tradition calls theosis.
What this does not claim: His theosis is becoming like God in character within the Trinity; it does not support becoming gods, eternal progression, or God and humans being one kind of being.
Caveat
CaveatGorman describes theosis as transformation into God's own character by sharing in Christ's life. He holds the classical Christian distinction between Creator and creature, so he does not teach exaltation in the Latter-day Saint sense.
Matthew Thiessen
Gentiles made Abraham's seed through the Spirit
“a whole new generation of sons of God had come and would be coming into existence…”
Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016); A Jewish Paul (2023) · Oxford University Press; Baker Academic · PGP ch. 5, p. 155; AJP ch. 10, p. 126 · source · quotation source
In context: He argues historically that Paul expected Spirit-filled gentiles to become sons of God and to reach full divinity at the resurrection, as star-like heirs of Abraham.
What this does not claim: This is his reconstruction of Paul's first-century cosmology, contested by other Pauline scholars; it does not establish premortal spirit parentage, exaltation or eternal marriage, and Thiessen does not endorse LDS teaching.
Caveat
CaveatThiessen's reading of Paul is his historical reconstruction, and his Stoic-leaning account of the spirit is contested. The pneumatic resurrection body he describes is not flesh and bones.
Michael S. Heiser
The divine council in the Hebrew Bible
“also known as glorification / deification / apotheosis…”
The Unseen Realm (2015) · Lexham Press · chs. 35–36 · source
In context: He reads Hebrews 1–2 and union with Christ as glorification and deification: believers become God's children and heirs and take part in the divine council.
What this does not claim: He denies that humans become gods like Yahweh or that God was once a man; this is deification in a creedal Christian sense, not LDS exaltation.
Caveat
CaveatHeiser disagreed with Latter-day Saint readings of Psalm 82, in a 2007 FARMS Review exchange with the Latter-day Saint scholar David Bokovoy: he held that Yahweh is unique in kind, not the same kind of being as the other elohim, and that creation was ultimately out of nothing.
Crispin Fletcher-Louis
Temple, the image of God and the identity of Jesus
“by which Christ became what we are, in order that humans might become what he is.”
The Divine Heartset (2023) · Cascade Books (Wipf and Stock) · ch. 14 · source
In context: He reads Philippians 3:21 as Paul offering believers a deification through conformity to Christ, who became what humans are so that humans might become what he is.
What this does not claim: Deification here is participation in Christ within a Nicene framework, not becoming a god as God's literal offspring, nor exaltation in the LDS sense.
In context: He documents Qumran texts that portray a restored Adamic humanity, especially priests, as transcendent, angelomorphic or divine.
What this does not claim: The status belongs to the community's worship and its priests, not to a universal destiny of all God's children; it does not show belief in human premortal divinity.
Caveat
CaveatFletcher-Louis holds a Christology of two persons within the one divine identity; he does not argue for the Father and the Son as separate beings.
M. David Litwa
Deification in Paul; "You are gods"
“It is a sharing in a/the divine identity, i.e., sharing in those distinctive qualities which make (a) God (a) God (p. 32).”
We Are Being Transformed: Deification in Paul's Soteriology (2012) · de Gruyter (BZNW 187) · p. 32 (definition); whole monograph · source · quotation source
“He is one of the few I have seen who makes no significant mistakes in talking about deification in Mormonism.”
Becoming Divine: An Introduction to Deification in Western Culture (2013) · Cascade Books (Wipf & Stock) · pp. 201-203 · source · quotation source
In context: A de Gruyter monograph argues that Paul's soteriology is a type of deification: believers share God's distinctive qualities (immortality, power, moral likeness) through conformity to Christ.
What this does not claim: The thesis is disputed (Orr, Themelios 38.2). It describes sharing divine attributes without fusion and says nothing of literal divine parentage, premortal sonship or eternal increase.
Caveat
CaveatLitwa's Pauline thesis is disputed (Orr, Themelios 38.2). His wider work treats the Gospels as myth shaped into history.
Philip S. Alexander
Worship with the angels in the heavenly temple
“has a throne and presides over a celestial law court.”
3 (Hebrew Apocalypse of) Enoch, in The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha vol. 1 (1983) · Doubleday · pp. 223-315 (intro pp. 235, 244) · source · quotation source
In context: Documents a Jewish tradition in which the man Enoch is transformed, enthroned and called 'the lesser YHWH', and reads 1 Enoch 71:14 as identifying Enoch with the heavenly Son of Man.
What this does not claim: 3 Enoch's final form is 5th-6th c. AD; Metatron remains subordinate and is demoted in ch. 16; he describes the texts and does not endorse the belief.
Caveat
Caveat3 Enoch is a late-antique text (final form 5th-6th century AD) that Alexander translated: the exaltation of Enoch is what the text presents, and he reads Metatron's demotion in ch. 16 as a later orthodox addition.
Alexander Schmemann
Marriage fulfilled in the Kingdom; worship as ascent
“покуда смерть и переход в вечность не соединит навеки…”
For the Life of the World: Sacraments and Orthodoxy (1963/1973) · St Vladimir's Seminary Press · ch. 5 (marriage chapter, 'The Mystery of Love') · source
In context: A leading Orthodox theologian argues from the wedding rite (the crowning) that the vow is taken until death unites the spouses for ever, with the Kingdom of God as marriage's fulfilment.
What this does not claim: This is liturgical theology, not exegesis of Matt 22:30. It says nothing about temple sealing, priesthood authority to seal, or eternal family structures, and he would not endorse LDS sealing.
Caveat
CaveatSchmemann is an Orthodox liturgical theologian. The anointing he describes is every baptised Christian's share in Christ's priesthood, not an ordained priesthood, and marriage in the Kingdom is not sealing. He defends infant baptism and an unbroken Orthodox tradition.
Hugo Méndez
Deification as the purpose of John's Gospel
“Jesus is a celestial, divine being who has come to earth to transform humans into celestial, divine beings like himself”
The Gospel of John: A New History (2025) · Oxford University Press · ch. 2, 'Why John Was Written', pp. 26-62 · source · quotation source
In context: A peer-reviewed Oxford study argues that transforming humans into divine beings like Christ is the central message of one of the four canonical Gospels, not a later patristic or Greek add-on.
What this does not claim: He attributes the idea to the evangelist and argues the historical Jesus never taught it. He argues John is falsely authored. He describes divinization as new spirit-existence, heavenly access and angel-like status, not LDS exaltation, eternal progression or literal divine parentage. He does not endorse LDS teaching.
Caveat
CaveatMéndez holds that John's Gospel is falsely authored and its beloved-disciple eyewitness invented, that deification is the evangelist's theology rather than Jesus' own teaching, and that John's 'last day' is already realized.
Martha Himmelfarb
Heaven as temple; ascent as priestly investiture
“the permeability of the boundary between angels and humanity…”
Ascent to Heaven in Jewish and Christian Apocalypses (1993) · Oxford University Press · ch. 3 'Transformation and the Righteous Dead' · source
In context: She documents ancient Jewish texts in which the righteous visionary is transformed and given a place among the angels, and she stresses the permeability of the boundary between angels and humanity.
What this does not claim: This is transformation into angels, not deification or exaltation to godhood. The angelic reading of 2 Enoch 22 is disputed (Otto, JSP 2024).
Caveat
CaveatHimmelfarb reads the ascent texts as literature that borrows priestly imagery, not as a record of an actual rite. Becoming like the angels is angelification, not deification, and she is not shown as agreeing with Barker.
Sebastian P. Brock
The robe of glory in early Syriac Christianity
“He gave us divinity, we gave Him humanity.”
The Robe of Glory (1999); The Luminous Eye (1985; rev. 1992) · The Way; Cistercian Publications · The Way p. 257; Luminous Eye pp. 152-154 · source · quotation source
In context: Brock shows deification ('Divinization, or theosis') at the centre of the earliest Semitic-language Christian theology, independent of the Greek fathers.
What this does not claim: In Ephrem it is deification by grace, with a strict Creator/creature distinction. It is not literal divine parentage or exaltation to godhood in the LDS sense.
Caveat
CaveatBrock describes a baptismal tradition, not a temple rite; the deification he finds in Ephrem is by grace. Feminine language for the Spirit is not a separate Heavenly Mother.
Joel Marcus
James 1:1: Gentile converts as the lost tribes
“a glorified picture of human destiny…”
Son of Man as Son of Adam, Parts I–II (2003) · Revue Biblique 110 · pp. 38–61; 370–386 · source · quotation source
In context: He reads the Gospels' 'Son of Man' against Jewish traditions of Adam as a figure of great glory, even godlikeness, giving a glorified picture of human destiny.
What this does not claim: It concerns Adamic glory and Jesus' self-designation, not deification as a teaching or humans as God's literal offspring.
Caveat
CaveatMarcus describes what James means; he does not argue for the gathering himself. His John the Baptist in History and Theology (2018) argues that John saw himself, not Jesus, as the one who began the kingdom, and that early Christians played down a rivalry between their followers.
6

Does the Bible teach that we lived before birth?

Topic: Premortal existence · 1 scholar
David Winston
Wisdom 8:19-20: souls that exist before the body
“are meant to suggest the preexistence of souls of varying spiritual capacities”
Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources (1978) · BYU Religious Studies Center · pp. 13-35 · source
In context: Winston shows that Wisdom 8:19-20 (1st century BCE) and Philo teach souls existing before the body, and says the verse should not be explained away.
What this does not claim: Second Temple Apocrypha, not the Hebrew Bible. He sees partial Platonic influence and possibly a soul created just before embodiment; nothing about a premortal council or spirit birth.
Caveat
CaveatWinston, a historian and rabbi, reads Wisdom's pre-existent souls and formless matter as Hellenistic Jewish ideas shaped partly by Platonism, not as teachings he endorses. In his 1978 essay for BYU's Religious Studies Center he compared them with Latter-day Saint teaching, noting differences as well as parallels.
7

Does the Bible know of a divine feminine?

Topic: Heavenly Mother · 5 scholars
Margaret Barker
Temple Theology
“This is the Heavenly Mother, represented by the tree of life, and then Mary and her Son on earth.”
'Joseph Smith and Preexilic Israelite Religion' (2005); The Mother of the Lord, Vol. 1 (2012) · BYU Studies 44:4; T&T Clark · BYU Studies 44:4, from p. 69 · source
In context: She reconstructs a divine Lady, Wisdom, in the First Temple who was purged under Josiah, and she calls her the Heavenly Mother.
What this does not claim: Her Mother is the mother of the divine Son and leads into Marian devotion; she is not presented as the Father's consort or the mother of all spirits.
Caveat
CaveatBarker's First Temple reconstructions are her own arguments, which specialists dispute (Schäfer, Paul, Twigg). She is an independent scholar and does not endorse Latter-day Saint claims.
William G. Dever
Archaeology of Asherah beside Yahweh
“had a consort, that her name was Asherah, and that she was part of the Canaanite pantheon.”
Did God Have a Wife? Archaeology and Folk Religion in Ancient Israel (2005) · Eerdmans · source · quotation source
In context: Inscriptions at Kuntillet ʿAjrud and Khirbet el-Qôm pair Yahweh with 'his Asherah', and Judean household figurines are widespread; Dever argues that many Israelites venerated a goddess alongside Yahweh, not instead of him.
What this does not claim: Dever treats this as folk religion that the biblical writers opposed, and he believes in no deity himself. The reading is contested (W. D. Barker, Wiggins, Sommer), and the LDS reviewer Von Feldt explicitly declines to call Heavenly Mother teaching a restoration of Asherah belief.
Caveat
CaveatDever, a self-described non-theist, reads the Asherah cult as folk religion opposed by the biblical writers; his consort thesis is contested. The main Latter-day Saint review (Von Feldt, 2007) declines to call Heavenly Mother a restoration of Asherah belief.
Thomas Römer
Asherah, the cult image and early plurality
“The goddess returned in a certain way through the personification of Wisdom in Proverbs 8…”
Yhwh, the Goddess and Evil (2013) · AOSIS, Verbum et Ecclesia · Introduction; 'The new wives of Yhwh'; Conclusion · source
In context: He argues that Asherah was worshipped as Yhwh's consort, including in the Jerusalem temple, and that the goddess partly returns as personified Wisdom.
What this does not claim: This is history of a cult the biblical writers condemned. He does not identify her with a divine Mother of human spirits, and he pairs her with Yhwh, whom LDS teaching identifies with Christ.
Caveat
CaveatRömer presents monotheism as a late development out of polytheism, and he does not link Asherah to a Heavenly Mother.
Saul M. Olyan
Asherah and Yahweh's incomparability
“before the reforming kings in Judah, the asherah seems to have been entirely legitimate…”
Asherah and the Cult of Yahweh in Israel (1988) · Scholars Press (SBL Monograph Series 34) · pp. 73–74 (legitimacy); pp. 29, 33–34, 38, 74 (consort), as cited by Peterson · source · quotation source
In context: His monograph argues the asherah was a legitimate part of Yahweh's state and popular cult, opposed only by Deuteronomistic reformers, and that Asherah seems to have been regarded as Yahweh's consort.
What this does not claim: A historical reconstruction of monarchic-era religion; it does not identify Asherah with a Heavenly Mother or make any theological claim; the consort view is hedged.
Caveat
CaveatOlyan's consort reading is hedged ('seems'), and in Isaiah 40-55 the heavenly host are no longer called gods.
Elaine Pagels
Opening the non-canonical early Christian writings
“certain of these texts describe God as a dyadic being, who consists of both masculine and feminine elements.”
"What Became of God the Mother? Conflicting Images of God in Early Christianity," Signs (1976); The Gnostic Gospels (1979), ch. 3 · University of Chicago Press (Signs); Random House · Gnostic Gospels ch. 3, "God the Father/God the Mother" · source · quotation source
In context: She documents early Christian texts that picture God as a Father-Mother pair, or the Mother as Spirit or Wisdom, and asks why these images disappeared from orthodoxy.
What this does not claim: These are Gnostic, largely abstract figures, not a distinct embodied Heavenly Mother.
Caveat
CaveatThe Gnostic texts Pagels treats sympathetically reject bodily resurrection and church hierarchy, so she is not cited for either. Specialists criticised her popular books for overstatement, and her diverse early Christianity is not the Latter-day Saint account of one church losing its authority.
8

Did God create the world out of nothing?

Topic: Creation from existing matter · 2 scholars
Gerhard May
How creation out of nothing became Christian teaching
“not demanded by the text of the Bible…”
Creatio ex Nihilo: The Doctrine of 'Creation out of Nothing' in Early Christian Thought (1994; German original 1978) · T&T Clark (orig. Walter de Gruyter) · p. 24 · source
“the first Christian theologian known to us who expressly advanced the proposition that matter was produced by God…”
Creatio ex Nihilo (1994) · T&T Clark · pp. 149-50 · source · quotation source
“in no way necessarily implied that matter also was something created.”
Creatio ex Nihilo (1994) · T&T Clark · p. 152 · source
In context: May's history finds that the biblical text does not demand creation out of nothing, that Jewish 'out of nothing' language did not necessarily exclude pre-existent matter, and that the explicit teaching appears with Tatian, Theophilus and Irenaeus in the late 2nd century.
What this does not claim: May does not say the Bible teaches creation from pre-existing matter; he judged ex nihilo consistent with the Old Testament and affirmed it. Bockmuehl (2012) and Copan argue for earlier Jewish roots.
Caveat
CaveatMay affirmed creation from nothing himself and judged it to fit the Old Testament; his thesis is about when the teaching was formulated. His dating is contested (Bockmuehl, 2012).
David Winston
Wisdom 8:19-20: souls that exist before the body
“its first explicit formulation appeared in second-century Christian literature”
Preexistence in Hellenic, Judaic, and Mormon Sources (1978) · BYU Religious Studies Center · pp. 13-35 · source
In context: He argues that Wisdom 11:17 assumes eternal formless matter and that creation from nothing first appears explicitly in second-century Christian writers.
What this does not claim: Contested (Goldstein, Copan); it shows the history of the idea, not what Genesis 1 must mean.
Caveat
CaveatWinston, a historian and rabbi, reads Wisdom's pre-existent souls and formless matter as Hellenistic Jewish ideas shaped partly by Platonism, not as teachings he endorses. In his 1978 essay for BYU's Religious Studies Center he compared them with Latter-day Saint teaching, noting differences as well as parallels.
9

Did early Christians believe we inherit Adam's guilt?

Ziony Zevit
Eden as a rise into moral discernment, not inherited guilt
“It is not the story of a decline but of a rise.”
What Really Happened in the Garden of Eden? (2013) · Yale University Press · p. 264 · source · quotation source
“our ideas about original sin are based upon misconceptions originating in the Second Temple period…”
What Really Happened in the Garden of Eden? (2013) · Yale University Press · source
In context: He argues Genesis 2–3 contains no teaching of inherited sin and that the idea arose in Hellenistic-era interpretation.
What this does not claim: He also denies that the story describes a Fall at all, which Latter-day Saints affirm.
Caveat
CaveatZevit concludes that Genesis 2-3 tells of no Fall at all, and suggests, tentatively, that Adam and Eve were mortal from the start. He is cited here for no inherited guilt and for the story as a rise into moral discernment; his Asherah and creation readings are secondary.
10

Is Christ's atonement something believers share in?

Michael J. Gorman
Paul, participation in Christ and theosis
“the genuinely juridical categories in Paul”
Inhabiting the Cruciform God (2009) · Eerdmans · source
In context: A mainstream Protestant New Testament scholar argues from Paul and John that salvation is transformative participation in God's life, which the tradition calls theosis.
What this does not claim: His theosis is becoming like God in character within the Trinity; it does not support becoming gods, eternal progression, or God and humans being one kind of being.
In context: He reads justification as transformation into covenant faithfulness through co-crucifixion with Christ, not a bare legal verdict.
What this does not claim: He frames this wholly as grace-enabled participation; it does not address LDS ordinances or covenant-making as such.
Caveat
CaveatGorman describes theosis as transformation into God's own character by sharing in Christ's life. He holds the classical Christian distinction between Creator and creature, so he does not teach exaltation in the Latter-day Saint sense.
Brant Pitre
Jesus, the Twelve and the Seventy, and the gathering of all twelve tribes
“Paul is best viewed as a new covenant Jew.”
Paul, a New Covenant Jew (2019, with Michael P. Barber and John A. Kincaid) · Eerdmans · source
In context: He and his co-authors read Pauline justification as real transformation within a new covenant, with grace enabling works.
What this does not claim: The framework is Catholic and sacramental, and the book is co-authored.
Caveat
CaveatPitre draws Catholic conclusions about the Eucharist and church authority, which differ from Latter-day Saint teaching on apostasy and restoration.
David M. Moffitt
Hebrews, resurrection and Christ's heavenly priesthood
“Jesus obtained atonement where and when the writer says…”
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2011) · Brill (NovTSup 141) · Hebrews 8–10 chapters · source
“his resurrection, ascension, offering, and exaltation.”
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2011); Rethinking the Atonement (2022) · Brill; Baker Academic · source
In context: In Hebrews, Christ's bodily resurrection and ascension are the hinge of his saving work; atonement is completed when the risen Jesus presents himself in the heavenly sanctuary.
What this does not claim: He places the atoning offering in heaven, not in Gethsemane, which cuts against the LDS emphasis on Gethsemane and Calvary; and in his account resurrection is the precondition of the offering, whereas 2 Nephi 9 treats it as a result of the atonement.
In context: Hebrews structures salvation as a Day of Atonement rite carried out in a real heavenly sanctuary.
What this does not claim: It concerns Christ's own heavenly ministry, not temple ordinances performed by believers or the endowment.
Caveat
CaveatMoffitt places Christ's atoning offering in heaven after the resurrection, not at Gethsemane or Calvary, and his thesis is contested. His priesthood argument concerns Christ's own priesthood.
11

Is the gathering of Israel a biblical hope?

Topic: Gathering of Israel, adoption · 8 scholars
Jason A. Staples
Israel, exile and restoration in Paul
“proposes a new paradigm for how the biblical concept of Israel developed in Early Judaism…”
The Idea of Israel in Second Temple Judaism (2021) · Cambridge University Press · source · quotation source
“required gentile inclusion to resurrect a greater 'Israel' from the dead.”
Paul and the Resurrection of Israel (2023) · Cambridge University Press · source · quotation source
“a term that refers to a larger group than just Jews/Judaeans”
What Do the Gentiles Have to Do with "All Israel"? A Fresh Look at Romans 11:25-27 (2011) · Journal of Biblical Literature 130.2 · pp. 371ff. · source · quotation source
In context: He shows Second Temple Jews and Paul used 'Israel' for the whole twelve-tribe people and kept hoping for the restoration of all twelve tribes.
What this does not claim: He holds the northern tribes largely assimilated; he does not support their survival as distinct peoples or a latter-day timetable for gathering them.
In context: He argues Paul counted faithful Gentiles as Israelites, so bringing them in is how Israel is restored, which parallels Abraham 2:10.
What this does not claim: This is Paul's first-century view as Staples reconstructs it; it is not lineage by adoption in the LDS sense, and critics (McDermott) dispute the reading.
Caveat
CaveatStaples argues as a historian of Paul and Second Temple Judaism; he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching.
Matthew Thiessen
Gentiles made Abraham's seed through the Spirit
“brings about four significant and substantive changes that remedy the gentile problem”
Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016) · Oxford University Press · chs. 4-5, p. 160 · source
In context: He reads Paul as opposing gentile circumcision as a route into the covenant, not opposing Torah or obedience as such, and frames gentile inclusion as real adoption into Abraham's lineage.
What this does not claim: It is a Paul-within-Judaism, anti-supersessionist reading; it says nothing about a latter-day gathering, and it holds that gentiles do not become Jews.
Caveat
CaveatThiessen's reading of Paul is his historical reconstruction, and his Stoic-leaning account of the spirit is contested. The pneumatic resurrection body he describes is not flesh and bones.
Brant Pitre
Jesus, the Twelve and the Seventy, and the gathering of all twelve tribes
“Rather, Jesus sought to inaugurate the ingathering of all twelve tribes of Israel…”
Jesus, the Tribulation, and the End of the Exile (2005) · Mohr Siebeck (WUNT II/204) / Baker Academic · source
In context: Pitre argues that Jesus looked for the ingathering of all twelve tribes, explicitly including the ten lost in the Assyrian exile.
What this does not claim: He says nothing about a latter-day gathering through missionary work, and he does not say the tribes survived as distinct peoples.
Caveat
CaveatPitre draws Catholic conclusions about the Eucharist and church authority, which differ from Latter-day Saint teaching on apostasy and restoration.
Paul R. Williamson
Two covenants with Abraham
“the international dimension of the promise (ignored in Gen. 15) is alluded to in Genesis 17…”
The Biblical Covenants (TGC essay, 2020) · The Gospel Coalition · source
“a solemn commitment, guaranteeing promises or obligations by one or both parties, sealed with an oath.”
Sealed with an Oath (2007) · Apollos / IVP (NSBT 23) · ch. 1 · source
In context: He shows that the text separates nationhood (Gen 15) from a mission to bless all nations through a royal seed (Gen 17, 22), so covenant identity carries an outward obligation.
What this does not claim: Does not support a latter-day gathering or Abr 2:9-11's priesthood framing; he finds the fulfilment in Christ and the church.
Caveat
CaveatWilliamson rejects covenantal nomism and the New Perspective on Paul, and he holds that punishment after death is eternal and conscious, with no repentance after death. The D&C 84 comparison is of wording only; he does not discuss priesthood.
Mark D. Nanos
Founder of the Paul within Judaism reading
“Arguing against those who think Paul was an apostate from Judaism…”
The Mystery of Romans: The Jewish Context of Paul's Letter (1996) · Fortress Press · source
In context: He reads Romans as Jewish correspondence and Romans 11 as preserving Israel's covenant standing while gentiles are grafted in, which supports an ongoing covenant with Israel into which the nations are brought.
What this does not claim: Gentiles do not become Israel in his reading (Latter-day Saints teach adoption into Abraham's seed), and his preservation of Israel is not tied to faith in Christ, unlike 2 Ne 30:2.
Caveat
CaveatNanos argues that gentiles join Israel's God as gentiles, not as members of Israel, and that Paul himself stayed Torah-observant, which goes beyond the Latter-day Saint teaching that the law of Moses was fulfilled in Christ.
Isaac W. Oliver
Luke-Acts and the restoration of all Israel
“Jews but also Samaritans and other Israelites who were dispersed from their land.”
Luke's Jewish Eschatology: The National Restoration of Israel in Luke-Acts (2021) · Oxford University Press · ch. 5, 'The Acts of the Apostles and the National Restoration of Israel', pp. 103–139 · source · quotation source
In context: His Oxford monograph argues that Luke did not write the Jews off and expected a real national and pan-tribal restoration of Israel, including dispersed Israelites, at Jesus' return.
What this does not claim: It does not support the LDS account of how the gathering happens (missionary work, priesthood keys, the lost ten tribes as LDS teaching describes them). He treats Gentile believers as saved alongside Israel, not adopted into it, and says he describes Luke's beliefs, not his own.
Caveat
CaveatOliver reads gentile believers as a people saved alongside Israel, not adopted into it.
Joel Marcus
James 1:1: Gentile converts as the lost tribes
“Gentiles who respond positively to the Christian message, then, are for James the Ten Lost Tribes.”
'The Twelve Tribes in the Diaspora' (James 1.1) (2014) · Cambridge University Press, New Testament Studies 60.4 · pp. 433–447 · source · quotation source
In context: Marcus argues that James 1:1 already treats Gentile converts as the Ten Lost Tribes, whose Israelite identity was lost among the nations and reawakened by the gospel.
What this does not claim: This is his reading of James's view; it does not claim converts are genealogical Israelites and is not an endorsement of Latter-day Saint teaching.
Caveat
CaveatMarcus describes what James means; he does not argue for the gathering himself. His John the Baptist in History and Theology (2018) argues that John saw himself, not Jesus, as the one who began the kingdom, and that early Christians played down a rivalry between their followers.
James H. Charlesworth
The Pseudepigrapha: God kept speaking
“The idea that the Messiah will visit the lost tribes of Israel is unique; it is neither in the Old nor in the New Testament.”
Messianism in the Pseudepigrapha and the Book of Mormon (1978) · BYU Religious Studies Center · section comparing 3 Nephi 17:4 with 4 Ezra 13 · source
In context: He notes that the idea is in neither Testament, but that 4 Ezra 13 has God's Son the Messiah gathering the ten tribes, which is a partial parallel.
What this does not claim: 4 Ezra speaks of gathering, not visiting; he allows for coincidence and does not argue that the passage is ancient.
Caveat
CaveatCharlesworth does not support the Book of Mormon's antiquity: in the same essay he reads Mosiah 3:8-10 as written after the event.
12

Was ancient Judaism a religion of earning salvation by works?

Matthew J. Thomas
Paul's earliest readers on "works of the law"
“Initial justification is completely by grace apart from works of any sort, and ... final judgment (or final justification) is based on the outworking of this grace in one's subsequent life”
Paul's Works of the Law in the Perspective of Second-Century Reception (2018; IVP 2020) · Mohr Siebeck / IVP Academic · p. 221 (IVP p. 279) · source · quotation source
“the 'new' perspective as, in reality, the old perspective”
Paul's Works of the Law in the Perspective of Second-Century Reception (2018), ch. 12 · Mohr Siebeck · ch. 12, quoted by Scot McKnight · source
In context: Thomas shows that Paul's second-century readers took the rejected works to be Mosaic rites, and held grace-first justification together with final judgment by works.
What this does not claim: He reads the early church as Catholic and continuous with Augustine; he does not claim an apostasy or endorse Latter-day Saint teaching. Reformed reviewers say the real dispute concerns the moral law.
Caveat
CaveatThomas, a Catholic scholar, reads the early church as continuous with Paul and with Augustine; the change he documents is the Reformation's, and he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching.
Matthew Thiessen
Gentiles made Abraham's seed through the Spirit
“brings about four significant and substantive changes that remedy the gentile problem”
Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016) · Oxford University Press · chs. 4-5, p. 160 · source
In context: He reads Paul as opposing gentile circumcision as a route into the covenant, not opposing Torah or obedience as such, and frames gentile inclusion as real adoption into Abraham's lineage.
What this does not claim: It is a Paul-within-Judaism, anti-supersessionist reading; it says nothing about a latter-day gathering, and it holds that gentiles do not become Jews.
Caveat
CaveatThiessen's reading of Paul is his historical reconstruction, and his Stoic-leaning account of the spirit is contested. The pneumatic resurrection body he describes is not flesh and bones.
Jacob Milgrom
Leviticus, ritual and holiness
“the ethical dimensions of ancient worship, and the priestly forms of ritual.”
Leviticus: A Book of Ritual and Ethics (2004) · Fortress Press (Continental Commentaries) · source
In context: Argues that Israel's rites encode ethical commitments, so ritual and morality are inseparable.
What this does not claim: About Israelite ritual law, not Latter-day Saint saving ordinances; does not address grace and works in the New Testament.
Caveat
CaveatMilgrom's work is background on Israelite temple holiness and sacrifice; he did not hold a Christological reading of it, and his view of Israel's monotheism runs against divine-council readings.
Mark D. Nanos
Founder of the Paul within Judaism reading
“Nanos challenges the previously dominant views of Paul as rejecting his Jewish heritage and the Law.”
The Irony of Galatians (2002) · Fortress Press · source
In context: Nanos argues that Paul remained a Torah-observant Jew and that his polemic targets gentiles undergoing proselyte conversion, not covenant faithfulness, so the faith-versus-law opposition is a later Protestant construction.
What this does not claim: His Paul keeps the law of Moses, which goes beyond the Latter-day Saint teaching that the law was fulfilled in Christ; he does not argue for saving ordinances or Latter-day Saint 'works within grace' as such.
Caveat
CaveatNanos argues that gentiles join Israel's God as gentiles, not as members of Israel, and that Paul himself stayed Torah-observant, which goes beyond the Latter-day Saint teaching that the law of Moses was fulfilled in Christ.
Alister McGrath
Iustitia Dei: the history of justification
“appears to have led to justification being treated in a factitive sense.”
Iustitia Dei: A History of the Christian Doctrine of Justification, 4th ed. (2020) · Cambridge University Press · ch. 2, pp. 26–41; ch. 4, pp. 67–81 · source · quotation source
In context: His standard history finds the Greek Fathers, Augustine and the medieval West read justification as making righteous, and places the forensic consensus in sixteenth-century Lutheranism under Melanchthon.
What this does not claim: It does not endorse Latter-day Saint soteriology or covenant obedience, and it describes how theologians defined the teaching, not what Paul meant; Catholic and Orthodox readers use the same finding for their own continuity claims.
Caveat
CaveatThe change McGrath documents is a Reformation one, not an early-church apostasy; he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching on salvation.
13

Is faith only belief, or faithfulness?

Topic: Faith as covenant faithfulness · 2 scholars
Teresa Morgan
Faith as trust in the New Testament
“For very early Christians, pistis language centrally meant trust.”
Roman Faith and Christian Faith (2015) · Oxford University Press · source · quotation source
“This study argues for the recovery of trust as a central theme in Christian theology”
The New Testament and the Theology of Trust (2022) · Oxford University Press · source
“From 325, Christian faith really was centrally a matter of right belief.”
From Trust to Belief (2021) · Classics for All (essay) · source
In context: Shows from Greek, Roman, Jewish and early Christian sources that pistis/fides was mainly trust and faithfulness within a relationship, which fits faith as a principle that shows itself in faithful action.
What this does not claim: She does not argue for LDS covenant theology or ordinances. She keeps propositional belief as part of faith, and she does not take a side in the Protestant debate over grace and works.
Caveat
CaveatMorgan's shift from trust to assent to set beliefs is historical development; she does not describe it as apostasy.
Matthew W. Bates
Faith as allegiance to Jesus the King
“integral to final salvation…”
Salvation by Allegiance Alone (2017) · Baker Academic · p. 110 (as cited by Schreiner) · source
In context: Argues that biblical pistis means allegiance to the king, expressed in obedience, so that works are 'integral to final salvation' rather than optional evidence.
What this does not claim: He keeps salvation as an unearned gift and presents allegiance as a better account of sola fide; he does not endorse Latter-day Saint ordinances or covenants as such.
Caveat
CaveatBates reads Psalm 110 and other texts as dialogue between the Father and the pre-existent Son; his allegiance thesis overlaps with Morgan, Wright and Gorman. He does not hold that baptism is essential to salvation.
14

If salvation is by grace, do works matter?

Topic: Justification in the covenant · 5 scholars
Matthew J. Thomas
Paul's earliest readers on "works of the law"
“Initial justification is completely by grace apart from works of any sort, and ... final judgment (or final justification) is based on the outworking of this grace in one's subsequent life”
Paul's Works of the Law in the Perspective of Second-Century Reception (2018; IVP 2020) · Mohr Siebeck / IVP Academic · p. 221 (IVP p. 279) · source · quotation source
In context: Thomas shows that Paul's second-century readers took the rejected works to be Mosaic rites, and held grace-first justification together with final judgment by works.
What this does not claim: He reads the early church as Catholic and continuous with Augustine; he does not claim an apostasy or endorse Latter-day Saint teaching. Reformed reviewers say the real dispute concerns the moral law.
Caveat
CaveatThomas, a Catholic scholar, reads the early church as continuous with Paul and with Augustine; the change he documents is the Reformation's, and he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching.
Michael J. Gorman
Paul, participation in Christ and theosis
“the genuinely juridical categories in Paul”
Inhabiting the Cruciform God (2009) · Eerdmans · source
In context: He reads justification as transformation into covenant faithfulness through co-crucifixion with Christ, not a bare legal verdict.
What this does not claim: He frames this wholly as grace-enabled participation; it does not address LDS ordinances or covenant-making as such.
Caveat
CaveatGorman describes theosis as transformation into God's own character by sharing in Christ's life. He holds the classical Christian distinction between Creator and creature, so he does not teach exaltation in the Latter-day Saint sense.
Brant Pitre
Jesus, the Twelve and the Seventy, and the gathering of all twelve tribes
“Paul is best viewed as a new covenant Jew.”
Paul, a New Covenant Jew (2019, with Michael P. Barber and John A. Kincaid) · Eerdmans · source
In context: He and his co-authors read Pauline justification as real transformation within a new covenant, with grace enabling works.
What this does not claim: The framework is Catholic and sacramental, and the book is co-authored.
Caveat
CaveatPitre draws Catholic conclusions about the Eucharist and church authority, which differ from Latter-day Saint teaching on apostasy and restoration.
Matthew W. Bates
Faith as allegiance to Jesus the King
“integral to final salvation…”
Salvation by Allegiance Alone (2017) · Baker Academic · p. 110 (as cited by Schreiner) · source
In context: Argues that biblical pistis means allegiance to the king, expressed in obedience, so that works are 'integral to final salvation' rather than optional evidence.
What this does not claim: He keeps salvation as an unearned gift and presents allegiance as a better account of sola fide; he does not endorse Latter-day Saint ordinances or covenants as such.
Caveat
CaveatBates reads Psalm 110 and other texts as dialogue between the Father and the pre-existent Son; his allegiance thesis overlaps with Morgan, Wright and Gorman. He does not hold that baptism is essential to salvation.
Alister McGrath
Iustitia Dei: the history of justification
“appears to have led to justification being treated in a factitive sense.”
Iustitia Dei: A History of the Christian Doctrine of Justification, 4th ed. (2020) · Cambridge University Press · ch. 2, pp. 26–41; ch. 4, pp. 67–81 · source · quotation source
In context: His standard history finds the Greek Fathers, Augustine and the medieval West read justification as making righteous, and places the forensic consensus in sixteenth-century Lutheranism under Melanchthon.
What this does not claim: It does not endorse Latter-day Saint soteriology or covenant obedience, and it describes how theologians defined the teaching, not what Paul meant; Catholic and Orthodox readers use the same finding for their own continuity claims.
Caveat
CaveatThe change McGrath documents is a Reformation one, not an early-church apostasy; he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching on salvation.
15

Why do temples matter so much?

Topic: Temple theology · 14 scholars
Andrei A. Orlov
Heavenly temple, veil and Melchizedek traditions
“depicts the ascension of the seventh antediluvian patriarch to the Throne of Glory as a visitation of the heavenly Temple.”
The Enoch-Metatron Tradition (2005) · Mohr Siebeck (TSAJ 107) · section 'Enoch as the Heavenly Priest' · source
“This realm of the immediate presence of the Deity, the Holy of Holies, is situated behind the veil.”
The Enoch-Metatron Tradition (2005) · Mohr Siebeck (TSAJ 107) · section 'Priestly and Liturgical Roles of Metatron' · source
“Yahoel functions as a senior priest explaining and demonstrating rituals to a junior sacerdotal servant.”
Heavenly Priesthood in the Apocalypse of Abraham (2013) · Cambridge University Press · source · quotation source
In context: He documents Second Temple and early Jewish texts in which Enoch and Abraham ascend to a heavenly temple, are instructed or vested as priests, and approach the Holy of Holies behind the veil.
What this does not claim: These are pseudepigrapha, some of disputed (possibly later) date; he shows what the texts claimed, not that LDS temple rites are ancient.
Caveat
CaveatOrlov documents ancient traditions; he does not argue that they are true. The early date of 2 Enoch is contested, and his texts point to creation from nothing.
Rachel Elior
Priestly and heavenly-temple roots of Jewish mysticism
“centred first on a heavenly Chariot Throne known as the Merkavah, and later on heavenly sanctuaries known as Heikhalot.”
The Three Temples: On the Emergence of Jewish Mysticism (2004 English; Hebrew 2002) · Littman Library of Jewish Civilization · ch. 1 (pp. 29-62), ch. 2 'From Temple to Merkavah' (pp. 63-81), ch. 8 'Priests and Angels' (pp. 165-200), ch. 10 'Heikhalot Literature' (pp. 232-265) · source
In context: Argues that temple worship lived on in Jewish mysticism as ascent to heavenly sanctuaries and participation in the angels' liturgy.
What this does not claim: This is a contested reconstruction about Judaism; it says nothing about early-Christian temple rites or the LDS endowment.
Caveat
CaveatElior's priestly-origins thesis is contested by others in her field (Himmelfarb, Schäfer, Stern), and the kabbalistic Shekhinah is not Heavenly Mother.
Martha Himmelfarb
Heaven as temple; ascent as priestly investiture
“the emergence of the understanding of heaven as temple in the Book of the Watchers…”
Ascent to Heaven in Jewish and Christian Apocalypses (1993) · Oxford University Press · ch. 1 'From Ezekiel to the Book of the Watchers'; ch. 2 'Heavenly Ascent and Priestly Investiture' · source
“is a heavenly version of a priestly investiture.”
Ascent to Heaven in Jewish and Christian Apocalypses (1993) · Oxford University Press · p. 40 (as quoted) · source
In context: She shows that Jewish and Christian ascent texts from the third century BC onward pictured heaven as a temple and described entry into God's presence as a priestly anointing and clothing (2 Enoch 22).
What this does not claim: She treats this as literary imagery borrowed from priestly investiture, not as evidence that anyone practised such a rite or had such visions. Washing is not verified in her treatment.
Caveat
CaveatHimmelfarb reads the ascent texts as literature that borrows priestly imagery, not as a record of an actual rite. Becoming like the angels is angelification, not deification, and she is not shown as agreeing with Barker.
L. Michael Morales
The tabernacle as a portable Sinai and the way back to Eden
“so that the tabernacle is a kind of miniature Sinai.”
The Tabernacle Pre-Figured: Cosmic Mountain Ideology in Genesis and Exodus (2012) · Peeters (Biblical Tools and Studies 15) · pp. 245-277 adapted as the Interpreter chapter · source
“as a return to Eden (pp. 100–103)”
Who Shall Ascend the Mountain of the Lord? (2015) · Apollos / IVP Academic (NSBT 37) · pp. 95-103, 173 · source
In context: He argues from the Hebrew text that Genesis, Exodus and Leviticus are structured as an ascent back into God's presence through sanctuary, veil and authorised ritual entry.
What this does not claim: He reads this pattern as fulfilled in Christ; it does not show that temple ordinances continue or match modern Latter-day Saint rites.
Caveat
CaveatMorales reads the tabernacle, its priesthood and its rites as fulfilled in Christ, not as patterns for continuing temple ordinances. He builds on Levenson, Clifford, Wenham, Barker and Fletcher-Louis, and his Eden-as-sanctuary and high-priest-as-Adam readings are contested (Harper, Leithart).
Frank Moore Cross
The divine council and the heavenly-pattern tabernacle
“a model of the cosmic Tabernacle of Yahweh”
"The Priestly Tabernacle in the Light of Recent Research" (1984) · BYU Religious Studies Center (The Temple in Antiquity, ed. Truman G. Madsen) · pp. 91–105 · source
In context: He argues the tabernacle was built to a tabnit, a model of Yahweh's cosmic tabernacle, so the earthly shrine is a microcosm of the heavenly one.
What this does not claim: Historical reconstruction of Priestly and Canaanite ideas; says nothing about endowment or LDS temple ordinances.
Caveat
CaveatCross's account is developmental: Israel inherited the council from Canaanite religion, and he held that Yahweh began as a name of El, not a son of El.
George W. E. Nickelsburg
1 Enoch: heavenly temple and ascent
“First, the real temple is the heavenly temple.”
The Temple According to 1 Enoch (2014) · BYU Studies Quarterly 53:1 · 1 Enoch 14–15 discussion · source · quotation source
In context: Shows that 1 Enoch, a text that circulated widely in early Judaism and is quoted in Jude, centres on a heavenly temple where Enoch ascends to God's throne.
What this does not claim: Says nothing about endowment, veil or ordinance rituals; his reading of the Animal Vision envisions a final city with no separate temple.
Caveat
CaveatNickelsburg treats 1 Enoch as a composite Second Temple work, and he finds Jewish belief about the afterlife diverse, with parts of 1 Enoch non-bodily.
Gary A. Anderson
Eden as sanctuary; garments of glory
“the building of the tabernacle is presented as the goal and completion of creation…”
That I May Dwell Among Them: Incarnation and Atonement in the Tabernacle Narrative (2023) · Eerdmans · pp. 21-33, 67, 103 · source
In context: Documents ancient Jewish and Christian readings in which Adam and Eve were vested like priests in an Eden laid out like the sanctuary, and lost garments of glory at the Fall.
What this does not claim: Tradition history of how ancient readers read Genesis; Anderson does not argue for an Adamic temple garment or the LDS endowment.
Caveat
CaveatAnderson defends creation from nothing. Latter-day Saint glosses on his work, such as 'terrestrial glory', are Bradshaw's, not his.
Michael Patrick Barber
Jesus, the temple and Peter's priestly keys
“In this book, Michael Patrick Barber examines the role of the Jerusalem temple in the teaching of the historical Jesus.”
The Historical Jesus and the Temple: Memory, Methodology, and the Gospel of Matthew (2023) · Cambridge University Press · ch. 3 'Jesus and the Jerusalem Temple' (pp. 43-80); ch. 4 (pp. 81-114) · source · quotation source
In context: Barber argues historically that Jesus accepted the temple's validity, took part in and endorsed its rites, and cast his community and its leaders in temple and priestly terms.
What this does not claim: It is about the Jerusalem temple in Jesus' ministry; it does not argue for temple-as-cosmos, ascent, veil or endowment rites, or any continuity with modern Latter-day Saint temples.
Caveat
CaveatMichael Patrick Barber argues that Jesus endorsed temple worship and framed his community in priestly terms. He applies Peter's priestly keys to Catholic Holy Orders, which implies continuity rather than restoration. Nothing here concerns a cosmic temple, ascent or endowment.
Philip S. Alexander
Worship with the angels in the heavenly temple
“union with the angels in offering praise to God in the celestial temple…”
The Mystical Texts: Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice and Related Manuscripts (2006) · T&T Clark (Library of Second Temple Studies 61) · source
“This curtain is the heavenly counterpart of the Veil which divided the Holy Place from the Holy of Holies…”
3 (Hebrew Apocalypse of) Enoch, in The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha vol. 1 (1983) · Doubleday · p. 296 n. 45a · source
In context: Argues that Jewish mysticism began in Second Temple priestly circles and centred on joining the angels' praise in the heavenly temple.
What this does not claim: Concerns Qumran liturgy and hymns, not an endowment-type ritual or ordinances; how literal the 'union' was is debated.
Caveat
Caveat3 Enoch is a late-antique text (final form 5th-6th century AD) that Alexander translated: the exaltation of Enoch is what the text presents, and he reads Metatron's demotion in ch. 16 as a later orthodox addition.
Jacob Milgrom
Leviticus, ritual and holiness
“He alone can contaminate the sanctuary and force God out.”
The Temple in Biblical Israel: Kinships of Meaning (1978) · BYU Religious Studies Center, in Reflections on Mormonism: Judaeo-Christian Parallels, ed. Truman G. Madsen · pp. 57–65 · source
In context: Shows that in Israel's own theology the sanctuary's purity was what kept God's presence among his people, a principle Milgrom himself linked to D&C 97:15–17.
What this does not claim: Concerns the Israelite sanctuary; says nothing about the endowment, early-Christian temple practice, or Christ's fulfilment of the law.
Caveat
CaveatMilgrom's work is background on Israelite temple holiness and sacrifice; he did not hold a Christological reading of it, and his view of Israel's monotheism runs against divine-council readings.
Lawrence H. Schiffman
The Temple Scroll and Qumran law
“In the End of Days, God will create a new Temple to replace the present one.”
Reclaiming the Dead Sea Scrolls (1994) · Jewish Publication Society · pp. 262-264 · source
In context: He documents a detailed Jewish temple programme with graded holiness, ordination rites and hope for a God-built temple of the divine presence.
What this does not claim: Says nothing of an endowment, veil ceremony or ascent; the Temple Scroll is not a Christian or proto-Christian text.
Caveat
CaveatThe Temple Scroll is a temple plan found among the Dead Sea Scrolls, not a composition of the sect. Its hidden law, revealed progressively, is not an open canon.
David M. Moffitt
Hebrews, resurrection and Christ's heavenly priesthood
“Jesus obtained atonement where and when the writer says…”
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2011) · Brill (NovTSup 141) · Hebrews 8–10 chapters · source
In context: Hebrews structures salvation as a Day of Atonement rite carried out in a real heavenly sanctuary.
What this does not claim: It concerns Christ's own heavenly ministry, not temple ordinances performed by believers or the endowment.
Caveat
CaveatMoffitt places Christ's atoning offering in heaven after the resurrection, not at Gethsemane or Calvary, and his thesis is contested. His priesthood argument concerns Christ's own priesthood.
Eyal Regev
The New Testament did not reject the Temple
“the Temple remains significant and even central to the authors of Luke, Hebrews and Revelation.”
The Temple in Early Christianity: Experiencing the Sacred (2019) · Yale University Press (Anchor Yale Bible Reference Library) · Jesus chapter, p. 33; John, p. 200; Revelation, p. 245 (per AJR review) · source · quotation source
In context: Regev's survey of the whole New Testament finds that texts once read as anti-Temple are better read as participation, analogy or criticism, and that the Temple stays significant for Luke, Hebrews and Revelation; Jesus' protest was not directed against the Temple itself.
What this does not claim: Concerns the Jerusalem sacrificial Temple and early Christian attitudes to it; it does not argue for modern temples, endowment, sealing, ascent or veil rituals, and Regev treats Hebrews as the most critical New Testament text.
Caveat
CaveatRegev finds Hebrews the most critical New Testament text on the Temple. He is not credited with arguments about apostasy, ascent or temple ritual.
Michael Fishbane
Founder of inner-biblical exegesis: scripture reworking scripture
“linking the highest heaven to the nethermost earth.”
Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel (1985) · Clarendon Press (Oxford University Press) · pp. 369–370 and p. 370 n. 132 (as quoted by Rennaker) · source
In context: He reads Ezekiel's altar summit as 'mountain of God' and the new Temple as linking the highest heaven to the nethermost earth.
What this does not claim: A few pages on Ezekiel, not a thesis about temple ritual or ascent; Levenson develops the theme more fully.
Caveat
CaveatFishbane writes as a Jewish theologian and historian, and he dates Isaiah 40-66 after the exile. Colby Townsend (Dialogue, 2018) calls his book a classic of inner-biblical exegesis, uses Hays's terms instead, and argues that the Book of Mormon's Malachi depends on the King James Version.
16

Do priesthood and ordinances have biblical roots?

Topic: Priesthood and ordinances · 6 scholars
Madison N. Pierce
Father, Son and Spirit as speakers in Hebrews
“establishes Jesus as a high priest in the likeness of Melchizedek.”
Divine Discourse in the Epistle to the Hebrews (Cambridge, 2020) · Cambridge University Press (SNTSMS 178) · pp. 62-78 (thesis pp. 69-85); Heb 5:1-6; 7:17-28 · source
In context: Pierce shows that in Hebrews the Father confers the high priesthood on the Son by call and oath, and that Heb 5:4 makes this the rule for every high priest.
What this does not claim: Her point concerns Christ's priesthood; she reads the 'order' of Melchizedek as likeness, not a succession held by others.
Caveat
CaveatPierce reads this within classical Trinitarian theology, including the eternal generation of the Son. Her priesthood point concerns Christ, and she reads the 'order' of Melchizedek as likeness, not a succession held by others.
Scott W. Hahn
Covenant as divine family
“fathers were high priests and firstborn sons were priests under their authority.”
"The Meal of Melchizedek" (talk, abridged from 'Eucharist: Holy Meal') · EWTN (transcript) · source
In context: Hahn argues Israel's priesthood was originally a family priesthood of firstborn sons in the pattern of Melchizedek, taken away after the golden calf and given to the Levites temporarily; with Bergsma (JBL 2004) he identifies Ezekiel's 'not good' laws with the Deuteronomic code given to a rebellious generation.
What this does not claim: He applies this to Christ and the Catholic ministerial priesthood, not to a restored Melchizedek priesthood; the priesthood claim comes mainly from a popular talk; the firstborn-priesthood thesis is contested by other scholars.
Caveat
CaveatHahn's priesthood argument comes from a popular talk. His own Catholic conclusions on apostolic succession and the Mass differ from Latter-day Saint teaching on apostasy and restoration.
Crispin Fletcher-Louis
Temple, the image of God and the identity of Jesus
“king and priest after the order of Melchizedek.”
Jesus as the High Priestly Messiah: Part 1 (2006) · Journal for the Study of the Historical Jesus 4.2 · pp. 155-175 · source · quotation source
In context: He argues from Psalm 110 and Daniel 7:13 that Jesus himself claimed to be king and priest after the order of Melchizedek.
What this does not claim: It concerns Christ's own priesthood, not a Melchizedek priesthood conferred on believers or its latter-day offices.
Caveat
CaveatFletcher-Louis holds a Christology of two persons within the one divine identity; he does not argue for the Father and the Son as separate beings.
Andrei A. Orlov
Heavenly temple, veil and Melchizedek traditions
“presents Melchizedek as a continuation of the priestly line from Methuselah, son of Enoch…”
"Melchizedek Legend of 2 (Slavonic) Enoch" (2000) · Brill, Journal for the Study of Judaism 31 · pp. 23-38 · source
In context: 2 Enoch, as he reconstructs it, presents a priestly line from Methuselah through Nir to Melchizedek, separate from Aaron's line.
What this does not claim: This is the view of one pseudepigraphon; it says nothing about priesthood ordinances being required for salvation.
Caveat
CaveatOrlov documents ancient traditions; he does not argue that they are true. The early date of 2 Enoch is contested, and his texts point to creation from nothing.
Alexander Schmemann
Marriage fulfilled in the Kingdom; worship as ascent
“Во Христе, Который есть Царь, Священник и Пророк, мы становимся царями, священниками и пророками…”
Of Water and the Spirit: A Liturgical Study of Baptism (1974) · St Vladimir's Seminary Press · ch. 3 ('The Sacrament of the Holy Spirit') · source · quotation source
In context: He argues that baptism, chrismation and the Eucharist truly accomplish entry into Christ and the Kingdom, and are not merely illustrative.
What this does not claim: This is the standard Orthodox and Catholic view, not an LDS distinctive. He defends infant baptism, does not support restored priesthood authority, and does not cover proxy ordinances.
Caveat
CaveatSchmemann is an Orthodox liturgical theologian. The anointing he describes is every baptised Christian's share in Christ's priesthood, not an ordained priesthood, and marriage in the Kingdom is not sealing. He defends infant baptism and an unbroken Orthodox tradition.
L. Michael Morales
The tabernacle as a portable Sinai and the way back to Eden
“and the high priest portrays Adam (/Noah/Moses).”
The Tabernacle: Mountain of God in the Cultus of Israel (2014; Interpreter reprint 2020) · Interpreter Foundation / Eborn Books · Interpreter 37, pp. 97-140 · source
In context: He treats the high priest's Day of Atonement entry as the archetypal priestly act by which Israel approaches God.
What this does not claim: Concerns Aaronic/Levitical mediation fulfilled in Christ's high priesthood; says nothing of Melchizedek priesthood authority today.
Caveat
CaveatMorales reads the tabernacle, its priesthood and its rites as fulfilled in Christ, not as patterns for continuing temple ordinances. He builds on Levenson, Clifford, Wenham, Barker and Fletcher-Louis, and his Eden-as-sanctuary and high-priest-as-Adam readings are contested (Harper, Leithart).
17

Did early Christian teaching change over time?

Topic: Apostasy and restoration · 7 scholars
Raymond E. Brown
God's council; the church after the apostles
“know some of the limitations of the claim that the episcopate stands in apostolic succession.”
Priest and Bishop: Biblical Reflections (1970) · Paulist Press · Preface; ch. 2 'Are the Bishops the Successors of the Apostles?' · source
In context: Brown found limits to 'the unqualified idea that the bishops are the successors of the apostles' and documented varied church orders after the apostles.
What this does not claim: He affirmed functional succession and read the changes as legitimate development; he gives no support to a loss of priesthood authority.
Caveat
CaveatBrown read the change after the apostles as legitimate development, not apostasy. His history of the Johannine community is a reconstruction.
Teresa Morgan
Faith as trust in the New Testament
“From the early second century, belief in the truth of doctrine becomes increasingly significant to Christians…”
Two Aspects of Early Christian Faith (2021) · Cambridge University Press (Studies in Church History 57) · pp. 6-31 · source · quotation source
“From 325, Christian faith really was centrally a matter of right belief.”
From Trust to Belief (2021) · Classics for All (essay) · source
In context: Documents that assent to set beliefs became central to Christian faith between the 2nd and 4th centuries, with Platonism as one influence; the earliest pistis was centred on trust.
What this does not claim: She describes development, not apostasy or a loss needing restoration, and she argues that trust and belief are bound up together.
Caveat
CaveatMorgan's shift from trust to assent to set beliefs is historical development; she does not describe it as apostasy.
Bart D. Ehrman
How scribes changed the New Testament text
“His thesis is that proto-orthodox scribes of the second and third centuries occasionally altered their sacred texts…”
The Orthodox Corruption of Scripture (1993) · Oxford University Press · source
In context: Documents specific New Testament readings that proto-orthodox scribes changed to fight rival views of Christ.
What this does not claim: Changes were occasional and identifiable; it does not show lost saving teachings, loss of priesthood, or a single original church to restore, and his diversity-from-the-start thesis works against that model.
Caveat
CaveatCited only for documented scribal changes to the New Testament text. Ehrman is an agnostic who holds that Christianity was diverse from the start and that several New Testament letters are forgeries; the changes he documents are occasional and identifiable, not lost saving teachings.
Francesca Stavrakopoulou
The embodied God of the Hebrew Bible
“Ultimately, this meant that God could not have a body.”
God: An Anatomy (2021) · Picador / Knopf · pp. 418-421 · source
In context: She traces how Greek translations of scripture, Platonic abstraction, and Nicene and Chalcedonian theology produced a simple, bodiless God unlike the God of the Bible.
What this does not claim: She does not argue for apostasy, lost priesthood or restoration; to her the whole sequence is human religious history.
Caveat
CaveatStavrakopoulou, an atheist, treats the Bible as human religious history, not revelation. God: An Anatomy is a trade book with explicit material that its Latter-day Saint reviewer says will at points offend.
Christoph Markschies
God's body in ancient Judaism and Christianity
“Platonic misgivings about divine corporeality entered the church early on…”
God's Body (2019) · Baylor University Press · Ch. 2, Ch. 4, Ch. 6 · source · quotation source
In context: Traces incorporeality to Platonist philosophy entering the church, and shows that it prevailed among theologians only by the fourth and fifth centuries, after controversy.
What this does not claim: Shows theological development on one point, not a general apostasy. He regards the outcome as legitimate theology, not a loss.
Caveat
CaveatMarkschies documents the ancient belief in God's body; he does not hold it, and ancient 'body' language often meant a refined substance, not flesh and bones. Not cited for D&C 130:22.
Géza Vermes
The Jewish Jesus; Nicaea as a late departure
“The idea of consubstantiality never occurred to any of the leading representatives of Christianity prior to 325.”
Christian Beginnings: From Nazareth to Nicaea (2012/2013) · Allen Lane; Yale University Press · source · quotation source
In context: Vermes argues that no leading Christian thinker before 325 held the Son consubstantial with the Father, and that Nicaea was a 'colossal' departure.
What this does not claim: He frames the change as a merely human Jesus being progressively deified, not as the loss of an original truth about a divine Christ, priesthood or ordinances; he does not argue for a restoration.
Caveat
CaveatVermes held that Jesus was a human prophet whose divinity was a later belief, and he did not accept the bodily resurrection as historically established. His 'son of man' reading works against divine-council and two-powers readings.
Gustaf Aulén
Christus Victor: the atonement as victory
“A major shift occurred, Aulén says, when Anselm of Canterbury published his Cur Deus Homo around 1097 AD”
Christus Victor (1931) · SPCK · chs. 5-6, 8 · source
In context: He argues that the victory model was the main patristic view and that Anselm's satisfaction theory is a later Western development, so a Latter-day Saint emphasis on Christ breaking the bands of death has deep early-church precedent.
What this does not claim: His history is disputed as too schematic (Hidal; Meyer, Tyndale Bulletin 2020), and he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching. The Book of Mormon also keeps satisfaction-of-justice language that he opposes.
Caveat
CaveatAulén opposed the satisfaction-of-justice model, which the Book of Mormon keeps (Alma 34, 42), and later historians call his three types too schematic.
18

Did revelation and scripture end with the Bible?

Topic: Open canon, revelation · 14 scholars
Margaret Barker
Temple Theology
“As far as we know, there was no idea of a closed canon in 600 BCE…”
'Joseph Smith and Preexilic Israelite Religion' (2005) · BYU Studies 44:4 · from p. 69 · source
In context: She notes that Judah around 600 BCE had no idea of a closed canon and accepted prophetic revelation.
What this does not claim: This is a historical observation; it does not establish that later scripture is authoritative.
Caveat
CaveatBarker's First Temple reconstructions are her own arguments, which specialists dispute (Schäfer, Paul, Twigg). She is an independent scholar and does not endorse Latter-day Saint claims.
N. T. Wright
New Testament scholar; former Bishop of Durham
“The risen Jesus, at the end of Matthew's Gospel, does not say”
The Last Word (2005) · HarperSanFrancisco · pp. xi, 24 (as cited by Holland, nn. 11–12) · source · quotation source
In context: Wright locates final authority in God and Jesus rather than in the text itself, a point Elder Holland used against 'the Bible alone'.
What this does not claim: Wright himself affirms the traditional canon and reads scripture within church tradition; the open-canon conclusion is Holland's, not his.
Caveat
CaveatWright argues as a historian, not as an advocate of Latter-day Saint teaching: bodily resurrection and new creation, Paul's covenant theology, the practice behind 1 Cor 15:29. He affirms the traditional canon and does not endorse Latter-day Saint priesthood, continuing revelation or exaltation. His empty-tomb case is contested (Crossley).
Hindy Najman
Scripture that kept growing
“Attribution to Moses is a central example whose function is to re-present the experience of revelation at Sinai.”
Seconding Sinai: The Development of Mosaic Discourse in Second Temple Judaism (2003; SBL pb 2009) · Brill (JSJSup 77); Society of Biblical Literature reprint · source
“This process begins with the revelation of the old and new books of the Law to Ezra.”
Losing the Temple and Recovering the Future: An Analysis of 4 Ezra (2014) · Cambridge University Press · source · quotation source
In context: Her work shows that in Second Temple Judaism scripture was still open, more expansive and flexible than the later Tanakh or Old Testament, and that works such as Jubilees created new Scripture that was received as authoritative.
What this does not claim: This is a historical description of ancient Judaism; she makes no theological claim that the canon should be open today and says nothing about modern revelation.
In context: She argues that 'forgery' and 'authenticity' are anachronistic categories for ancient Judaism and that attribution to a founder such as Moses was an accepted way of renewing his revelation.
What this does not claim: Her model assumes later human authorship in the founder's name, which is not the usual Latter-day Saint claim that restored texts preserve the words of ancient prophets; it should not be cited as support for that claim.
Caveat
CaveatNajman's 'Mosaic discourse' explains texts written later in a founder's name. She is not cited for the ancient authorship of any modern scripture.
Lee Martin McDonald
The late, gradual closing of the canon
“The NT in his opinion was not formed until the fourth through the sixth century a.d.”
The Biblical Canon: Its Origin, Transmission, and Authority (2007) · Hendrickson · source
“Lee Martin McDonald provides a magisterial overview of the development of the biblical canon”
The Formation of the Biblical Canon, 2 vols (2017) · Bloomsbury T&T Clark · source
“We know that the early Christian church had a variety of scriptures and other source material…”
Forgotten Scriptures: The Selection and Rejection of Early Religious Writings (2009) · Westminster John Knox · source
In context: His histories show the canon was fluid for centuries, with the New Testament list settled by church consensus in the 4th–6th centuries and boundaries never fully agreed, so a closed canon is a later church development, not a biblical or apostolic teaching.
What this does not claim: It is a historical argument only: it does not show that new scripture or modern revelation is genuine, and he does not endorse the Book of Mormon or LDS prophets.
In context: He openly questions whether the church was right to need a closed canon and whether confining inspiration to first-century texts implies the Spirit no longer speaks; Latter-day Saint writer Robert Millet builds on these questions.
What this does not claim: These are questions he raises, not a conclusion he defends; he remains an ordained Baptist minister.
Caveat
CaveatMcDonald does not endorse new scripture or modern prophets, and evangelical scholars such as Michael Kruger dispute his late dating.
Loren T. Stuckenbruck
Enoch, the Book of Giants and early scripture
“Erst im 15. Jh. wurde der kanonische Wert allgemein in Äthiopien bestätigt.”
The Book of Enoch: Its Reception in Second Temple Jewish and in Christian Tradition (2013) · Mohr Siebeck (Early Christianity 4.1) · pp. 7-40 · source
“straightforward correspondence between the name(s) Mahawai in the Manichaean texts and Mahaway in the Aramaic [Book of Giants]…”
The Book of Giants from Qumran (1997) · Mohr Siebeck (TSAJ 63) · source · quotation source
In context: His work shows 1 Enoch functioned as authoritative literature in Second Temple Judaism, was quoted as prophecy in Jude, and remains canonical in the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church, so the canon's boundaries were historically drawn differently by different Christian bodies.
What this does not claim: He does not argue for an open canon today, for continuing revelation, or for the Book of Moses.
Caveat
CaveatStuckenbruck's work on angel veneration concludes in favour of Jewish monotheism. The Mahijah parallel with the Book of Moses was noticed by Nibley and Bradshaw, not by him.
Bernard M. Levinson
'You must not add': the Bible revising its own law
“later writers were able to criticize, reject, and replace it with the alternative notion of individual retribution.”
"'You Must Not Add Anything to What I Command You': Paradoxes of Canon and Authorship in Ancient Israel" (2003) · Numen 50:1 (Brill) · pp. 1-51 · source · quotation source
“But a closer look reveals that the homily so fundamentally transforms the original as to revoke it.”
"At the Intersection of Scribal Training and Theological Profundity" (2020) · BYU Studies Quarterly 59, supplement · pp. 96-98 (Case Study 4, Deut 7:9-10) · source · quotation source
In context: He shows that the biblical text carrying the do-not-add formula itself revised earlier authoritative law, so the formula coexisted with ongoing authoritative reworking of scripture.
What this does not claim: He describes scribal revision before the canon closed, not new revelation through prophets, and he does not argue for an open canon today.
Caveat
CaveatLevinson's model is scribal revision presented as Mosaic, not revelation, and he cautions against treating chiasm as proof that a text is ancient. His 2020 BYU Studies Quarterly article was a guest contribution to its chiasmus issue.
James H. Charlesworth
The Pseudepigrapha: God kept speaking
“God did continue speaking after sixty-six books were collected and called the Bible.”
Messianism in the Pseudepigrapha and the Book of Mormon (1978) · BYU Religious Studies Center (Reflections on Mormonism: Judaeo-Christian Parallels) · conclusion · source
In context: His pseudepigrapha work shows that ancient Jews and Christians treated some writings outside the later canon as authoritative (Jude cites 1 Enoch as prophecy), and he personally affirmed that God continued speaking after the Bible was collected.
What this does not claim: He frames the latter as personal conviction, not a historical finding, and he does not endorse LDS scripture as canon.
Caveat
CaveatCharlesworth does not support the Book of Mormon's antiquity: in the same essay he reads Mosiah 3:8-10 as written after the event.
James C. VanderKam
Jubilees, Enoch and an unfixed canon at Qumran
“it was believed that revelation and inspiration continued, at least in the time of the Teacher of Righteousness.”
Questions of Canon Viewed through the Dead Sea Scrolls (2001) · Bulletin for Biblical Research 11.2 (Institute for Biblical Research) · p. 269ff. (abstract) · source
In context: He argues from the Dead Sea Scrolls that authoritative collections were still unfixed, that even the text of the Torah was not settled, and that the Qumran community believed revelation and inspiration continued in its own day.
What this does not claim: This is a historical claim about one Second Temple community. It is not an argument for a modern open canon or for Latter-day Saint scripture.
In context: His Jubilees and Enoch scholarship documents that some Jews, notably at Qumran, read books such as Jubilees, which presents itself as revelation to Moses, as authoritative.
What this does not claim: It shows reception by some groups, not acceptance by Jews generally. He treats these books as second-century BCE and earlier pseudepigrapha, not as genuine revelation.
Caveat
CaveatVanderKam shows scripture was unfixed at Qumran, where revelation was believed to continue; he does not argue for a modern open canon or address Moses 6-7. His reading of 1 Enoch 71 (Enoch as the Son of Man) is contested.
Annette Yoshiko Reed
Enoch's authority among early Christians
“This book considers the early history of Jewish-Christian relations focussing on traditions about the fallen angels.”
Fallen Angels and the History of Judaism and Christianity: The Reception of Enochic Literature (2005) · Cambridge University Press · ch. 4-6 (pp. 122-232); Epilogue (pp. 273-277) · source · quotation source
In context: Shows that early Christians, from the first followers of Jesus to the church writers who preceded later orthodoxy, used the Book of the Watchers as an authority for reading Genesis, and that Western rejection came only in the 3rd-4th centuries; her JTS article shows the 'pseudepigrapha' label itself is an early-modern category.
What this does not claim: Shows the edges of scripture were fluid and later narrowed; does not argue for continuing revelation or that the church should have kept these books.
Caveat
CaveatReed documents one case of loss, not a general apostasy. Her subject is the Book of the Watchers (the fallen angels), not the Enoch of Moses 6-7.
John N. Oswalt
Isaiah and the call to holiness
“argues convincingly that the whole book can be attributed to the Isaiah of the eighth century.”
The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 1–39 (1986) and 40–66 (1998) · Eerdmans (NICOT) · Vol. 2, introduction, p. 5 (per Themelios review); vol. 1 introduction on unity and authorship · source
In context: A standard evangelical academic commentary argues at length that the whole book can be attributed to the eighth-century Isaiah, so the dating objection is contested in serious scholarship.
What this does not claim: This is a minority view among biblical scholars. Oswalt never mentions the Book of Mormon. His argument does not show that brass plates existed or that the Book of Mormon is authentic, and he allows that the book may have been assembled later from Isaiah's collected works.
Caveat
CaveatSingle authorship of Isaiah is a minority view among scholars. Oswalt never discusses the Book of Mormon.
Jacob Neusner
Rabbinic portrayals of God; an open Torah
“Torah is, as I said, an unfilled basket, a canon still (and, I think, perpetually) open and uncompleted.”
The Glory of God Is Intelligence: Four Lectures on the Role of Intellect in Judaism (1978) · BYU Religious Studies Center · Lecture 4, 'The Mishnah as a Focus of Torah Piety' · source
In context: He shows that the talmudic rabbis treated Torah as a canon 'perpetually open and uncompleted' and saw revelation continuing through study of the Mishnah.
What this does not claim: This is revelation through learning in the Oral Torah, not through prophets or new canonized scripture; it describes rabbinic belief, not a claim about Christianity.
Caveat
CaveatNeusner describes how the rabbinic texts portray God; he did not claim that God has a body. Torah study as continuing revelation is a rabbinic parallel, not support for living prophets. Lieberman, Sanders and others criticised his translations and method.
Martin Hengel
The early exalted, pre-existent Son
“a Christian canon should be as broad as possible.”
The Septuagint as Christian Scripture: Its Prehistory and the Problem of Its Canon (2002, with Roland Deines) · T&T Clark · pp. 100, 110-12, 126-27 (per Shead's review) · source
In context: Hengel argues that early Christians had loose Old Testament boundaries, that NT writers cited books outside the Hebrew canon as scripture, and that prophecy did not cease before the first century AD.
What this does not claim: Concerns ancient canon boundaries only; it does not argue for new scripture or modern prophets, and the reviewer judged parts of the argument fragile.
Caveat
CaveatHengel's work supports an early, exalted, pre-existent Son, not an embodied God or separate beings. His Judaism-and-Hellenism thesis complicates any apostasy-by-Hellenization argument, so he is not cited for it.
Lawrence H. Schiffman
The Temple Scroll and Qumran law
“The hidden laws were thus progressively revealed and changed with the times.”
Reclaiming the Dead Sea Scrolls (1994) · Jewish Publication Society · pp. 247-249, 'The Revealed and the Hidden' · source
In context: He shows that a Second Temple Jewish community believed God kept disclosing hidden law to it through inspired study, beyond the written Torah.
What this does not claim: This is revealed law through interpretation, not new scripture or an open canon; he says the Scrolls hold no independent authority for religion today.
Caveat
CaveatThe Temple Scroll is a temple plan found among the Dead Sea Scrolls, not a composition of the sect. Its hidden law, revealed progressively, is not an open canon.
Michael Fishbane
Founder of inner-biblical exegesis: scripture reworking scripture
“the terms traditum (or body of tradition) and traditio (or transmission) are introduced”
Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel (1985) · Clarendon Press (Oxford University Press) · whole book; ch. 'The Mantological Exegesis of Oracles', pp. 458–499 · source · quotation source
In context: He shows that the Hebrew Bible itself contains later authoritative reinterpretation, reapplication and revision of earlier scripture and oracles, so reworking inherited scripture is a biblical practice.
What this does not claim: It concerns growth before the canon closed; it says nothing about whether the canon should remain open or about modern revelation.
Caveat
CaveatFishbane writes as a Jewish theologian and historian, and he dates Isaiah 40-66 after the exile. Colby Townsend (Dialogue, 2018) calls his book a classic of inner-biblical exegesis, uses Hays's terms instead, and argues that the Book of Mormon's Malachi depends on the King James Version.
19

Is baptism for the dead found in the Bible?

Topic: Salvation of the dead · 5 scholars
Jeffrey A. Trumbower
Rescue for the dead in early Christianity
“the grammar and logic of the passage point to a practice of vicarious baptism…”
Rescue for the Dead (2001) · Oxford University Press · ch. 2, pp. 35-36 · source · quotation source
“The question of who was saved at the descent was not settled in the first four centuries of Christianity.”
Rescue for the Dead (2001) · Oxford University Press · ch. 5 (Jesus' Descent to the Underworld), p. 108 · source · quotation source
In context: An Oxford-published historian argues that the grammar and logic of 1 Cor 15:29 point to a real practice of living people being baptized on behalf of the dead, rejecting readings that explain the verse away.
What this does not claim: He does not say Paul approved of the practice. He limits the Corinthian practice to people who wanted baptism in life or died in the faith unbaptized. He takes no theological side (p. 155).
In context: He documents prayers for unbaptized dead people, a descent tradition in which salvation was offered to the dead, and progress after death in Origen. He shows that the principle that death closes the door was slow to develop and was contested until Augustine.
What this does not claim: These were contested minority strands, partly found in groups the church condemned; he shows that the beliefs existed, not that they were apostolic or true.
Caveat
CaveatTrumbower writes history: he limits the Corinthian practice to people who wanted baptism in life or died in the faith unbaptised, and he does not argue for a general apostasy.
N. T. Wright
New Testament scholar; former Bishop of Durham
“Otherwise, what are people doing when they get baptized on behalf of the dead?”
The Kingdom New Testament (2011) · HarperOne · 1 Cor 15:29 · source · quotation source
In context: His translation and commentary read 1 Cor 15:29 plainly as people being baptised on behalf of the dead, a practice Paul cites without condemning it.
What this does not claim: Shows only that the practice existed in Corinth and that Paul used it in his argument; Wright does not endorse it or the modern ordinance.
Caveat
CaveatWright argues as a historian, not as an advocate of Latter-day Saint teaching: bodily resurrection and new creation, Paul's covenant theology, the practice behind 1 Cor 15:29. He affirms the traditional canon and does not endorse Latter-day Saint priesthood, continuing revelation or exaltation. His empty-tomb case is contested (Crossley).
Richard E. DeMaris
Proxy baptism at Corinth
“a vicarious baptism undergone by the living for the benefit of the physically dead…”
Corinthian Religion and Baptism for the Dead (1 Corinthians 15:29): Insights from Archaeology and Anthropology (1995) · Society of Biblical Literature, Journal of Biblical Literature 114/4 · pp. 661–682 (vicarious reading at p. 662; no Pauline objection pp. 679–81) · source · quotation source
In context: A mainstream JBL study concludes that the plain reading of 1 Cor 15:29 is vicarious baptism by the living for the dead, that Paul cites it without voicing objection, and that the verse has been marginalised for the wrong reasons.
What this does not claim: He does not say the practice was apostolic, universal or saving. He explains it as a local Corinthian funerary rite, suggests Romans 6 may implicitly correct the Corinthians' theology of it, admits there is no archaeological confirmation, and declines to comment on modern LDS practice.
Caveat
CaveatDeMaris explains the rite as a local Corinthian funerary adaptation, reads Paul as tolerating it, and calls his own reconstruction speculative.
Krister Stendahl
1 Corinthians 15:29 as real practice
“the text seems to speak plainly enough about a practice within the Church of vicarious baptism for the dead.”
Baptism for the Dead: Ancient Sources, Encyclopedia of Mormonism (1992) · Macmillan · s.v. 'Baptism for the Dead', section 'Ancient Sources' · source
In context: A Harvard New Testament dean judged that 1 Cor 15:29 speaks plainly of a practice of vicarious baptism within the early church, which Paul cites in his argument for the resurrection without condemning it, and that this is the majority view of critical exegetes.
What this does not claim: It shows a historical practice and Paul's non-condemnation, not a command, a universal practice, or the validity of the LDS ordinance; the entry is brief and appeared in an LDS-edited encyclopedia; Stendahl remained a Lutheran.
Caveat
CaveatStendahl read 1 Cor 15:29 as a real practice Paul did not condemn; his 'holy envy' is interfaith admiration, not endorsement. His essay appeared in the Encyclopedia of Mormonism.
Richard B. Hays
Intertextuality: the echoes of scripture
“he merely points out that it is contradictory for the community to practice it…”
First Corinthians (1997) · John Knox Press (Interpretation) · pp. 267-268 · source
In context: Hays's commentary reads 1 Cor 15:29 as evidence that the Corinthian church actually practised vicarious baptism, and notes that Paul cites it to argue for the resurrection without condemning it.
What this does not claim: He does not say Paul instituted, commanded or approved the practice, or that it continued in the church; it is a brief exegetical judgement.
Caveat
CaveatHis readings of 1 Cor 15:29 and Psalm 82 are brief commentary points, not sustained arguments. His last book (2024) affirms same-sex relationships, which differs from Church teaching on marriage.
20

Did early Christians hope for salvation after death for most people?

Topic: Gradations of Glory · 2 scholars
Matthew Thiessen
Gentiles made Abraham's seed through the Spirit
“a whole new generation of sons of God had come and would be coming into existence…”
Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016); A Jewish Paul (2023) · Oxford University Press; Baker Academic · PGP ch. 5, p. 155; AJP ch. 10, p. 126 · source · quotation source
In context: He argues historically that Paul expected Spirit-filled gentiles to become sons of God and to reach full divinity at the resurrection, as star-like heirs of Abraham.
What this does not claim: This is his reconstruction of Paul's first-century cosmology, contested by other Pauline scholars; it does not establish premortal spirit parentage, exaltation or eternal marriage, and Thiessen does not endorse LDS teaching.
Caveat
CaveatThiessen's reading of Paul is his historical reconstruction, and his Stoic-leaning account of the spirit is contested. The pneumatic resurrection body he describes is not flesh and bones.
Ilaria L. E. Ramelli
Age-long, corrective punishment; the dead redeemable
“the future punishment of the wicked is never termed anything but 'aiônios'.”
Terms for Eternity: Aiônios and Aïdios in Classical and Christian Texts (2007), with David Konstan · Gorgias Press · source
In context: She documents that early Christian Greek reserved aïdios ('eternal') for future life and called punishment only aiônios ('of the age'), and that many Fathers treated punishment after death as corrective.
What this does not claim: Her conclusion is universal restoration (possibly including the devil), not Latter-day Saint gradations of glory or sons of perdition; she says nothing about proxy ordinances; critics (McClymond, Pedersen) dispute how widespread the view was.
Caveat
CaveatRamelli's universalism, possibly including the devil, is not Latter-day Saint teaching. McClymond has published a critique of her handling of the evidence.
21

Did early Christians expect a bodily resurrection on a renewed earth?

Topic: Resurrection and new creation · 3 scholars
Jon D. Levenson
Covenant, resurrection and the Hebrew Bible
“Levenson challenges the notion that it was a foreign import into Judaism…”
Resurrection and the Restoration of Israel (2006) · Yale University Press · source
In context: He argues that resurrection of the whole embodied person grows out of the Hebrew Bible's own theology of God's victory over death.
What this does not claim: It does not address universal resurrection of all people, gradations of glory, or eternal marriage; the rabbinic sources he studies expect the righteous to rise.
Caveat
CaveatLevenson writes as a committed Jew and resists Christian claims to Israel's identity; he does not endorse Latter-day Saint teaching. The primordial chaos of Genesis 1 in his reading is not the same as eternal matter.
Brittany E. Wilson
The New Testament's visible, embodied God
“bodies are worthy of the heavenly realm, since Jesus is a human in heaven.”
The Embodied God (2021), 'Beholding the Human One' · Oxford University Press · pp. 231-270 · source
“finds its most concrete expression in the flesh-and-bone body of Jesus”
The Embodied God (2021), 'Visually Verifying the Corporeal Christ' · Oxford University Press · pp. 193-230 · source
In context: She reads Luke's resurrection and ascension accounts as verifying Jesus's flesh and carrying his body into heaven, so bodies are worthy of the heavenly realm.
What this does not claim: Her argument concerns Jesus; it says nothing about exaltation of others, eternal marriage or family.
Caveat
CaveatWilson treats God's body as fluid and multiform, not a body of flesh and bones like ours, and she is not cited for D&C 130:22. Her argument extends Benjamin Sommer's.
David M. Moffitt
Hebrews, resurrection and Christ's heavenly priesthood
“his resurrection, ascension, offering, and exaltation.”
Atonement and the Logic of Resurrection in the Epistle to the Hebrews (2011); Rethinking the Atonement (2022) · Brill; Baker Academic · source
In context: In Hebrews, Christ's bodily resurrection and ascension are the hinge of his saving work; atonement is completed when the risen Jesus presents himself in the heavenly sanctuary.
What this does not claim: He places the atoning offering in heaven, not in Gethsemane, which cuts against the LDS emphasis on Gethsemane and Calvary; and in his account resurrection is the precondition of the offering, whereas 2 Nephi 9 treats it as a result of the atonement.
Caveat
CaveatMoffitt places Christ's atoning offering in heaven after the resurrection, not at Gethsemane or Calvary, and his thesis is contested. His priesthood argument concerns Christ's own priesthood.